55 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Doesn't really do what the Editorial Review says, August 11, 2006
This review is from: Building Websites with Joomla! A step by step tutorial to getting your Joomla! CMS website up fast (Paperback)
My hope was that the book would do what the Editorial Review said i.e. walk you through the creation of your own website. It does not. It does walk you one by one through every possible menu item etc, although again not in a particularly useful order. As others have said, most of what is there is already available in the online help. It would have been much better to have gone though the process of building a site to show the user all of the steps involved from planning to implementing to refining...
My other major complaint is one of the legibility of the screenshots - of which there are very many. They are presented at a size where it is very difficult to read the text on them, although this is important to understanding the book.
There are other brief niggles, the language is strange in some portions, and there is one point where the author refers the user to a very good online tutorial in German (can't really think why a professional editor would let that get through.)
Lastly, the price is rather high for a computer book - maybe it would be better value if a real example based tutorial were added.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
37 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Waste of Money, February 2, 2007
This review is from: Building Websites with Joomla! A step by step tutorial to getting your Joomla! CMS website up fast (Paperback)
I bought this as a book and a download based on the editorial description. Just as the other reviewers said (I wish I had read them before I bought the book from Packt website!!!), the editorial description is misleading. All this book does is list the various menu items and options and VERY BRIEFLY describes what they do. There is no tutorial here, there is no step-by-step here.
Honestly, I played with the software for a few hours before I bought the book and I felt I was already way ahead of what was written here. Bitterly disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
30 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Horrible Introduction to Joomla!, May 11, 2007
This review is from: Building Websites with Joomla! A step by step tutorial to getting your Joomla! CMS website up fast (Paperback)
Having downloaded and installed Joomla without incident, I played around with the administration pages enough to get a feel of what was going on: there were templates that had places to put sections, which contained various categories, that contained content. After convincing myself Joomla! was exactly what I wanted, there were three tasks I wanted to get into immediately. 1) Removing the example junk from the page (e.g., "powered by Joomla!" and its banners). 2) Customize my own templates. 3) Inject some of my own PHP. Given that I'm familiar with Linux, Apache, MySQL, HTML/XML/XSLT/CSS, and PHP, all I needed was some simple documentation to show me where to start and how the architects laid out the system so that I could make modules that were Joomla! friendly.
This book totally failed to live up to the task.
There's something slightly off about the author's command of the English language. Word choices don't seem quite right, the analogies are obtuse and unnecessarily complicated, he gets overly excited about non-issues, and there's inconsistency between diagrams and corresponding code. (e.g, a picture will show something as a "section", but the HTML will show it as a "part" -- very confusing when it's unclear if this code is related to that picture).
The book does a half-way decent job of walking through each menu item, which is an extensive feature list. Problem is, the book is already dated, and the descriptions aren't that much more detailed than the text hints provided on Joomla! pages themselves.
The section that talks about creating templates instead presents a horrible and incomplete example of basic HTML, no where getting to what you need to know to make an actual template. Right at the point where PHP calls are needed to inject content or behavior, the book glosses over details, providing not so much as a function reference. In short, you're flying blind.
The section on modules and writing PHP is just as bad, if not more so incomplete. You're pointed a list of modules other people have written, but given very little instructions other than to fill out the forms when presented after installation.
I was really under impressed with this book.
After going through the whole book, I realized there wasn't a thing covered that I hadn't figured out in 15 minutes of casual playing with the software.
There's much more that's needed other than a bunch of screen shots. This book simply doesn't deliver. Try another title.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No