Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Essential for all GBV fans *, December 11, 2008
This first Boston Spaceships cd is the most "classic era GBV" sounding record Robert Pollard has done in a long time. Almost every song is instantly catchy, and the few that aren't, will grow on you. The first 3 songs are so sharp and melodic, and it's also refreshing to hear Bob with a real live band again. Chris Slusarenko and John Moen are tight, and well rehearsed, with good rock and roll chops, and this record has a real rock band vibe to it. Every song is arranged perfectly for it's style or mood, and Bob's vocals are very strong. Favorite tracks are "You Satisfy Me", "Ready To Pop", "Still In Rome", "Psych Threat", the super-catchy "Winston's Atomic Bird", and the remake of an old gbv song, "Go For The Exit". This album has something for everyone who's ever loved the "Propeller" thru the "Do the Collapse" (and beyond) era of Guided By Voices, and also for the hardcore fan, who must buy every single challenging side-project, or solo excursion of Robert Pollard. Bravo Bob, "Brown Submarine" is fantastic. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Captain Fades to Brown, November 8, 2008
Destined to be a Robert Pollard classic, I'm surprised this album isn't getting more attention. Probably because of the ungodly amount of material this man releases. It's easy to lose track, but this new band Bob's put together is incredible. Brown Submarine kicks off with "Winston's Atomic Bird", a quirky piece of oddball pop perfection, but as soon as you get your head bobbing, it's over and the mood shifts to the dark, stripped acoustic title track. Well, this barely lasts a minute and in comes that very familiar GbV style guitar riff, similar to the intros to "I Am a Scientist" and "Queen of Cans and Jars". One of the longest songs on the album at three minutes, "You Satisfy Me" is pure melodic bliss. From here it just keeps getting better. Acoustic guitar is very prominent throughout, but it still rocks hard. Kind of similar to Half Smiles of the Decomposed in that way. One of my favorites, "Rat Trap" ("Oh no, not Rat Trap!") is acoustic power glam-punk with a wigged out Pollard singing a laugh (Ha-ah-ah-Ha Ha HA!) over reverbed electric piano for the songs climax. And you know Bob can't help but experiment a little, and "Still in Rome" let's him prog out with some as always intriguing, dark yet humorous lyrics, asking "Shall I show them thumbs down?" and "I was hopin' that the dead would rise by themselves". It could've easily been a Circus Devils track. The album closes with a reworking of an old Guided by Voices demo, "Go For The Exit". It starts off as a gentle acoustic ditty, dripping with melodic goodness, then the band kicks in, turning it into a full on rocker, still dripping with melodic goodness. The whole thing's over before you know it, and you'll find yourself playing the entire album again. It also had me wanting to hear Normal Happiness, it seems to have a similar pace and feel to that album, also recommended. Apparently the next record is already in the can and slated for an early '09 release, and Bob's finishing the demos for the third. Can't wait.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The operative word is fun, February 15, 2009
For longtime Robert Pollard/GBV fans, I'd describe this debut Boston Spaceships album as reminiscent of the classic "Alien Lanes," but with slightly longer songs and better sound. It's also a bit more consistent than "Alien Lanes," maybe because there are only 14 tracks here. The most light-hearted thing Pollard has released in some time, the album is varied, spirited, absurd, irreverent, very tuneful and imbued with a punky energy that makes it sound like the work of inspired 20-year-olds rather than a middle-aged goofball and his like-minded cohorts. Nobody can write like Pollard at his best. "You Satisfy Me," "Winston's Atomic Bird," "2 Girl Area," "Andy Playboy," "Psych Threat" and several others here are straight from skewed pop heaven -- inspired melodies and sharp, funny lyrics that are more comprehensible than is usually the case with Pollard. "Ate it Twice" and "Zero Fix" rock with abandon. Even the two songs that probably won't grab you immediately, "North 11 A.M." and "Still in Rome," will grow on you with repeated listenings. This album and Pollard's new solo disc, "The Crawling Distance," (which is very different but just as great) rank with his best-ever work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|