Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
THE TEENAGE TIMES, THEY ARE A-CHANGING, August 22, 2001
The times have changed from when those of us went to elementary and middle school (junior high) back in the sixties and seventies and were assigned certain books for reading and discussing. Although there are many "classics" assigned for literature readers of the same age in this new era, the world of teenage books truly screams out for stories that are more timely. I believe it is through literature teenagers can come to see other cultures, other lives, and other situations more than if we keep waving newspapers in front of their faces. Literature sings a new song, and if the song is well written, the mind can dance to it. Buried Onions is such a novel. My son was assigned it as summer reading and he was so absorbed in it, I decided to read it myself. It is timely. Soto brings the character of Eddie to life by revealing both his small rays of hope and his overpowering sense of hopelessness to the reader. The struggle he faces to remove himself from the violent gang environment and into vocational school and eventually a job. His best efforts fail due to outside influences and he must make a decision which will chart the course for the rest of his life. The ending of the book, revealed above in the canned review, I feel is deliberate, much like the ending of "The Giver." The reader was pointedly forced into wondering what really happened after the book was closed. What a great hook to make someone think. Even more than Eddie's story, the ending opens up wonderful opportunities to discuss the story and the different avenues Eddie's life may have taken AFTER the conclusion in the book. It's a different age, a different time in history and while it's wonderful to revisit the classics, it is vital young people have the opportunity to delve into some of the very real issues all kids are facing. If your kid has this as an option on a reading list, encourage them to choose it. They (and you) will be engrossed and it's an excellent jumping off point to discuss life choices.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brown is a favorite target, November 10, 2000
By A Customer
I think the book Buried Onions is a good one. I recommend this book to all teeagers. Gary Soto tells you what a Mexicano or Chicano have to live just because our skin is brown. I was raised in the town of Cicero and I know how living in the street is, I know that any day my life could be taken away. But, that is the risk I have to take when I am out there with my home boys. I also have to look out for the police because brown is one of their favorite targets to arrest or beat up. Life in my town is like Fresno. Some of the gangs are small, but there are some crazy home boys that just don't care if they take a life or two. Life is nothing easy, but you have to learn how to live it. Some times you have to throw down to get your respect, and sometimes you have to steal to survive, but that is life. Most of my home boys are drop outs and some didn't even start high school, but everybody chooses their own way of living. Some have jobs, but not careers. Some are professional thieves. I liked the way this book mixed Spanish and English together, that is the way I was raised and my homeboys, too. I liked that the book is written in realistic language. I liked the way the book ended. Sometimes that is the best thing to do, fly away with the wind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Struggle for Survival, September 4, 2002
Gary Soto's Buried Onions tells the story of Eddie, a young man who is struggling to survive in the neighborhood he lives in. In his neighborhood "Once a dude pointed you out in a 7-Eleven parking lot or some filthy gas station, there was no mercy, no time to explain that you were a father or a good son or an altar boy with combed hair." That is exactly what Eddie wants to escape. His goal to work and stay out of trouble although simple is many times challenged by the relationships that time has established in his neighborhood, his aunts pressure to have him avenge his cousins death and his bad luck. Although he is constantly seeking out employment opportunities he has a hard time finding a job and when he does luck is not on his side. Events that are out of his control occur and the opportunities that he so desperately seeks and need are taken away. He is then left to try again to fulfill his goal and not take the easy way out like it is expected. Eddie's struggle is one that many young adults can relate to. Buried Onions is a different story that addresses the concern for survival in a world in which you are expected to fail. I would definitely recommend this book to young adults of all genders and race. The struggle for survial is one that they all can relate to. They will enjoy reading this fiction story that is filled with realistic events that many of them face today. It is an easy and enjoyable book to read. The Spanish language used in this story gives life to the characters and is non-confusing since there is a glossary in the book. Some foul language is used in the story but it is non-offensive. It is used at a minimum. This is a great story that can be discussed in class or with friends.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|