6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The editor could use an editor, June 19, 2006
This review is from: Burroughs Live: The Collected Interview of Wiliam S. Burroughs, 1960-1997 (Double Agents) (Paperback)
While any book collecting the words of William Burroughs, & particularly any Burroughs book of this size, is cause for celebration, this particular book has some serious editorial flaws. There is a great deal of alteration to the interview transcripts, there is repetition within the book & in relation to other books, & there are many obvious errors.
The interviews, says Sylvere Lotringer at the outset, were altered from their original form in order to better serve the flow of the book. While this is understandable or even necessary given the number of interviews collected here, some of the editorial choices destroy any sense of the original interviews. In several cases Lotringer collapses different interviews with different interviewers from different times into one, creating a fictionalized pastiche of Burroughs live. & in other cases the editing of transcripts is so severe, as with the Playboy drug panel, that Burroughs comes out seeming like the subject of the article when originally he was just another participant. The thrill of the interview format is in seeing how a particular subject creates on the spot, how he interacts with the other participants & how the ideas of his work transfer to his life. While there's a good deal of originals throughout the book, many interviews needlessly lose the spontaneity of the originals as a result of editorial tinkering.
In addition, there is repetition, particularly from other books that an avid Burroughs reader would already have. There is material reprinted from the Re/Search book on Burroughs, as well as Victor Bockris's With William Burroughs: A Report from the Bunker. The pieces culled from the latter are particularly frustrating, since that book was already a collection of interviews. In addition, those pieces tend to be edited here! To reprint interviews already collected in book form is wasteful, but to alter them further is absurd. We would have been much better off with the complete transcripts of previously unavailable material, rather than the inclusion of recycled, re-edited, already-available interviews.
Finally, there are basic editorial errors throughout the book. Typographical errors, sometimes quite embarrassing (as when Burroughs tells David Bowie of a sound below the level of hearing - below 16 'Mertz'!), litter the whole book. There are several times where paragraphs are repeated word for word on a single page. There are even interviews that end in the middle of a sentence simply because that sentence came at the end of a page. As an editor myself, I can spot the telltale signs of unchecked OCRing (optical character recognition) - in other words, the editor scanned the interviews into his computer, used the OCR program to convert it to a text format, & never bothered to check the accuracy of the results. Any competent copyeditor would spot such errors from a mile away & easily fix them; the fact that this book has been published without such necessary editorial attention is disgraceful.
That said, there are many interviews collected here which would otherwise be impossible to find. There are translations from French & German, there are reprints from the myriad small presses Burroughs associated with in England, there are curiosities & oddities that might not have otherwise seen the light of day. For these pieces alone, this book remains a necessary purchase for us Burroughsphiles. But the errors of the editor keep this book far from being the last word on his interviews.
That Burroughs is a fascinating read in any format goes without saying. For all the intelligence, humor, & world-weary wisdom he imparted, he surely deserves a better publication than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
the genius heart of the beat movement, January 12, 2003
This review is from: Burroughs Live: The Collected Interview of Wiliam S. Burroughs, 1960-1997 (Double Agents) (Paperback)
yeah yeah i know there are so many mad geniuses in the beat movement. burroughs however is the godfather of all. this book is the bible of burroughs interviews as well as his thought. there are a few interviews with his other beat cronies but most of them are just naked burroughs. some of the interviews are a little dry but i wouldn't cut a one of them.few could write with more imagination than w.s. and even less could say it better or be more thoughtful or provacative. god i miss him. to read burroughs is to never again think the same. what freud and jung etal claimed to know of the psyche only burroughs truly explored.long may he wave. i highly recommend this book. then after you get this read then tackle is compilation word virus
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
More a reference work, than a book, April 25, 2010
This review is from: Burroughs Live: The Collected Interview of Wiliam S. Burroughs, 1960-1997 (Double Agents) (Paperback)
I am hesitant ot give this a full five stars, despite being one of the most read books in my library.
Naturally this is a wonderfull collection of interiews of Mr Burroughs. And unlike "From the Bunker" this is every single one. This is not a best of, nor just a sample, this is it. And it's there that it becomes a little... too much. Reading the entire book cover to cover is no simple task, as Burroughs, naturally, repeats himself time and time again. Some interviews seem to be the same, and I find myself screaming: "I KNOW, you've said this allready"
That being said, it IS interesting to note how he over the years contradicts himself, often seeming more interested in overpowering the interviewer with his brilliance, than being truthfull.
I think it is more helpfull to look at this book as a reference book, than a good read.
If you want to be entertained and taught by Burroughs, I would rather reccoment "From the Bunker" and "The Job" as they function more as works in themselves. Read THIS entire book, and you feel you never wanna see the man again, as you've had your fill. There is such a thing as too much of a good thing...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No