Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A tale so true for idealistic untrained teachers, November 11, 2003
This review is from: Brief Intervals of Horrible Sanity: One Season in a Progressive School (Hardcover)
Elizabeth Gold's book made me laugh so hard with intense recognition of my own experience on every page. I couldn't put it down for two days (very rare for me). I was a similar overeducated idealistic substitute teacher, who in the middle of the year, was placed in charge of an urban Oakland CA eighth grade ESL classroom (the previous teacher had had a nervous breakdown in the middle of class and left abruptly, leaving her students wondering where she had gone). Ms. Gold's description of the difficulty of managing such a classroom with no classroom management skills, no consequences for the student misbehavior, no support from senior administration, insufficient books/materials for her students, no curriculum, etc, etc were painfully similar and accurate to my experience. The teacher I had replaced was a "Teach for America" teacher, the best and brightest of college grads who have been placed in urban schools with 6 weeks of teacher training. Teaching in an urban school is one of the hardest jobs there is, and it takes professional, emotional, and material support to make it happen successfully. I've gone on to get my teaching credential and to realize how many more years it is going to take to become a master teacher. Elizabeth Gold is a brilliant writer and observer of urban education and its shortcomings and contradictions, and her insights of her four months teaching more than make up for her four months of inadequate "teaching" (which includes managing her classroom which she obviously couldn't manage at all).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
finally! a terrific memoir!, October 8, 2003
This review is from: Brief Intervals of Horrible Sanity: One Season in a Progressive School (Hardcover)
I love a great memoir and I have been combing the shelves for one for months: devils wearing Prada, people climbing Everest, etc etc and I can say for sure they've got NOTHING on Elizabeth Gold. My hat is off to her, not only because she did what many of us underemployed New Yorkers have thought we SHOULD do, that is, teaching in the NYC public school system: she took the experience and wrote a HEARTBREAKING and HILARIOUS memoir about it. One of my favorite passages is when she's lost total control of the class (VERY early on) and she thinks she's seen it all, until 2 students are about to begin necking ARDENTLY, right before her very eyes, (page 43): "Please, please, I pray, don't let them kiss, I don't want to tell them to unglue those lips, and Tongues, Buster, Are Not For Sharing, but the other part of me is thinking, why not kiss? Who am I to interfere with young love, if that's what it is? Why don't I push a couple of desks together in the back and throw a sheet over them, light some mood candles (though they really don't need mood candles), toss over a pack of cigarettes for after, why don't I make myself useful?" I was doubled over laughing and when I wiped my eyes I thought "wait a minute: these are my fellow New Yorkers in these schools. These are supposed to be the Leaders of Tomorrow! Boy, are we in trouble". Gold leaves us forewarned: what's going on in the inner city schools is terrifying. It seems like the problem is far too complex for quick-fix solutions. These kids are angry (as Elizabeth hilariously testifies), and they have good reason to be. They have nothing to say but "I Hate Elizabeth" when she tries to teach them Romeo and Juliet, but ask them about Amadou Diallo and they have plenty of opinions. The book is funny, but it leaves you thinking about racism and inequities in education.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Miscategorized Memoir, October 21, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Brief Intervals of Horrible Sanity: One Season in a Progressive School (Hardcover)
This memoir of one writer's experience teaching in Queens, NY is not, as the book is marketed, about education. Instead, it is about a new teacher's experience within the New York City education system, and about her students and fellow teachers. As that, it works. With wit and candor, the memoir details the writer's encounters with a system on the verge of spiraling out of control.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|