5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Banal Attempt at Self-Pity, July 1, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Breaking Apart : A Memoir of Divorce
I have a problem with books like this. Although the world certainly has an overabundance of people with "problems" that can neither be ignored nor assumed to simply patch themselves up over time, it seems rather unfortunate that Ms. Swallow has determined to openly flay her ex-husband (in and of itself a rather cold, heartless, and calculated move against someone who - according to Ms. Swallow herself - does not have the emotional capacity to defend or redeem himself) as well as display her children's trauma to the world.
There are reasons for the psychological and psychiatric professions. I'm going to safely bet that if going through a painful divorce, it would be much more cathartic (and much more advantageous for the family as a whole) to actually visit a professional of some sort, rather than attempt to self-diagnose and engage in the "woe is me" fest that books like this represent.
There is nothing even remotely helpful in Ms. Swallow's book - unless you find it helpful to have yet another example of the self-absorbtion of many divorced parents.
Ms. Swallow's children will eventually grow up - when they do, I can only hope that they will seek professional guidance, rather than following in their mother's footsteps and foisting more atrociously self-serving writing onto us all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Emotional Rubble........., April 22, 2001
This review is from: Breaking Apart : A Memoir of Divorce
My own divorce experience is rather different from
Ms. Swallow's. Instead of an active participant, as she was, I was a
13 year old child in the center of a nasty divorce. Now 3 years later,
I can look back into it with eyes that are slightly less emotional,
but until a week ago, their own feelings, however torrential and
visable, were something of a mystery to me.
Until I read Breaking
Apart. As I opened the book, it was a mystery to me. Why I read the
book is something of a mystery to me, as memoirs have often struck me
as an indulgent genre, the chicken fried steak of literature. But as
my eyes darted into and through the book (I read its 352 pages in
about 1.5 hours), something clarified within me. Through
Ms. Swallows's clear, engaging prose, I learned what it meant to go
through divorce as an participant. The sorrow of being torn apart from
your partner dawned upon me. The similarties between a childs and a
wives divorce experiences shocked me. I remembered, as did swallow,
the feelings of destruction of yourself, that you are dust in a cruel
world. It is a beautiful, powerful book. ...
Please press the little
"order the book" button to get this deeply mooving
memoir. Even if you have never been subjected to the perticular
ravages of divorce, read it to learn something about the world, read
it because it is beautifully written, read it because it is a powerful
book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Placing the Blame, June 30, 2003
As a divorced father of two, I tried to share the author's pain as she slowly delves into her own experiences. However, as I read chapter after chapter, I found out more about her own emotional problems than her husband's supposed ones. How could any good mother publicly denigrate the character of her children's father? One day her poor sons will realize how she put their pain on display in order to satisfy her fear that she was as much responsibile for the failure of her marriage as her husband.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No