Customer Reviews

The Brothers Grimm [Blu-ray]

5 star:		(35)
4 star:		(61)
3 star:		(62)
2 star:		(53)
1 star:		(64)

 

 

I've heard a few people say they were disappointed after seing this film; they had expected better. I think a lot of people have the wrong expectations when it comes to The Brothers Grimm: in the theatre I see lots of people of whom I can tell from moment one they will be disappointed.

Mothers with young children who actually think this movie has anything to do with the traditional fairy tales; this movie is NOT for children! If I were 7 I'd wet my bed for days after seing The Brothers Grimm. Young boys and girls on dates, all expecting an easy digestive romcom with an obvious storyline and no depth (I don't know how they got there but they did). That is NOT the case. If you want Finding Nemo, go see Finding Nemo. If you want American Pie, go see American Pie. But don't complain about The Brothers Grimm, because it is an absolute masterpiece!

The storyline is entertaining (one of the few movies that doesn't make you go "when's the intermission already? I need to pee!"), the director paints an amazing picture with his brilliant set, the characters are adorable and the actors do an amazing job. There wasn't a moment I saw them acting instead of being. One thing that really caught my attention was the role of Angelika (by Lena Heady) which reminded me in every single way of Keira Knightley's version of Guinevere in King Arthur - in a good way though.

Overall, I think this movie is a serious tribute to the fantasy genre, and I think that people who can appreciate that will love this. Don't look for logic, don't look for unexpected plots like in The Village and The Others, don't expect American Pie jokes and FOR GOD'S SAKE don't take your little children with you to this movie.

This is a brilliant movie that can hold it's own and if you ask me it deserves lots and lots of attention and awards.

YOU WILL LIKE THIS MOVIE IF YOU LIKE... Sleepy Hollow (with Johnny Depp and Christina Ricci), King Arthur (with Clive Owen and Keira Knightley), Pirates of the Caribbean (with Johnny Depp and Orlando Bloom).

I recently heard someone say they were disappointed with Gilliam's "update" of the Famous Brothers and their Fables. Whoever said that doesn't understand Gilliam's modus operandi. He is a genius at creating brand new worlds(Time Bandits and Brazil) and Bringing old Folktales and fantasy stories back to their roots while still making them entertaining(Baron Munchausen).

The same is true of the Brothers Grimm. He offers a unique spin on Red Riding Hood, Hansel and Gretel, and quite distinctly the Gingerbead Man, but at the same time retains the essence of the original stories. Fariy Tales are DARK! They were meant to frighten Children into BEHAVING!

I also appreciated the emphasis on Character. With the Exception of Peter Stormare's hammy torturer, the Cast is Excellent. Matt Damon is always good, but Heath Ledger Steals the film with his portrayal of Jacob Grimm. And of course Jonathan Pryce is always enjoyable.

My biggest complaint though is a rather nasty scene involving a kitten. Gilliam can at times have an extremely nasty sense of humor and this was particularly unpleasant.

Gilliam's films are not for all tastes I confess. But I thouroughly enjoyed this film. I'll never look at the gingerbread man the same way again.

The Brothers Grimm is a suspenseful light-hearted ghost story in the cinematic tradition of such movies as Pirates of the Caribbean, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, and Sleepy Hollow. The brothers, played by Heath Ledger and Matt Damon, couldn't be more enchanting in their roles in this fairy tale movie. Jacob, played by spectacle toting Heath Ledger, is the lovable underdog, an impractical poet who wears his gold heart on his sleeve. Wilhelm of course, couldn't be more different as the devilishly dashing woman-chasing lead and older brother.

The film is set in French occupied Germany and is quite amusing for history buffs. There, Jacob and Wilhelm have a run in with the French army. They've roamed from town to town making up fairy tales, but not only in the story sense! Jacob largely follows Wilhelm around documenting the folk tales of the various villages they weave their `magic' around. When they are captured, the scenes involving the French general (Jonathan Pryce) are classically macabre in every sense- I don't want to spoil any surprises so you'll have to see the movie to find out why. Caravaldi, a captain in that army, played by Peter Stormare, becomes a permanant pest and an unexpected side-kick. The character is completely absurd with an Italian accent, hilarious yet creepy.

With Caravaldi, the brothers find themselves embroiled in a real mystery when all the girls in the village disappear. The townsfolk are strange but the boys eventually warm up to the female lead, Angelika (Lena Headey) who leads them through the forest and tells them of the folk tales of her youth. There's a little bit of that fairy tale magic mixed in with some European folklore which makes the movie interesting from an anthropological perspective... it makes you wonder what our folktales say of our history. The movie makes us imagine that these fairy or folk tales were real events, documented faithfully by the trusting Jacob. And there in the forest the brothers discover the truth behind the girls' disappearance, the connection with Angelika's missing father, and a wolf that has terrorized the forest.

The Brothers Grimm is spooky and maybe a little scary/disturbing for young children but don't see the movie expecting a thriller- after all the movie is based on Grimm's fairytales. It's a lot of fun trying to guess which fairy tale is being alluded to in the various scenes as the Brothers seek to rid village of their haunting. And it is interesting how the movie weaves each story into another. There are great questions as to what is real and what is not... is it supernatural, a trick, magic?

Magic there is, and chemistry too for sure in this entertaining movie. Lovers of fairy tales and ghost stories alike will find themselves falling in love with The Brothers Grimm! Hopefully, the DVD or movie will be out for Halloween.

Renowned director/screenwriter, Terry Gilliam, brought the tale, featuring the two legendary authors, Jacob (Heath Ledger) and Wilhelm (Matt Damon) Grimm, to the screen in 2005's "The Brothers Grimm".

The movie starts by introducing us to the brothers as young children in the late 1700s when it's discovered that Jacob, (played by Jeremy Robson in this scene) has sold the family's cow for a handful of magic beans. Several years later the two brothers have grown into men who travel from town to town throughout Germany getting rid of unsavory creatures who seem to be plaguing the towns. However, it's soon realized that the pair, along with a couple of friends, are con artists who have constructed everything from the evil characters (in one case a witch) to the elaborate "rescue" of the town.

Napoleon's General, Delatombe, (Jonathan Pryce) is not pleased. When he threatens to execute the two brothers, Jacob and Wilhelm have no choice but to travel to Marbaden and solve the mystery behind the disappearance of several of the village's children. With Cavaldi (Peter Stormare), one of Delatombe's henchmen, to keep an eye on them, the brothers meet Angelika (Lena Headley), who agrees to escort them into the nearby forest. The group soon finds the tower that legend says is home to the Mirror Queen (Monica Bellucci) and who has great powers over the forest. But is the legend true? What other secrets does the forest hold and how do they connect to the disappearance of the children?

Terry Gilliam has directed and/or co-wrote a number of films including "Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas" (1998), "Brazil" (1985), "Time Bandits" (1981) and several of the Monty Python features. "The Brothers Grimm" was one of those films that I had high hopes for and really wanted to like it a lot. However, the movie, while good in some parts, seems to be lacking in others.

There were two things I especially liked about "The Brothers Grimm". The film was visually appealing. The way it was shot was reminiscent of "Sleepy Hollow". I also liked the way that familiar stories from the Grimm brothers were incorporated into the movie; for example "Jack and the Beanstalk", "Little Red Riding Hood" and a little bit of "Hansel and Gretel".

The idea of the two Grimm brothers as con artists traveling from town to town, swindling people out of their money by exorcising fake creatures, until they come across the real thing was great. Unfortunately, the movie seems to stray from this and eventually gets scattered in several directions with the brothers in situations with Delatombe, Cavaldi and the Mirror Queen as well as a side story about Angelika and her family. Don't be surprised if you find yourself exhausted from trying to keep up with everything that's going on! (You wouldn't believe how hard it was coming up with the movie summary above!)

I did like Heath Ledger's and Matt Damon's take on the two brothers. But I felt that the characters could have been developed more. We really don't get to know a lot about them. Perhaps a little more insight into their backgrounds would have made the characters more compelling. Also the possible romance with Angelika just didn't go anywhere.

While I have liked Jonathan Pryce's and Peter Stormare's previous works (Pryce was Governor Swann in "Pirates of the Caribbean" (2003) and Stormare appeared in "Chocolat" (2000) and "Armageddon" (1998)), I felt their characters were somewhat shallow, bordering on annoying. A lot of screen time also isn't given to the evil Mirror Queen who is supposed to be the Grimm's main opponent. Maybe without the Delatombe and Cavaldi side story, more time could have been spent on developing the character of the Mirror Queen, letting everyone know just how much of a menace she was.

"The Brothers Grimm" isn't the worst movie to come out of Hollywood. But, unfortunately, it failed to grasp the opportunity to become a great one.

For the person who wrote animal cruelty. There is such things as fake cats, cg graphics and robotics. They are not that stupid to do that to a real cat, so don't push your peta beliefs on everyone else. If you want to boycott it because you don't agree with it then fine, but don't force everyone else to.

Yes I did think that it was a little misguided in the ad. People assumed it would be alright to take kids to due to it being about fairy tales.... However I noticed a lot of reviews made bad comments saying that isn't how the fairytales went, it was awful blah,blah, blah. If you EVER do your investigating you will realize that the original storys were just has horrific as how they were offered in the movie. Little red riding hood did get eaten, hanzel and gretle did get killed by the witch and all the other storys were like that. There is books where the storys doesn't go as plan. If you investigate you will realize the storys were changed later so they would not scare children. If people cannot accept this then they shouldn't worry about seeing the movie ever again.

Now back to the movie, yes it was graphic with the cat scene as well as afew others, I suggest this as a renter for those who really disagree with the whole concept of the dark side of the storys or those who agree with the negative comments. As for those who enjoy action, horror, dark movies, then by all means this is a buyer.

Video wise I give this movie one thumb up and I'll explain why. Graphically it was pretty good and and the effects or lack there of was alright but could have found better ways to do some scenes. Audio was average but I think that was because the theater speakers sucked. Acting was average.

I was captivated by the sharp, tight mix of buffoonery, macabre story telling, and artistic pacing. The funny parts goose you when you don't expect it, evoking laughter just long enough until the story gets serious again. The blending of all the various fairytales into one narrative was flawless and masterful.
And 'Le General' was SUPERB!

First off let me say that i am downright pissed off with some of the reviews. Just because this is not the watered down, sugar coated, junk of Diney does not mean this a bad movie. If you want to watch some stupid move like Americian Pie then by all means watch it. Just know all humans have their own views and thoughts on things. What you find offensive another person might find very good or visa-versa. Also, if you are going to watch this movie then be sure you research the subject material first.
Secondly, people are complaining that this movie is too dark and convuluted. If you ever read the ACTUAL Grimms fairy tales you will find they were dark and menacing. The tales were written to keep kids from doing stupid stuff. Most of the tales did not end on a Disney note. For example, one sister of Cinderella chopped her toes off while the other sister chopped her hells off. Also, you have to be familiar with Terry style of directing.
In addition, their was no gratuitus nudity. Yes you did see some cleavege but that was it. There was nothing overtly sexual at all. I thought that was a very wise decision on Terry part.
Finally, Terry used his skills as a director to weave in a lot of references to to the tales. I give Terry all the credit in the world for be able to pull this off.
In conclusion, if you read the tales and not rely on the sugar coated Disney junk then you will enjoy this movie! Also, have a adult there if you are letting your child watch this.

British comedy is not for everyone, and british action flicks are really not for most people, especially when starring American actors. Once you understand and accept this fact of life, then you realize how good a movie this really is. The storyline is simple; the two Grimm brothers (Damon and Ledger) are traveling con men in Napeolonic Europe. They use their knowledge of optics, chemistry, physics and psychology to create apparitions in isolated villages, and then appear to save the villagers from these demons. The local French ruler (Price) uncovers their ruse and sends them on a mission to solve a real mystery in a German village. They, of course do, and proceed to become local heroes.

There are numerous aspects of this film that are quite impressive and admirable. First of, this is one of the few films to accurately portray European village life before the Industrial Revolution. The roads are muddy, the people and their clothes are dirty as daily bathing is unknown, bad hygiene (missing teeth, etc...) is universal, superstition is ingrained in daily thoughts and speech, and children of both genders often wear the same clothes. None of the Musketeer films have done such a good job of portraying rural Europe circa 1800.

Second, the action scenes are deliberate and integral to the story. There are no grand war scenes, nor eye-catching CGI. Every action scene progresses the story in some way or another, and each is innovative. A good example is when the farmer's horse swallows his daughter.

Third, the casting was quite good. Lena Headey was perfect in her role as the village outcast. She was attractive, but not too much as to cast doubt on the validity of her role as village outcast. The choice of Monical Belluci as the Mirror Queen was also great. She is very attractive, but for a queen who is centuries old, Belluci's natural age was a good fit. And Peter Stormare does quite well as local henchman.

I saw this movie twice; once at the theater and once on DVD. The DVD viewing is much better because I could read the subtitles. Terry Gilliam made this movie so authentic that a lot of the dialogue includes strong accents that can be lost in a movie theater, but which is captured with subtitles.

First off, I liked The Brothers Grimm. In particular, I found the blend of fantasy and horror and the creepy production with moving trees and the Mirror Queen were fantastic.

The film is set in German during the Napoleonic wars and concerns Wilhelm and Jacob Grimm, con artists pulling off fake exorcisms from village to village. The different between the brothers is that Jacob (Heath Ledger) believes in things magical and Wilhelm (Matt Damon) is a pragmatist. The bothers and their two partners in crime have a great scam going until they are arrested by a French general (played by Jonathan Pryce) and are sent to a cursed German village where children are being mysteriously abducted to prove whether they can actually battle spirits as they claim. In the village, they find Angelika (Lena Headley) whose sisters have been claimed by the unknown forces in the forest. Angelike knows the forest and the evil the lives there and guides Wilhelm and Jacob to a mysterious tower that is the home of the Mirror Queen (played by Monica Bellucci).

Like many of Terry Gilliam's films there are moments of near slap-stick comedy followed by scenes of horror or the fantastic. Mixed into the film are hints of well-known fairy tales, such as Little Red Riding Hood and Hansel and Gretel. One of the abducted girls is wearing a red cape and two children searching in the woods are dropping breadcrumbs. This film is stunning for its production design and special effects. The forest is fittingly forbidding and the story holds your attention throughout the film. I have read a review that suggested that the film was difficult to follow but neither I nor my wife had any such difficulties. Matt Damon makes a good Wilhelm Grimm but Heath Ledger is a passionate Jacob as he makes his case for believing in magic and that the curse of the woods can be lifted. Jonathan Pryce was a slimy villain but I didn't care for his accent or the foppish way that he approached his role. Lean Headley was good as the determined Angelika. If you like fantasy films and Terry Gilliam in particular, then you should see The Brothers Grimm.

It seems as if our illustrious, self-important "film critics" nationwide have lost their sense of fun, for the majority of them crucified this movie, for no good reason. It's a rousingly entertaining, enjoyable movie that deserved much, much better.

This hyperkinetic, involving fairy tale avoids, unlike most of its type, in taking itself too seriously. It strikes just the right balance of terror, suspense, goofiness, thrills, and even poignance. Best of all, it catches you constantly off-guard with shrewdly placed comedy that's just right: at some points when things get fairly intense, it will make fun of its own absurdity.

The movie lightly satirizes the classic fairy tales marvelously, in sly references to all the most famous ones, but the movie's story in itself is just as wondrous and gripping as the best of them. The "Happily Ever After" element is handled perfectly, and is genuinely moving, but without making you cringe: it successfully avoids being maudlin or saccharine - and is funny as hell.

The director, Terry Gilliam, keeps things moving, with a giddy, galloping pace, and never lets things get bogged down in heavy-handed portentousness. The plot often takes surprising turns, taking us pleasantly off-guard; there's an imaginative, whimsical, childlike glee in the proceedings - it's an adult's recall of how fairy tales sparked our fancies. The sense of danger, especially of sinister hobgoblins hovering ominously in the forest, is exhilarating: Gilliam makes our childish fears of the dark forces lurking amongst the trees into something particularly unsettling and spooky. The wandering, darting vine tendrils and branches that reach out to grab you are redolent of the nightmares you always wanted to avoid. The "special effects" are startling: the phantasmagorical computer generated images, are for once, entirely in keeping with the scope of a fairy tale element, hence they look "real."

Heath Ledger and Matt Damon, romping gaily as the two brothers, are clearly having the time of their lives, both showing their talent for physical comedy. It's surprising to see Ledger, pre- "Brokeback Mountain," exhibit such goofy, unforced charm, and the sweetness of his character is endearing (he's very moving at the end). It's great to see Damon expanding his range so convincingly; the perpetual frat boy persona has matured into a dynamic screen presence. Ledger and Damon look wonderful in their period costumes, looking truly Dickensian. Peter Stormare as the bungling villain is a hoot: the business with his hairpiece repeatedly deflates his character's authority. Lena Headey, a Jacqueline Bisset lookalike, is a strong presence as Angelika. It's hilarious to see her often out-masculinize the 2 brothers. Monica Bellucci, as the evil Queen, is an inspired choice: her alluring, Botticelli-like beauty makes you believe in the force of her seductive powers.

It would be a pity if this enchanting fantasy were relegated to oblivion because of some jaded critics.