28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This first book in a 7-book series is a household treasure., October 12, 1999
By A Customer
I have kept this book and its 6 successors in my family library for many years. My daughter recently announced that the series was the most enjoyable she read as a teenager, a comment which caused her younger brother to begin to read the series, and me to reread them. Almost two decades after encountering them the first time, this was again an enjoyable read.
Arriving at this review opportunity was the result of searching for possible successors to the series. Unfortunately, none seem to exist.
The series is well-written, with good character development. The reader immediately identifies with the rugged individualism of the book's central characters, and mourns their eventual passing. An enjoyable diversion is to try to determine, on a current map of the United States, the sites mentioned in the book, and to determine how and why they come to be different in 31st century Urstadge.
I recommend this series for teenage children and adult readers. Although there is violence, it is not graphic, and there is no gratuitous sex. There is an emphasis upon values which are no longer as clearly evident in America as they once were -- a designed irony for these books set in the post-3000 millenium.
You will want to read the books in the order of their printing, and if possible to read them in tandem with your children:
Book 1: The Breaking of Northwall
Book 2: The Ends of the Circle
Book 3: The Dome in the Forest
Book 4: The Fall of the Shell
Book 5: An Ambush of Shadows
Book 6: The Song of the Axe
Book 7: The Sword of Forbearance
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hard to start but then impossible to put down, March 8, 2004
By A Customer
Initially, I had a similar experience as the reviewer from Arizona: I tried literally 3 times to read this book but thought it was just too obtuse to figure out. But because Prof. Williams was my wife's English professor and advisor at college, and she held him in such high regard, I took another try. This time I stayed with it long enough and found that though the beginning didn't offer the quick action thrill of the start of the Star Wars movies, it led to a work that was far more substantial and satisfying in the long run than most anything else I've read.
I tend to like book series and rate them among my favorites because of character development, well developed and intriguing story lines or both. The Pelbar Cycle delivers both and is on the short list of books I've read more than once because of the messages and actions they contain. I had an opportunity to tell Prof. Williams how much I enjoyed this series, and why, and he seemed surprised that someone would talk to him about it. Humble man, very good writer.
My oldest son has read the series and liked it, now my youngest son is reading it and I may just read along with him so we can compare notes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lyrical, insightful, October 19, 1999
This book the the first in a series name The Pelbar Cycle. There are two reviews here already that talk about William's subject material, and I only wanted to add that he occasionally writes as a poet would. His discriptive, evocative style is one which draws the reader into his creation in both the physical and the emotional. Some of his characters possess an unassuming strength that I have not encountered in other author's work, and I feel very strongly that Williams has been shelved by other readers because of the genre he has chosen. Read The Pelbar Cycle, its seven books avoid repetition but maintain continunity. They are an extremely talented piece of work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
