From Publishers Weekly
White's collection, unified by sharp wit and seemingly boundless erudition, has a surprising drawback: his trademark elegance of style, which works well in his book reviews (a large portion of which are reproduced here) is less appropriate to his political rhetoric. In those pieces the edges seem sanded down by restrained prose, even as White describes his anger at the marginalization of gays since Stonewall and the oppression that gay people, including himself, "no stranger to gay militancy," have traditionally faced from straight society. Yet when White assays literature, he nears perfection. His critiques of Tennessee Williams, Jean Genet, Coleman Dowell, James Jones, James Merrill, Cormac McCarthy and other writers are persuasive, especially when the authors discussed are White's friends or acquaintances. As readers of "A Boy's Own Story" and "The Beautiful Room Is Empty" will expect, White can be forcefully self-revealing; the autobiographical references are moving. But his writing on politics (he acknowledges his "nearly total silence" on AIDS) is insightful rather than inciting and seems to invite placid contemplation, not argument or action. Bergman is an English professor at Towson State University in Maryland. Reader's Subscription and QPB alternates.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
While White is best known for his novels, particularly A Boy's Own Story (LJ 9/1/82), this collection reveals what a fine essayist he is. White's descriptions of gay male life of the past 30 years and the changes in attitude that have occurred among gay men toward themselves and their sexuality are clear, forceful, intelligent, and thought-provoking. Nongays can learn much about the American gay male experience. White offers other essays and reviews of the work of contemporary writers, American and European, gay and nongay, such as James Merrill, Christina Stead, Darryl Pinckney, and Marguerite Yourcenar. This material, together with White's discussions of his own fiction, provides valuable insights into the reading and writing of literature. Six of the essays are previously unpublished. Highly recommended for literature collections.
Judy Mimken, Boise, Id.Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.