From Publishers Weekly
The creators of True Heart once again laud a historical heroine with gentle restraint. Here they give pilot Harriet Quimby just the right note of quiet confidence: "I hadn't grown up wishing to be a pilot, because there were no planes when I was a girl, but once I saw one, I knew where I belonged there, at the controls, with blue sky all around me." Harriet wins her license from a skeptical board ("No woman has ever received a license to fly," a licensing official says), works as a barnstormer, then conceives the idea of crossing the English Channel. Her pilot friend Gustav Hamel tries to dissuade her, offering to fly for her in disguise; Harriet refuses. She completes her mission, but the sinking of the Titanic on the same day overshadows news of her success. "But it didn't matter, because I knew I had done it," she says. Payne's spreads resemble period photographs stop-action shots of wood-framed airplanes taken from striking angles, a newsboy reading the headlines about the Titanic and Harriet looking wistfully across the Channel, her skirt billowing in the wind. Pair this with Julie Cummins's Tomboy of the Air (Children's Forecasts, July 2) for a complete picture of the first women pilots. Ages 6-9.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
K-Gr 3-American Harriet Quimby was the first woman to pilot a plane over the English Channel. Unfortunately, this potential headliner was pushed into obscurity by a bigger event that took place at the same time-the sinking of the Titanic. Moss tells the aviator's story using a fictionalized, first-person narrative. The mixed-media depictions are large and inviting and fit in well with the setting and feel of the story. The cover shot shows Quimby competently piloting her plane. Her contemplation of the glory that might have been, if not for the tragedy of the Titanic, is sensitively portrayed on the last page where she is shown looking off into the horizon. An appended author's note hints at her death in a tragic air mishap. However, the focus here is on her adventuresome spirit. While not an essential purchase, this exciting story will find an audience especially among youngsters who enjoyed David A. Adler's A Picture Book of Amelia Earhart (Holiday, 1998).
Anne Chapman Callaghan, Racine Public Library, WI
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
