Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Accurate, vivid, and touching!, July 12, 2010
This review is from: CHINA: Portrait of a People (Paperback)
I am a Mainland Chinese who grew up during the 10 years of Cultural Revolution. At the end of my graduate study in 1986, I went on a hitch-hiking trip to Tibet with a friend of mine. We had 45 RMB Yuan, a camera, and 4 rolls of films with us. We spent a month on the road, riding in the back of coal-hauling trucks, on the make-shift engine cover in the front of old buses, in the back of tractors, climbing over hills, and riding on the back of horses. We slept in horse stables, tents, and sometimes, for 1.5 yuan a night, we got to sleep in a bed...
That was the highlight of my travel experience: 1 month, 4 provinces, and 100 photos.
Tom Carter has done this for 2 years across 33 provinces in China. When I looked at the photos in his book, my eyes were swelled with tears the whole time: His photos have so accurately and vividly captured the features and the characteristics of the people from this most diversed country in the world that I call my motherland! Without reading the captions, I can tell that that young man is from Guangxi, that girl is from Sichuan, and those folks are from Heilongjiang. I can hear them talk in their dialects. I can feel their hopes. I can touch their spirits... They have aroused my desire to talk with them and laugh with them again. They reminded me so much of everything I saw in my little excursion over twenty years ago. It was a journey down the memory lane but it is more. It tells me things that I have no experience of since I have been gone away for almost 20 years...
I have lived in the United states for many years. When I go to bookstores, I am naturally attracted to the sections where I can find books about China. I have not seen another book like this - so real and so recent, capturing all the changes that have happened in China in the last 20-30 years while at the same time showing the essence and heritage of the culture.
I hope more people will read this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
These Pictures Capture the Heart and Souls of 1.3 Billion People, June 24, 2010
This review is from: CHINA: Portrait of a People (Paperback)
There are more than 1.3 billion people in China. Besides the majority Han Chinese, the population includes 56 ethnic groups numbering over one hundred million. Over the course of 2 years and 35,000 miles, photojournalist Tom Carter captured it ALL on film.
For their historical value alone, the 800+ photos in Portrait are priceless. I highly doubt if there will ever be another book about China like this one. Carter's anthropological-like study of China stands apart in its genre, as it focuses expressly on the PEOPLE of China. In addition to documenting the everyday life of "ordinary" people, Carter also backpacked to the most remote areas of China to observe reclusive ethnic minorities such as the red-turbaned Pai Yao minority of northern Guangdong and the resplendent Dong and Miao tribes of eastern Guizhou.
From Inner Mongolian nomads to newlyweds in Hong Kong, from the teenage girl living in Chengdu dressed like an American punk rocker to the soot covered coal miner in Southern Shanxi, Carter's camera documented the complexity and diversity of China like no other book ever has (or likely ever will). There is an old saying that a picture is equal to a thousand words. In CHINA: Portrait of a People, each picture is worth TEN thousand words, maybe more.
The consensus amongst backpackers is that China is probably the single most challenging country in the world to visit. As such, in order to reach certain locations, Carter had to travel on foot into some seriously rugged terrain. To get an idea what I'm talking about, consider that China, almost the size of the United States, uses only sixteen percent of its land for growing crops. The rest is either mountains or desert.
To take the up-close and personal pictures in CHINA: Portrait of a People, Carter also risked jail multiple times; was stranded in Tibet; faced exhaustion and hunger; was beaten by drunks; plagued by a nearly-fatal viral infection, and risked being shot by North Korean border guards. And that was only the first year!
If you plan to visit China, buy this book before you go. On the other hand, if you are an armchair tourist who never strays far from home, Carter's Portrait will not disappoint. The warmth of the Chinese comes cross in every image from cover to cover. You will laugh along with the Tibetan nomads seeing their photo for the very first time, and scratch your head at the eight-year-old acrobat student at Wuqiao bending herself like a folded sheet of paper.
Between the covers of Portrait, you will start a vicarious journey visiting China like few photographers have ever accomplished. With this thick, 600-page book, you too can travel on this 35,000 mile journey without ever leaving your home. Or better, it will inspire you to make a similar journey.
There is no way that this review can do justice for the monumental accomplishment that is CHINA: Portrait of a People. Seeing is believing.
Lloyd Lofthouse, author of "My Splendid Concubine"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Accent is on The People, June 25, 2010
This review is from: CHINA: Portrait of a People (Paperback)
I've been living in the country for 20+ years, so it's no easy task to capture my attention--or hold it--with a "China" book. But somehow Carter has managed to do so.
Maybe it's the smiles: Warm, infectious, genuine. A positively ancient yet bubbly Beijing couple on the eve of their 55th wedding anniversary. The Yao woman whose front teeth checked out long ago. Or an adorable Uighur girl with a dainty, coffee-colored lace headdress.
Carter documents the astounding variety of the peoples of China, face by face, but he also does a good job of contrasting architecture in different regions. My favorites: The myriad flat rooftops of Tibet's second city, Shigatse; perfectly circular "tulou" communal houses of the Hakka in Fujian; and a sea of sloping roof tiles rippling over Lijiang, Yunnan, perhaps China's best-preserved traditional village.
Just one page of text precedes each of the 33 chapters introducing a municipality, province or autonomous region. Brief, to the point, but not formulaic. Zhejiang is encapsulated by an ancient poem, Qinghai via the words of a 10-year-old Tibetan girl who is worried that her family's nomadic life is doomed, and the humorous text referring to expatriates in the capital, "China's unofficial 57th minority group."
By no means is it all exotic headdresses, ancient architecture and winning smiles; this is not your standard coffee-book tome. Carter doesn't flinch as he profiles victims of industrial accidents, fire and mental illness, some reduced to begging for a living. But, curiously, even they seem to retain a bit of dignity as seen through his eyes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|