Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Like Father, Not Like Son, August 30, 2010
This review is from: Brady, Brady, Brady: The Complete Story of The Brady Bunch as Told by the Father/Son Team who Really Know (Hardcover)
Brady, Brady, Brady: The Complete Story of The Brady Bunch as Told by the Father/Son Team who Really Know, by Sherwood Schwartz and Lloyd J. Schwartz.
Overall, the book was a fun, quick read - it only took me about one night to complete. I've read almost every book on the Brady Bunch and was less than impressed with this one. The book is set up like this: The first half, which really ends up being the first third, is written by Sherwood Schwartz and then the other half, which ends up being the last two thirds is written by his son Lloyd Schwartz. Sherwood Schwartz is professional, talented, and humble and his third of the book comes off that way. His ancedotes about writing the pilot, getting rejected by major networks, casting, production, Robert Reed, etc. are all interesting and fun to read. While most of his stories won't be new to Brady fans (i.e. Robert Reed being difficult, dyeing Mike Lookinland's hair brown) they are at least easy to read, fun, and a reminder of why we love the show so much.
However, while Sherwood's third is professional and humble, Lloyd's Schwartz's portion of the book is everything but. Lloyd comes off as egotistical, arrogant, unprofessional, and untalented. Basically, he seems to spend more time proving to the reader that every memorable line, moment, backstage anecdote, and plot development associated with the series was his idea and less time telling us interesting new stories about the production of the show. He takes credit for everything - including helping Maureen (Marcia) off cocaine. The book advertises as the real in depth look at the show, but apprently that means listening to Lloyd pontificate about he was the youngest asoociate producer to work in television etc. etc. It all ends up being more of a testimonial to himself than the beloved show he worked on. Also, his thoughts on Robert Reed are awful. While I'm sure he was a difficult person to deal with Sherwood at least comments on Reed in a professional manor by exposing his flaws but also pointing out his talents. Lloyd speaks of Reed as if he's a piece of dirt under his finger nail and it comes off as disgusting and unprofessional.
The last part of Lloyd's section covers all the reunion and spinoffs including the motion pictures and the stage musical. These are so brief they're hardly worth a read - with a page or less on each production he barely skims the surface telling us brady fanatics no new information.
I recommend the book with an asterisk. Only because I enjoyed Sherwood's section and also found some of the anecdotes in Lloyd's amusing. But if you're a real Brady fanactic it won't offer up much new information. Except maybe that Lloyd Schwartz has an enormous head. Having said that, most Brady fanactis (like myself) are completeist when it comes to the show and will go ahead and buy the book anyway. But if you're a semi-brady fan do yourself a favor and pick up "Growing Up Brady" by Barry Williams, Maureen McCormick's newer biography, or one of the many fan-written books on the show. They are much more interesting reads all around.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Sometimes Brady FANS know better..., December 30, 2010
This review is from: Brady, Brady, Brady: The Complete Story of The Brady Bunch as Told by the Father/Son Team who Really Know (Hardcover)
This is going to be fun. Just finished the Schwartz's book. As a Brady fan, a fast read, some new insights gained, but I would like to challenge Lloyd Schwartz's memory a bit, maybe a lot. Lloyd writes, "Other books have been written about the Brady Bunch, ironically some by 'experts' who weren't there and had no real inside knowledge (though they claim to know the truth). Even Barry Williams (Greg Brady)..." And thus Lloyd seems to set himself up as the authority. He even told Barry Williams, "Just because you wrote it down and its on paper doesn't mean it's the truth," (p.113). How true. Here's where the fun begins. Lloyd may be the authority on the production side of things, but his memory is a little faulty when it comes to episodes. He tells a story of the show where Mike and Carol switch places for the day, Mike taking the girls and helping Marcia in the kitchen and Carol playing ball with the boys in the backyard. He says they put Florence henderson in one of her typical blouses for the scene in the backyard and she told Lloyd that it wasn't right, she should be wearing one of her husbands old shirts. So Lloyd took his short sleeve button up shirt off and stood there bare-chested as Florence donned his shirt and did the scene. Every die hard Brady fan knows that Florence was not wearing a button up short sleeve shirt in that scene, but comes running out in a long sleeve dark green sweatshirt. (I believe Lloyd's shirt was in the episode where the girls are building their own clubhouse).
Another discrepancy is when Lloyd recalls the episode where Jan is allergic to Tiger and they have to give him away. He claimed because the original Tiger was hit by a car, they had to use the "last minute" Tiger for the goodbye scene in the boys' bedroom, but the dog wouldn't stay put, so they nailed his collar to the ground so he wouldn't move. Again, true fans know that in that scene, the boys actually give Tiger a bone to chew on while they say their goodbye's and there is no evidence of the dog's collar being nailed to the floor. He's chomping away in the whole scene and the dialogue even lends to that.
In mentioning real people's names that were incorporated into scripts, he says the name "Hank Coleman" was mentioned in an episode and was a guy who had a crush on Marcia or Jan. Actually, it goes down like this: The girls are playing Truth or Dare at the slumber party and Paula asks Ruthie if she's ever been kissed by Hank Coleman, "Truth or dare?"
In the infamous "Oh, my nose!" episode, Lloyd says Greg and Peter were throwing the football around when Marcia got hit in the nose with the ball. It was actually Peter and Bobby, not Greg.
And then he mentions the episode where Greg and Peter divide up their room by running a piece of tape across the middle of the room. Again, that was Peter and Bobby.
So, you're right, Mr Schwartz, just because it's written down and in a book doesn't mean it's true (wink wink). This is all so trivial, I know, but when it comes to Brady trivia, you gotta leave it to the fans!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not bad, but nothing really to write home about..., November 29, 2010
This review is from: Brady, Brady, Brady: The Complete Story of The Brady Bunch as Told by the Father/Son Team who Really Know (Hardcover)
While there are some very interesting little tidbits here and there, overall, this book is VERY light on information and reads VERY quickly. I was reading along, and before I knew it, I was almost done with the book. There really isn't much to this book, there are wide spaces between the lines, and lots of the chapters are very short (making for many, MANY half-full pages, when the chapter ends before the bottom of the page.) The anecdotes sound like they're going to be interesting (how did Peter learn to do the Bogart impersonation) but when its explained, its quick and not all that interesting. Not very in-depth, nor do they spend much time explaining things, the things all of us Brady-philes are waiting to hear!
As other reviewers have stated, there are also LOTS of "clapping himself on the back" from Lloyd Schwartz. The first part of the book is very nice (albeit simple, see above) from Sherwood Schwartz. Once it shifts to the Lloyd Schwartz part, there really is a lot of self-congratulations about what an incredible talent LLOYD SCHWARTZ is, and what a jerk Robert Reed was. Something tells me there are two sides to the Lloyd Schwartz/Bob Reed debate. I think this was a case of two egos colliding, to be honest. :)
Regardless its a nice read, very quick, and has some nice insight...but really, when its billed as the "Complete Story" as told by those who 'REALLY know'...I expected a LOT more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|