Customer Reviews

Buddha, The Four Encounters: Buddha, Vol. 2: The Four Encounters

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Our family read this book and it's companion, Kapilavastu, cover-to-cover, just about non-stop. They were both totally engaging.
As a Buddhist, I was wondering what this treatment of the Buddha's life would be like. This is my first exposure to manga style. My only reference point is comic books. I had enjoyed another "comic book," illustrated treatment of the life of a Buddhist saint, Milarepa. That was well done. I very much wanted a book that would capture the interest of my two children, 10 and 14 years old. It did. My 14 year old read the book in two days. My 10 year old and I read it aloud together.

What is facinating is the way the author creates the historical context using a mixture of historical figures and people of his own imagination. We are given an insight to the caste system of ancient India and the stage is set for the Buddha's questions about suffering, it's origins, and his strong desire to put an end to suffering.

I'd say that this is appropriate for 9 year olds and up. For adults: my wife and I kept reading ahead. It is captivating. It has the air of an adventure story. I also enjoyed explaining and discussing the context of the story with my children.

Hope you enjoy it as much as we did.

I read a lot of books on Buddhism (I even write some), but, alas, very few have pictures. This elegant (if one is allowed to use such an adjective to describe a graphic novel) series from Vertical of course goes way beyond "pictures." It tells the story of the Buddha and, in effect, the society he came from, through the expansive envisioning of Tezuka, The Man of La Manga. (Sorry, couldn't resist the pun. In case you don't know, "manga" means "graphic novel" in Japanese, and Tezuka really is The Man, having pretty well created the genre). So it's not about a text with pictures, it's about telling the story of the Buddha as a *vision*, rather than as a collection of words. It works.

Seriously, volume two carries on the dual track of intriguing characters who illustrate overarching themes, bringing them to life in a way that mere text almost never does. These are not scholarly books, by any means, but they depict the cultural milieu from which the Buddha and Buddhism arose. We haven't yet gotten to where Tezuka lets the Buddha expound the dharma, but, if he follows his established pattern, he's going to get things pretty straight.

I'm really looking forward to future volumes this series and think a whole range of others will soon be waiting with me.

There was some substance to the book and yet at the same time it managed to stay funny which is a rarity if I do say so my self. I am not particularly a fan of manga art but I loved this book, story and art work and I read both volume one and volume 2 without setting them down. Now I just have to get my hands on the third one :)

The graphic novel medium is perfect to share Tezuka's adaptation of the Buddha's life. While reading this, you can sense the artist's love and joy in having created such an intricate and complexly interwoven story. The detail and care taken in drawing some of the pictures is absolutely incredible. And, Tezuka's drawing style is always a blast to look at. Not necessarily for children, but certainly worthwhile for young adults and up, these books do not have anything vaguely resembling a "religious" or overtly moral feel to them. There is sadness, joy, history, sex, violence, profanity, redemption and liberation. The artist allows the reader to digest the understanding of the lessons for themselves without spoon feeding it to them. There arent many details on the Buddha's upbringing and there certainly aren't many comic books on the Buddha's life (are there any?), but this set effectively communicates one mans interpretation of the "The Awakened One". If you're looking for a great graphic novel that will be tons of fun to read and encourage you to see life differently, this is a wonderful addition to your collection. If you're looking for a fun way of understanding the life, culture and teaching of the Buddha, this is THE way to do it.

I enjoyed the first in this series but found this second book disappointing. The graphic style sagged with too much Manga cuteness and less dynamic, novel creativity for the eye. The plot was also less than compelling. However I still plan to keep reading the series.

This second volume exceeds its predecessor in terms of overall power. Unlike Volume One, the character of Siddhartha is squarely in the center of this work, and Tezuka does a great job in making this character likeable and human, steering far clear of pious platitudes and stock situations. While ending with the death of Bandaka and the rushed birth of his son, Devadetta, the future nemesis of the Buddha, this Volume both delights and entertains.