From School Library Journal
Grade 2-4 - This colorfully illustrated version of a little-known story from the early history of ancient Rome tells of a girl who was one of the hostages given to the Etruscan king as part of a treaty. When Cloelia plotted an escape with some of her friends, the king demanded that she return to honor the agreement. She agreed, gaining the admiration of King Larth, who granted her the opportunity to select other hostages to return home with her. Cloelia's courage and daring were acknowledged by the city of Rome with the casting of a statue in her honor. Whether actual history or a legend, this is an inspiring tale of a brave young heroine and would be a useful addition to Roman history collections. The text is well written, and the handsome, richly colored, full-page illustrations successfully depict the action and setting.
- Cynthia M. Sturgis, Ledding Library, Milwaukie, OR Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 2-4, younger for reading aloud. Because King Larth and the Etruscan soldiers have besieged Rome and demanded 200 hostages, Cloelia and her family are sent to the Etruscan camp. Two nights later, Cloelia leads a group of girls who escape from the guards and swim across the River Tiber, back to Rome. When King Larth demands her return, Cloelia goes with dignity and wins not only his respect but also the release of 40 more hostages. Perhaps historical, perhaps legendary, this story is based on Livy's
The History of Early Rome, which was written several centuries after the events described. Though the opening paragraphs setting up the situation in the Etruscan camp are a bit stilted and confusing, the rest of the story reads well. Some of the colorful illustrations feature pleasing scenes and sensitive portrayals of individuals, while others seem stiff and idealized. The ancient Roman setting makes this picture book for older children a natural for schools with a classical curriculum, though consider it a secondary choice for the target audience.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved