Customer Reviews

The Burglar in the Library (Bernie Rhodenbarr Mystery)

5 star:		(12)
4 star:		(15)
3 star:		(5)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

This is one of the best in Block's Bernie Rhodenbarr series.

"The Burglar in the Library" is one part Agatha Christie's "And Then There Were None" (a.k.a. "The Ten Little Indians"), one part Christie's "The Body in the Library" and one part Dashiell Hammett's "The Thin Man," with Bernie and Carolyn Kaiser pairing up as a platonic Nick and Nora Charles. All of the Rhodenbarr books are pretty funny, but this one is also a loving take on the English house murders that Dame Agatha Christie made famous.

Usually, these near-parodies aren't as kind to their inspiration. But "The Burglar in the Library" makes you want to rush out and re-read a Miss Marple mystery.

This book is such a departure from the Rhodenbarr books, which are as brash and hip as their New York City setting. I wonder how many years Block has yearned to produce his own genteel English mystery? I'm glad he decided to scratch that particular itch.

It's an excellent book. The true test of a mystery is if you enjoy it when you re-read, when you already know "who done it." This book passes the test with flying colors: I've read it twice, and I'm sure I'll be reading it again.

As with all the Rhodenbarr books, Block fills it with tons of book and other trivia. I'd never read any Hammett or Chandler (who figure prominently in this book), but Block prompted me to correct that, too.

Lawrence Block is one of our most talented mystery authors. In the Bernie Rhodenbarr series he explores how an ordinary, but intelligent, "honest" person might go about pursuing a life of crime as a fastidious and talented burglar who isn't proud of what he does, doesn't like to hang out with criminals, and really gets a big thrill out of breaking and entering . . . and removing nonessential valuables from rich people. As you can see, there's a sitcom set-up to provide lots of humor. But the humor works well in part because Mr. Block is able to put the reader in the Bernie's shoes while he breaks, enters and steals . . . and evades the long arm of the law. To balance the "honest" burglar is an array of "dishonest" and equally easy-money loving cops. As a result, you're in a funny moral never-never land while your stomach tightens and your arm muscles twitch as tension builds. To make matters even more topsy-turvy, Bernie at some point in every story turns into an investigator who must figure out "who-dun-it" for some crime that he personally didn't do. It's almost like one of those "mystery at home" games where the victim comes back as the police investigator, playing two roles. Very nice!

So much for explaining the concept of the series. The Burglar in the Library is the eighth book in the series. I strongly suggest that you begin the series by reading Burglars Can't Be Choosers and follow it up with The Burglar in the Closet, The Burglar Who Studied Spinoza, The Burglar Who Liked to Quote Kipling, The Burglar Who Painted Like Mondrian, The Burglar Who Traded Ted Williams and The Burglar Who Thought He Was Bogart. Each story in the series adds information and characters in a way that will reduce your pleasure of the others if read out of order. Despite that admonition, I originally read them out of order and liked them well enough. I'm rereading them now in order, and like it much better this way. The Burglar in the Rye comes next in the series.

The series, always comical and satirical, continues the new turn begun in The Burglar Who Thought He Was Bogart. The spoof expands to the detective/thriller genre in general. I found this change to be a welcome and charming one. Anyone who is an Agatha Christie fan will appreciate the many references to And Then There Were None.

And Then There Were None was my favorite mystery for many years. I loved the way that there seemed to be no solution . . . until the solution miraculously appeared from an unexpected direction. And that was before I knew what a red herring is in a mystery book. Although not duplicating all elements of Dame Agatha's masterpiece, you will find enough reflections to keep you entertained and more than normally amused.

Another delightful element is that parts of the book relate to Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett. In truly spoofish fun, those parts of the story reflect the characterizations and style of those two great mystery writers.

Bernie has once again fallen in love, with one Lettice Runcible by name, who adores anything English, even if it is an English country house set in New England. Bernie has arranged to take her to Cuttleford House (which fits that description) to enjoy the atmosphere, while he checks out the chance that a rare first edition of The Big Sleep resides there unappreciated by the current owners. He plans are desperately derailed when Lettice announces she cannot go because she's getting married instead. Crestfallen, but still curious about the Raymond Chandler volume, Bernie persuades Carolyn Kaiser, his lesbian best friend, to accompany Raffles, the cat, and him. Added to the usual humor between Bernie and Carolyn are the complications of being bed mates and others assuming that they are either married or lovers.

On the way to Cuttleford House, a huge snowstorm sets in that makes travel difficult. Bernie soon begins discovering unexpected dead and live bodies while he tries to check out the library in the wee hours of the night. By the next morning, they are cut off by the storm . . . and the bodies begin to pile up. With no way to reach the police, Bernie had better get to the bottom of what's going on . . . or he may be next!

The mystery is masterfully complicated and rewarding, for those who care about that aspect of the book.

When I finished this one, I was sure that I had found the best book in the Bernie Rhodenbarr series . . . and I still feel that way. This book is amazingly wonderful.

The theme of this book focuses on the importance (and challenges involved in) treating other people with respect, kindness and consideration. Beware: Bad things happen when we do not!

Donald Mitchell
Co-author of The 2,000 Percent Solution, The Irresistible Growth Enterprise and The Ultimate Competitive Advantage

While sometimes some of the entries in Lawrence Block's Burglar series can be a bit formulaic (some of the scenes are virtual repeats, at times), this one is a parody of other authors' prior, classic mystery works. Block's characters are simply a riot. The plot has a few flaws, but the emphasis here is on comic mystery not purity. So, if you are looking for a hard boiled or serious mystery, read Block's Scudder series or an Agatha Christie. There is fun in this book and two great quotes for my collection: "Whenever a politician answers a question that you haven't asked, he's lying" on page 282; and "I don't know who picked you to be the head wallaby in this kangaroo court" on page 303. However, this is not, IMHO, his best Burglar/Rhodenbarr book. Try "The Burglar Who Traded Ted Williams" or "The Burglar in the Closet." Still, I'd recommend reading them all as light entertainment, somewhat similar to Block's Tanner/pseudo-spy series.

This is a tribute to Agatha Christie and Raymond Chandler, all rolled into one neat murder mystery. Bernie and Carolyn spend the weekend in a New England guesthouse, which attempts to replicate an authentic old English manor. When guests begin showing up murdered, it's Bernie who plays the part of Hercule Poirot or, if you like, Philip Marlowe, as he gathers the clues, which will hopefully lead him to the murderer before too many more guests are knocked off. Being a guesthouse, there are suspects aplenty delivering us ample opportunity to figure out the mystery ourselves. If mystery fans will be delighted by this book, then fans of the British crime story will be even more so. Combining the wit and humour of Lawrence Block with the traditional murder mystery creates a deadly weekend, though presented in a light and breezy manner.

This is the 3rd Bernie Rhodenbarr book I have read, and I enjoyed it the most out of the bunch. I read the Burglar in the Closet, which disappointed me by having an extremely predictable ending, and I read the Burglar who Traded Ted Williams which was a middle of the road mystery. What kept me coming back was that I thought the character of Bernie Rhodenbarr was likable and the stories flow and end up being a quick read.

I thought that this story was intriguing and the ending is not readily predictable. This story and its characters are well developed and it keeps you interested throughout. For mystery lovers the references to Hammett, Chandler, and the Christie comparison of the story prove to be an extra treat. Even if you are not familiar with those writers it doesn't detract from the story and the book should still prove to be enjoyable.

So whether you have or haven't read Lawrence Block before, this one is worth picking up.

Very good character in the lead of a very well writing plot. As a Mathew Scudder fan, I change direction to the Bernie Rhodenbar series and found it amazingly pleasant. I intend to read the entire series as well as the whole Lawrence Block's collection. He's the very best in the writing field where he moves.

Lawrence Block is a very good writer, usually. This "mystery" is chockablock with padded dialog that often seems to go on endlessly and to no purpose. And, to top it off, the "mystery" ends on a totally unbelievable and silly note.

There were four bodies total, that is people "killed" or otherwise departed from this realm of tears. Three were explained at the end, and the other one was simply left hanging, the explanation being that, well, some things just cannot be explained. Gimme a break.

That, on top of the bloated dialog, makes this one of Block's lesser efforts, to put it mildly.

I am hooked on Block's "burglar" series! This is the fourth Bernie mystery I've read and they only continue to get better and better! Block sends up classic mysterys (this one focused on Agatha Christie) while maintaining their set-up and plot development.

Unlike so many authors, Block doesn't assume his audience are idiots. He writes intellignet and well-crafted mysteries that amuse and entertain. While the books can get slow at times, the action is never too far off. A true test of fiction for me is whether you ever want to put the book down. When you're reading a good novel, you should want to read straight through and dread having to set the story aside. That's the case with Block's "Burglar" books...they are a solid, entertaining read from start to finish!

As readers of Lawrence Block's "Burglar" series know, master cracksman Bernie Rhodenbarr is a city boy -- New York City, to be specific. It is strange, then, to see him tromping through the snow and the plush rooms of a British-style manor house in THE BURGLAR IN THE LIBRARY. Block uses the eighth installment in this excellent series as an opportunity to send up mysteries of the Agatha Christie "And Then There Were None" variety (also taking some affectionate potshots at Raymond Chandler along the way). The result is extremely funny, and the brilliance of the comedy makes it hard to mind too much that the solution to the book's mystery is awfully hard to follow. Does anyone complain that the plot of Neil Simon's "Murder By Death" doesn't make any sense? No. They just pop the tape in the VCR and laugh themselves sick. THE BURGLAR IN THE LIBRARY is disorienting in spots and some long-time readers may not approve of the change of venue, but I defy any reader to make it from cover to cover without laughing out loud. A wonderful, wonderful work of comic fiction.

Lawrence Block is a joy to read. Whenever I feel the need to escape, I pick up a Bernie Rhodenbarr book. And since I'm a cat lover, I especially like that he keeps his cat Raffles in every book of the series. Reading the humorous events of a burglar from the burglar's standpoint is quite refreshing. And stealing only from the rich, I guess makes him a modern-day Robin Hood. I have read all the Rhodenbarr books, but the Burglar in the Library is one of my favorites. I also have listened to other books by Block on tape and CD during long drives. He never ceases to amuse me.