7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Busoni according to Sitsky, May 28, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Busoni and the Piano: The Works, the Writings, and the Recordings (Contributions to the Study of Music and Dance) (Hardcover)
"Busoni and the piano" is the sort of title a Busoni fan would fall for, especially if he or she is a pianist. So I did. But aside from the hunger of specific Busoni-piano related subjects and details, I found that the author of this book is an interpreter of Busoni's personality, writing as if Busoni had been an old friend or relative of his. I must say that a lot of what Sitsky says is very inspiring, and I am grateful that many words have been spent on Busoni "and" the piano, rather than Busoni "at" the piano or Busoni' work as a transcriber, etc. It is quite obvious that Busoni carries along a hidden, almost esoteric quality and there is also a great deal af collective memory of past artistic treasures and styles in his complex musical style and idiom. Busoni can strike for his classical (in the Greek-Roman sense) redondances as well as for his modernisms, but the all-embracing knowledge that underlies his creative work is something that can certainly make a change in the artistic and aesthetic sensitivities of those that love and understand his music. It appears that Sitsky does understand it in an authoritative manner, conveying also the humanistic nature of the composer. I wish Sitsky had gome more into that mysterious realm of Busoni's aesthetics, I don mean what was written in the well known writings, but rather what was "said", or "stated" in his sound world. Maybe he will, and I will be an enthusiastic admirer of his new work. "Busoni and the Piano" can also serve as a fairly detailed catalogue of Busoni's piano works. Maybe an updated edition of it could present new recordings of Busoni's music, why not? Carlo Grante
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A thoughtful and scholarly text highly recommended for serious scholars of the piano, May 11, 2009
First published in the late 1970s, Busoni and the Piano has been re-issued in an updated second edition for the twenty-first century. Written by Larry Sitsky, a music teacher, performer, and scholar of Busoni's work, this newly revised second edition of "Busoni and the Piano" explores Busoni's influence upon early 20th century music. Chapters examine individual works of Busoni in depth, excerpting scores as needed to illustrate points; compare Busoni to other great composers such as Bach, Liszt, and Mozart; and scrutinize Busoni's view of aesthetics, including his theory of notation for the piano. A thoughtful and scholarly text highly recommended for serious scholars of the piano.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Busoni always seemed to me to be someone worth knowing better. Now I know why., April 1, 2009
While I have played transcriptions of Busoni's Bach pieces, particularly the chorale preludes, I do not know his original compositions. I had supposed him to be a virtuoso pianist who dabbled in arranging and some composing as was fashionable in his day. This book educated me on the greater substance of the man, what he means to his devotees and what his musical aims were when he put pen to paper and fingers to the keyboard. I think this is a wonderful, valuable, and fascinating book for anyone who loves piano music and would like to get to know the true value of Busoni at the piano. We also see the way he struggled with his competing cultural influences between Italy and Germany. We are also reminded of other complications because of the way he was situated in musical history and the changes in music language and theory that happened during his lifetime.
Larry Sitsky has organized the books nineteen chapters into four broad sections with the first chapter, the appendix, catalogue of works, bibliography, index of Busoni's works, and general index coming before and after the four sections. There is a paragraph on the author at the very end of the book. He is obviously a devotee of Busoni, and is himself a pianist, composer, and professor of music.
The four big sections are:
"The Shorter and Unpublished Original Works" - mostly stuff that is justly not published and of interest to Busoni scholars.
"The Major Original Works" these include his six sonatinas, a piano concerto, other works for piano and orchestra, and his complex "Fantasia Contrappuntistica" for two pianos and solo piano (but it is all but unplayable). Busoni's comments in the score about orchestral effects are also discussed. Sitsky also takes us through the volumes of Busoni's "Klavieruebung", which is a collection of studies and materials for pedagogy and practice. Much is material by others, some by Busoni, and some tweaked by him.
"Busoni and Other Composers" takes us through his arrangements and recompositions of works by Bach (we all know at least some of these), Liszt, Mozart, and other composers. In my view, this music is far too easily dismissed nowadays as an artifact of the days before recordings. No. These are works of genuine artistry and deserve to be looked at. Bach and Handel re-worked the music of other composers in their day and if we want to get at a genuine music practice of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, these works should be performed without apology or grimace.
"Busoni and Aesthetics" deals with Busoni as a theorist and aesthete. We are shown how he approached transcriptions and how he reworked organ music for piano. Sitsky also evaluates the body of compositional work of Busoni and what he accomplished. We are also treated to Busoni's idiosyncratic theories on music notation. The last chapter takes us on a tour of the recording Busoni left us. Only a few are acoustic recordings. Most are in the form of piano rolls.
Enjoy!
Reviewed by Craig Matteson, Ann Arbor, MI
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No