20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Inspirationaltransition story, September 1, 2004
This review is from: Branded T (Paperback)
Here is an unusual book. In simple terms, it is a personal transsexual experience. But it is so much more. It is the story of the transsexual experience on the streets of New York from the early 1970s through the beginning of the new millennium. It is the story of the sleazy side of New York during the same period, seen through the eyes and experiences of a transsexual. And, it is an inspirational story of a courageous transsexual person surviving the streets to become a highly-respected professional social worker and political activist.
Rosalyne Blumenstein was identified male at birth. She was introduced to shame by five years old when she dressed female with dress-up clothes provided in kindergarten. She left school and home at age 13, and spent the majority of her next 18 years working in New York's famous (infamous?) sex industry. She experienced life on the street as a prostitute, drug user, and peep-show girl.
Then she overcame her drug addiction. She returned to the peep show business clean for another seven years, supporting herself through college and graduate school with her earnings and scholarships. She was an early participant in the Gender Identity Project within Mental Health and Social Services at the Lesbian and Gay Community Services Center of New York. By March 1996, she became the first ever Director of the project.
The book is somewhat disjointed, making it difficult to read straight through. It is best read in segments, and is organized in a way to facilitate reading in that fashion. Life on the streets and in the clubs is related in great and intimate detail. Some will find both the language and discussions offensive, but it reflects the environment where Ms. Blumenstein spent much of her life. No one without this experience can really understand what it was like or what strength and courage it required to survive and overcome it.
As a volunteer at the Center, Ms. Blumenstein realized how out of touch she was without a formal education. She also realized that most of those she worked with were truly out of touch without her informal (street) education. Her collegiate success built on her transsexual experience to make her uniquely-qualified for her varied mental health and social services, especially for the marginalized members of our gender communities.
"This book is about pain, it's about celebration, it's about taking risks, its about going crazy, and it's about being fabulous and adventurous" It is an inspirational success story of a young woman originally designated male overcoming this incorrect designation, overcoming drug and alcohol abuse, and overcoming her life on the streets of New York to become a leader in HIV/AIDS prevention, education and outreach to all LGBT, and many other services to various marginalized communities.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Rosalyne Blumenstein's Secret Journey, November 16, 2003
I knew Roz Blumenstein during the 1990s, when she was Director of the Gender Identity Project of the Gay & Lesbian Community Center of New York. I didn't know, until she asked me to read a pre-release copy of her book Branded T, that she was simultaneously working in the peep shows on Broadway. In print, I saw a different side of Ms. Blumenstein-- a side that was struggling with issues of self-worth and self-discovery. I had thought she had it SO together!
It takes great courage to tell the world of our secret struggles, our insecurities, our private fears, our little pockets of craziness. Ms. Blumenstein has that courage. She has given us a book that transcends her gender issue and speaks to the human spirit. As one reviewer at Amazon has said, it's sad, and funny, too. It's an amazing read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unflinching bravery, May 2, 2005
This review is from: Branded T (Paperback)
Transsexual autobiographies often tend to recount events and experiences, but rarely do they delve deeply into the underlying issues. Such is not the case with this fine book, which gives a glimpse of what it was like to transition on the urban streets in the bad old days (which sadly hasn't changed much in the ensuing decades).
The reason I recommend this book so highly is not just the style or the thoughtfulness Rosalyne has put into this, but also because it shows that there is a way out of even terribly hopeless situations. We can stop the downward spiral of despair and self-medication, of anger and self-hatred, but it requires introspection, support, and most of all perseverance. I wish every drop-in house and shelter that services young trans clients living on the street and/or engaged in survival sex had this book available. Rosalyne is a survivor, and her example can give others strength in moments of weakness or times of great adversity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No