Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Bright Not Broken: Gifted Kids, ADHD, and Autism Hardcover – September 13, 2011
|New from||Used from|
Elsevier Sales & Deals
Save up to 50% on textbooks, study guides & resources for your medical specialty.
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
"This book addresses an important, under discussed topic, supporting children with social and attention problems but who have good cognitive skills. With discussion of who they are and why they end up stuck and frustrated, this highly readable book fills an important need."
-- Fred R Volkmar, MD, Director, Yale Child Study Center
This book is essential for parents and professionals. It is both theoretical, practical and creatively updates thinking on autism spectrum disorders. In our experience change in the field only happens when parents campaign which these authors are doing with such enthusiasm.
Dr. Lorna Wing and Judith Gould, PhD
The National Autistic Society
"A work of tremendous scholarship and passion that deserves to be a seminal and paradigm-shifting work. It should be read by all parents of gifted children with coexistent disabilities--and the professionals who work with them."
William Sheehan, MD, Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health Services, Willmar, MN
"This book is an outstanding analysis of the flaws in the educational and psychiatric approaches to children's challenges. It gave me excellent insight into my more challenging cases and has had a profound impact on my personal and professional life."
Ruth Goldberg, PhD, clinical and school psychologist, mother of three 2e children
"Bright Not Broken is a unique resource for parents and professionals who seek to understand children's behaviors. The authors are to be applauded for their clear-thinking approach to the jungle of DSM labels--a must read for the open minded!"
Lydia Furman, MD, Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital, Cleveland OH
"This book is truly inspiring and it shows that by simply changing our perception of these children, and then the testing and education that stems from that perception, we can help them become successful, contributing adults." (psychcentral.com, March 13th, 2012)
From the Inside Flap
Bright Not Broken sheds new light on this vibrant population by identifying who twice-exceptional children are and taking an unflinching look at why they're stuck. The first work to boldly examine the widespread misdiagnosis and controversies that arise from our current diagnostic system, it serves as a wake-up call for parents and professionals to question why our mental health and education systems are failing our brightest children.
Most important, the authors show what we can do to help 2e children, providing a whole child model for parents and educators to strengthen and develop a child's innate gifts while also intervening to support the deficits. Drawing on painstaking research and personal experience, Bright Not Broken offers groundbreaking insight and practical strategies to those seeking to help 2e kids achieve their full potential.
Top Customer Reviews
The reason I got this book is that my child has already gone through plenty of testing, and it's become apparent to me that he fits this taxonomy. I suspect many, many others do. So I don't need repetitive chapters describing the type. I know the type. I live with the type. I probably *myself* fit the type. I got that. And our IEP team (fortunately) gets it too - but what we need are specific solutions that we can sell to the educators who implement the IEP. And anyone who has dealt with their IEP team and school knows, most the great ideas in the IEP meeting don't get implemented, and the ones that do, most don't get implemented properly, and of those, even less are measured. So platitudes and directional guidance are of little use. When it comes to special education, school districts love to live in the world of platitudes and no accountability because it's easier for them.Read more ›
This book goes into many different learning disabilities and disorders. I'm not sure its a cure-all if that is what you are looking for. Instead, its a different way of looking at kids with learning disabilities or on the spectrum. There is so much negativity and this books sheds a new view on these kids. For that, its well worth the read.
Of course, as I began reading this, I teared up because I finally felt like someone understood what it was like to deal with the doctors and school systems. It's been a long and emotional road for us, but I think finally, we're on the right track. This book gives practical and encouraging advice and realizes that our systems aren't perfect, but there are additional things that can be done to help if you have the means. For us, we figured out a rewards system for the oldest. He does well in school, but refuses to do homework, so his grades are usually close to failing. He learns best by teaching himself (reading and hands-on) and we found, after discussing it over with him, that he would agree to do the homework that he finds an utter waste of time if we'd let him study on his own in advanced fields by allowing him to order textbooks and programs that he was interested in, mainly 3-D rendering and computer programming. It's working well so far, but it took some close monitoring in the beginning. He also has started repairing computers and game systems in his free time.
We're in the process of having the younger sibling evaluated now, and hoping to get an IEP in place for her. There are a great many ideas for younger children included, and I wish we would have had this book around when my older Aspie was younger. I have high hopes for her IEP, and I feel armed with information this time around!
I've always felt that ADHD is a bit of a "junk" diagnosis that lumps together children with many different underlying issues, including some who are just highly gifted & bored with the slow pace of the typical heterogeneous classroom. After reading "Bright Not Broken", I fully believe that a significant number of children with Asperger's Syndrome do, in fact, wind up mislabeled as ADHD. The authors are convincing in their argument that this mislabeling can result in less effective or even down right inappropriate treatment.
Where I found the book much less convincing, however, was the authors' position that ADHD and AS are "indistinguishable in their symptoms, deficits, and characteristics" and both conditions present "identical social, communication, and executive function impairments, as well as identical attention and oppositional behaviors." I don't think this is actually the case. I know people with attention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity issues who do not at all show signs of having difficulty with non-verbal communication or emotional reciprocity. In fact, I know several who are "life of the party" types and impulsively showing off for peers without thinking through the potential consequences of their actions is part of their executive function impairment. Whatever is going on with them, it isn't AS.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
This wasn't exactly what I was hoping for. There is lots of information about how these kids get lost in the shuffle, but it's really light on what we can do to help. Read morePublished 23 days ago by Katheryn Lowrance
As someone in the mental health field, it described medical terminology at nauseam that I already know.... really took away from the contentPublished 1 month ago by Keri
Society have focused on children with the learn problems. And not enough on the talent. They focuses on the weaken and try to strengthen it. While their gifted and talent . Read morePublished 1 month ago by Amazon Customer
I wish I had trusted the lower star reviews.
1) As another review said, much of this book is railing against the old classification system. The DSM-5 is out. Read more
This book confirms what I have thought for some years now. A disservice is being done to our children who are being given 'an alphabet soup list of letters' behind their names... Read morePublished 11 months ago by Jean Klier
I'm determined to finish this book because I did spend the money to buy it, after all. And perhaps I'm hoping there will be some redeeming information to justify its purchase. Read morePublished 11 months ago by Mosquitohawk