From Publishers Weekly
Three brief vignettes about a bashful canine comprise this uneven yet often charmingly illustrated beginning reader from newcomer Bechtold. In the opening tale, "Buster's First Party," Bechtold's watercolors and hurried ink line whimsically capture the dynamics of a household filled with three cats, two dogs and an array of guests, and the plot exploits shy Buster's predicament to the fullest. The artist is at her best when she gets specific, as in a series of three Thurber-like spot illustrations when the pooch takes notice of a little girl who feels left out of the festivities. As he edges closer in the next two scenes, the elements of the composition shift and convey his transformation as he overcomes his shyness to befriend her. The next two stories are less intimate?in "Buster and Phoebe," Buster feels dwarfed by pooch pal Phoebe's talents until he finds one of his own; "Buster and Phoebe Meet the Garbage Bandit" chronicles the dog duo apprehending the culprits for whose mischief they've been blamed; both tales take place at night accompanied by illustrations steeped in subdued colors. Still, the dogs have very childlike characteristics, and youngsters will find much with which to identify. Ages 6-9.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3-These three stories about a puppy searching for his strengths will bring smiles of recognition to the beginning-reader set. In the first, Buster is new to the household, trying to find his niche among bossy pets and intimidating guests during his owner's birthday party. Next, he tries to search and catch like fellow-canine Phoebe, but learns that his less-flashy ability to listen is just as valued. It is this quality that enables him to assist Phoebe in solving the mystery of the garbage bandits in the last piece. Bechtold's watercolor-and-ink illustrations are droll and plentiful. Children not quite ready for Cynthia Rylant's "Henry and Mudge" series (S & S) will appreciate the natural repetition of vocabulary and the brevity of text per page.
Wendy Lukehart, Dauphin County Library, Harrisburg, PA Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.