5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lovely, September 15, 2006
This review is from: Brother Juniper (Hardcover)
This is a great story about a generous friar. I love especially how it doesn't try to be politically correct about the reality of the Franciscans; the book includes tasteful pictures of a naked Brother Juniper who gave the robe off his back. It's refreshing to read quality kids' books.
Further, I don't know why Amazon is describing this as a baby/preschool book. I'd say it's perfect for kids starting around age 4 but continuing on into older elementary ages as well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Sacred and the Slightly Profane, February 12, 2007
This review is from: Brother Juniper (Hardcover)
Introduction
Juniper is one of sever friars who lived with the renowned patron of animals, Father Francis (later, Saint Francis) of Assisi. ALl of them are pious and poor, but Brother Juniper seems different from the otehrs. While he's generous, good, and simple, some of his brothers:
"...thought he was silly." This was because Brother Juniper was often naked. IF somebody asked for his robe, Brother Juniper would gladly give it to him. Even if it was a cold day. Even if it was snowing."
Scandalous
Talented water colorist Meilo So, does her job and illustrates the naked Brother Juniper, exposing all of his backside with two curved lines. It's very vague, and from a distance, but there you have it. Grammar sticklers have undoubtedly already noticed that "If it was a cold day" should be "If it were a cold day." Don't say you weren't warned.
Generous to a Fault
ONe day Assisi and the friars leave Juniper alone, although they're worried about his extreme generosity. At first, Brother Juniper is quite occupied with a friar's many duties, including praying, polishing golden candlesticks, mending brocaded vestments, and scrubbing the stained glass windows. Soon, however, villagers arrive at the monastery, one after another, each with a tale of poverty, disease, or hunger. The ever-generous Brother finds a material solution for them, giving away valuable church artifacts to help them get by (and, he's naked again--the cleaning woman was cold...).
Many 'F's in a Row
When Francis and the friars return, the friars are furious. For example, Brother Bernard cries, "You have ruined our church." Brother Pietro, more thoughtfully, asks, "Where will we worship?" There's a hole where the church should be.
The Moral Lesson
Brother Juniper is so sad that he stays in hiding until Sunday, when he yells "DING, DING, DING" to call the villagers to church. (He had given away the bell.) When they come, the friars see that their Brother's generosity is more than repaid--in the size of the congregation, and the smiles on their faces. Father Francis is very pleased, observing that Brother Jumiper has actually built the church, not destroyed it.
Thoughts on the Book
Although the story has a religious base, it's interesting that the problems and solutions are so rooted in the material--in goods that can be exchanged for money. One may view this as refreshingly realistic. It also gets around any church-state separation issues that might bar this book from public schools. Other than Father Francis' implicit statement that one's service to others makes a church (not stones, stained glass, and gold), the focus is on money. "The Rainbow Fish" presents a similar possession-based stance, yet a surprising number of Amazon reviewers somehow view "Fish" as a Communist manifesto!
The book includes a brief afterwards about Saint Francis and the tales collected in "The Little Flowers of St. Francis." I enjoyed "Brother Juniper" for its originality, depiction of monastery life, and the expressive, open watercolors by Meilo So.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
