Customer Reviews

Butch Camp

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I put off buying this DVD for over a year, as I thought it was just going to be another campy farce. Not that I have anything against that, mind you. But this surprising little film is so much more than the title might suggest: it is as warm and intelligent as it is funny. For starters, in his apparent labor of love, writer/director Alessandro De Gaetano pays homage to cinema of all kinds throughout the script, with cinematic references ranging from 'Casablanca' and 'Star Wars' to 'Moonstruck' and 'Maurice'. Every character name has a Dickensian, if not to say Freudian, significance. The plot is a deftly woven blend of comedy, politics, and romance.

Butch Camp is a defense class for put-upon gays, run by outrageous, foul-mouthed, wise-cracking 'Sam' Rotweiller. Judy Tenuta is both butch and camp as Sam. Arch-wimp Matt (played by cute Paul Denniston like Woody Allen on speed) is underpaid, overworked, afraid of love and, fed up, he enrolls in the course. For his first assignment, he must go to a sports bar armed with butch vocabulary cards and infiltrate 'the enemy'. He encounters manipulative Janet Cockswell (yes, that's right), her gorgeous boyfriend Rod (!), and his friend Woody (!!). Rod is played by wonderful Jason Teresi, the sweetest hunk ever, without whose warmth, beauty, rye humor, and delightfully mischievous personality as a foil to Matt's nervous negativity, the film would not have worked. Matt is surprised to find someone 'straight' who is so sensitive, literate, and musical, with whom he has so much in common. Dismayed, disarmed, and despite his self-imposed aloofness, Matt starts to fall in love as Rod takes him under his wing. Janet and Rod are both attracted to Matt's bashful eccentricity.

Rod quietly and steadfastly pursues the hapless, defensive Matt. He is seductive and persuasive by virtue of his compelling looks, athletic body, and honest, gentle, caring, insistent nature. His smile and twinkling eyes could melt any heart. However, they also seem destined for one another because (a) Matt needs furniture and Rod has 'a great five-piece sectional', and (b) they both have stunning hair.

Their romance is the heart of Mr. De Gaetano's story -- and the most pleasant surprise of the film. Treasure abounds as Matt and Rod find each other, and themselves in the process. They are the sweetest couple this side of 'Beautiful Thing', and theirs is the sexiest love story since 'World and Time Enough'. The film is not without its flaws and miscalculations, to be sure, but they become insignificant when the characters are so warm and winning. The full five stars are for them, with thanks.

I just wish dreams came true in 'real life' like they do in 'reel life'.

This movie is so funny! I saw this film at the Gay & Lesbian Film Festival and never stopped laughing.
I enjoyed it.

Once you get past the dated camp that permeates the movie, it's still pretty bad. The acting is mostly terrible, but I will say that the romance between Matthew and Rod is oddly sweet and the only worthwhile part of the movie. There were a few funny parts as well. Sweet in a b-movie kind of way.

Judy Tenuta runs "Butch Camp," a place where gay men go to learn how to masquerade as straight men. Judy is hysterical (as always), and Paul Denniston, as Matt - one of her students - is whiny and pretentiously intellectual, but still ultimately loveable.

I rate this movie 4 stars because the story is weak, even with the great performances. Matt, who is a bank loan officer, meets Janet and Rod in a straight bar, a couple who definitely have problems. Janet, in fact, is intent on seducing Matt, but Matt is interested only in Rod.

The ending is unrealistic, but funny nonetheless. The director, Alessandro De Gaetano, apparently only has one other film to his credit, a werewolf film starring Barry Bostwick of "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" fame.

Don't see it expecting to see a masterpiece, but I personally found it as enjoyable as "Trick" or many other better-known gay classics.

Thoroughly enjoy watching this film over & over. It's great fun. Camp (but not in a drag-queen way), a little romantic and lots of fun as we watch the hetero oppressors get their comeuppance. The acting is not the best, but who cares? This is simply fun. Only camp-o-phobes or people expecting deep meanings to their films would not enjoy this movie.

I had to stop watching this one 'cause the level of my irritation reached dangerous level. Was it the silly script? Probably. Was it the main character? For sure. A boy with thin voice and no balls - grrrr.
Once again gay theme movie based on cliches and stereotypes.
Well, if I write that acting quality is similar to the rest of the film, I will not discover second America.
Sorry, I have better things to do than watching such mediocre thing.

Sure, the acting is beyond bad and I spotted the boom/mic in at least four scenes. However, at its heart, this is a very sweet romantic comedy with a big ol' pinch of raunch for shock value. Quite cute.

If this film didn't have a gay plot, it would be sitting on the directors coffee table and nowhere else. Why are so many American Gay films unspeakably lousy? This film has terrible acting, writing and directing, avoid it at all costs. If you want to see a good gay film try Urbania or Parting Glances.