14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An entertaining handbook for investors, September 20, 2006
This review is from: Business Fairy Tales: Grim Realities of Fictitious Financial Reporting (Hardcover)
I found "Business Fairy Tales" engrossing and remarkably readable. When one considers the mystique that surrounds the scandals of questionable accounting techniques and poor corporate governance it is easy to believe that only an accountant could follow the details. Not so. Dr Jackson presents all of the material facts in very human narrative making it easy to follow the methods applied. He develops the key characters enough that I could sense the opportunities that tempted them and felt I gained some insight into their motivation.
After exploring each case the author presents straightforward tests or indicators that any investor can apply.
Perhaps the recent corporate scandals are themselves indicators that we have naively relied too much on regulators, analysts and auditors to protect us from risky investments. The measures set out in "Business Fairy Tales" won't replace professional guidance, but they can equip both investors and their advisers to spot risks early and raise the right questions. All this and an enjoyable read!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A must-read for investors in individual companies, July 9, 2010
This review is from: Business Fairy Tales: Grim Realities of Fictitious Financial Reporting (Hardcover)
This book is a series of case studies of accounting malfeasance over the last twenty years. The author reviews Enron, Worldcom, Sunbeam, Xerox, and about a dozen others whose transgressions range from too-aggressive judgment calls to massive and continuous deception. Each chapter has a natural progression from the history of the company and the leading actors, to the specific mechanisms by which they misled the investing community, and then most importantly, to the red flags in their financial documents that should have raised eyebrows long before the truth became common knowledge.
The wheat-to-chaff ratio is extremely high. Much of what passes for financial education in the popular press are storybooks and pablum. If you're investing in individual companies, the only way to move beyond gambling is to get your hands dirty with financial statements. Accounting textbooks will give you the theoretical knowledge to do this, but they won't tell you the slippery ways corporate brass can manipulate operations to fudge the numbers.
A few common schemes:
* Recognizing an arbitrarily high, one-time restructuring expense immediately after an acquisition, which is then released back into earnings in later periods to inflate income
* Recording future and contingent merchandise sales, or future income from contracts, in the current period
* Understating operating expenses by pretending as if the money had gone to the purchase of an asset
* Understating cost of goods sold by failing to account for loss of inventory through shrinkage
* Hiding liabilities in ostensibly independent holding companies that are actually controlled by the principal
While the author deftly unwinds this duplicity in a retrospective, it isn't within his power to suggest ways to determine with certainty whether fraud is occurring. That isn't the point of the book. No outside investor is privy to the full details of company operations, and many of the larger shams were so intentionally convoluted that unraveling them wasn't even within reach of the firm's auditors.
What he does suggest are certain high-level metrics for which the change, or lack of change, over time should raise suspicion. Few companies act fraudulently from the outset. They almost always have a period of normal operation that can be used as a point of comparison for their current behavior. Moreover, even when a company is violating GAAP, the numbers in their financial statements still have to be internally consistent; the paper trail must end somewhere. While actual fraud is difficult to detect, this book will provide you with the tools to cast enough doubt to steer clear of questionable prospects. In context then, it's a bargain.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Valuable Information For Accountancy Literate Investors, January 7, 2007
This review is from: Business Fairy Tales: Grim Realities of Fictitious Financial Reporting (Hardcover)
Business fantasies (including turn-arounds) sound really good, until reality crashes in. How do the manipulators get away with it? Well, people don't understand what the manipulators are up to, and the fantasy is much more appealing. People looking for investing opportunities want to believe in a bright future, so they overlook minor issues like false and deceptive financial reporting.
This book describes many of the financial techniques used to create the fantasies. It can be quite useful to serious investors who want to avoid investing in fairy tales, but a reasonable knowledge of accounting is necessary to understand the material. Many of the suggestions would be very difficult to implement by anyone without access to internal records, so don't expect to use everything directly.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No