I hate making an overly dramatic statement about anything, but I can't help it this time. This is simply the best, most full-featured headset I've ever used. That is, at least for me and the features I care about.
Let me start by saying, I've been an avid PC gamer for as long as there have been sound cards and headsets to go with them. Within the last two years, I've tried out, no less than, 6 different headsets from manufacturers like Asus, Plantronics, Corsair, Turtle Beach, Sennheiser and Logitech. If you're anything like me, you do a lot of review reading to try and figure out what will work best for you. It's amazing how wide the discrepancies can be in headset reviews. In my experience, each headset always had strong weaknesses to go with any strengths. This time, it seems we may have finally broken the mold.
This is what I look for in a gaming headset, and how the Sirus performs (as well as some comparisons to others I've tried).
- Comfort. You're going to be wearing this thing for possibly hours on end--it's no fun to have to keep taking off your headset to rub your head or worse, have to quit because you just can't take it any more. For me this is one of the big highlights of the Sirus headset--it's a really comfortable fit. It doesn't put your head in a vice-grip like the Plantronics GameCom 377 I tried out. I *think* I have a large head, and it fits snug, but is adjustable height-wise, as well as having some free ear cup movement so it adjusts to the back of your head. When putting on a headset, I usually know very quickly if the fit is going to be a problem. After a few hours, these have done what they're supposed to do: let you forget that you're wearing something over your head. Are they the best I've ever worn? NO. They are a little heavy, and still seem a bit tight to me. The old Turtle Beach AK-R8's were the most comfortable because of the headstrap design that let the headset "rest" on your head to stay on instead of relying on "pinching." My comfort rating: 8/10.
- Audio capabilities. I don't keep a separate set of headphones at my computer to switch out when I decide to listen to music. I want to use my headset for gaming, listening to MP3s, and watching videos. As most headsets, the Sirus headset comes with software to adjust the audio settings. The software is very robust, and the sound responds well to the adjustments. There are a lot of advanced features to play with (including a 10-band equalizer), but you might not know it if you don't read the manual because they're hard to find. The equalizer really helps to bring out the best sound you're looking for. I've always thought the environment effects were a gimmick, but they're there if you so choose.
For games, I tried the set out in Call of Duty: World at War and Age of Conan. Each game utilized the headsets capabilities and provided a clear sense of direction of sound, though not always perfect: it can be hard to tell if someone is coming from the front or the back, but maybe that's just me or the limitations of the technology. It was certainly better than the Corsair 2000's simulated 7.1 surround.
For music, my tastes vary greatly, and I audited songs from Smashing Pumpkins, Rush, Metallica, and various 80's pop songs. The sound was good, but sometimes required tweaking if you wanted to hear certain highs or lows accented. Of course, this seems to be the nature of music in general; you emphasize highs on something like Rush's Moving Pictures album, but desire more bass on Metallica's ...And Justice For All. Either way, the Sirus can accommodate whatever sound you're trying to achieve. (Note: RIGHT click on the speaker icon!!). My audio capability rating: 9/10.
- Usability and features. One of the features I've really come to enjoy is the control dial that comes with the Sirus headset. The control dial has buttons to mute the mic, mute the headset, and switch between the various speakers of the headset while the dial itself adjusts the levels of each. The control dial is a weighted, circular device that goes between your headset and the computer. It's a really nice interface to control the volume as well, so you're not fumbling for some kind of in-line cable thing, and the weight of it keeps it from sliding off into your lap. I was also impressed by the fact that CM included analog connections if you didn't want to use the built-in USB audio card. Granted using the analog hookups would eliminate being able to use the control dial, but it's still good to have the option. Again, the software is great, however some of the features can require some searching to find. My usability and feature rating: 9/10.
- Bass. Yes, this might be included under "Audio capabilities," but I felt it was so important that bass needs it's own entry--whether it's for music or for games. Let me start by saying that "good bass" means a lot of different things to different people. Good news. In my opinion, this headset can make everybody "bass happy." I mean that by saying that the bass is so configurable that it will make everybody happy. Yes, that's a bold statement, but I think it's true. Let me give some background.
As a frugal consumer (and what my daughter calls a cheap-skate), I always try and research every semi-important investment I make, headsets are no exception. In the world of headsets, and specifically with bass, I've been misled to think that the size of the driver is everything (e.g., "50mm driver for awesome bass!!"). I've used the Turtle Beach X12 and the Corsair Vengeance 1500 which both have 50mm drivers, and my ears could never tell the difference. What seemed make more of a difference was the frequency response; all of the cans that didn't go any lower than 20Hz seemed to suffer when it came to good bass. I know there are limitations of what the human ear can hear, but cans that have a lower freq. response range always sound better. These are no exception, the range is 10Hz - 20Khz. The Sirus headset uses 40mm, not 50mm, drivers for it's sub sounds and I can't tell a difference.
Along with some of the aforementioned songs, I tried out simple bass lines by U2, Bush (Chemicals Between Us), and Ozzy Osbourne (Zombie Stomp). This headset follows right along with incredible reproduction and accuracy (from a consumer's point of view!).
My favorite bass feature of the Sirus headset has to be the "Flex Bass II" setup. Not only is the bass amplified through the built-in sound card, but you can adjust the "clean-ness" (for lack of a better term) of the bass. This is really cool as it allows you to adjust the bass level as well as the cut off frequency! Moving the frequency slider back and forth makes an incredible difference on how clean the bass is! It's by far the best feature I've seen on a headset. My bass rating: 10/10.
That being said here are some of the things I don't care about (which may or may not be important to you):
- Noise cancelling or sealing out all noise from the outside. The Asus Vulcan ANC set drove me absolutely nuts by completely sealing off my ears from the outside world. While that may sound cool, it felt like I had ear-plugs in and every touch of the headset vibrated in my head--kind of like putting your ear up against a door and listening in. Worse, the "Active Noise Cancelling" they had cuts out ALL bass! Really?! The noise-cancelling headphones I use at work (Sony MDR-NC40) actually improve the bass when noise-cancelling is activated!
- Quiet for others around me. Anytime this is brought up as a "feature", it always seems to compromise performance for the headset. Plus I don't care. :)
- Not being wireless. Of course having the exact headset in a wireless option would be awesome, but you can't get the exact headset. At least, not yet. :)
- Aesthetics. This headset is awesome looking--lighting on the sides, etc.. it's just I don't care.
I used to say, "oh, I'm not an audiophile, but..." Now I just say that I know what I like and I pay attention to statistics, details, and read up on anything I can regarding headset audio. I hope this review can at least steer you in a direction one way or another. I don't write a lot of reviews, but after a such a long and tiring search for a decent headset that fits my needs, I felt compelled to possibly help someone else in the same position.
As a side note: NO, I was not paid, nor given this headset. I bought it straight off the shelf like anybody else would.
#UPDATE# 6/10/2012
I've found an issue with the headset that's apparently a "known issue" on Cooler Master's CM Storm website: the microphone (when in USB mode, i.e. using the control dial) is very weak and won't pick up any bass--almost giving you a chipmunk sound! I apologize for missing this when I originally wrote the review; I didn't notice a problem when I looped the audio back through the headset, but once I got on Ventrilo, the issue became very apparent. I verified the issue with my buddy who bought the same Sirus headset as I did and we joined up to tweak any setting we could. Needless to say, it was a frustrating experience as nothing could get it right.
Cooler Master's website gives the following in their FAQ:
"There is a known problem with the mic sensitivity of Sirus in USB mode being notably weaker than in 3.5mm mode."
Well, the problem goes way beyond just being weaker. They go on to say:
" A few early Sirus Headsets shipped with badly calibrated MICs resulting in poor MIC performance in USB mode."
I'll give them credit for recognizing the problem, but that's nothing without a good resolution.
Read more ›