Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
There is Hope, May 18, 2005
This review is from: A Call to Action (Hardcover)
In "A Call to Action" Pfizer chairman Hank McKinnell makes the observation that the US has a "sick care" system, not a health care system. While the entitites working within this system may be the best at what they do, the lack of a true health care system will continue to impose a growing financial, social, and quality-of-life burden on all. Additionally, the health issues facing the world, such as the HIV/AIDS pandemic, are bigger than any one organization can handle.
Through provocative observations and insightful questions, McKinnell creates a framework for the discussion of this crucial issue. The solution can not lie solely upon private enterprise, governments, NGOs, or individuals, but must be achieved through the concerted efforts of all parties, both public and private. The questions raised in this book provide a necessary framework to both get the dialogue going as well as to organize what may otherwise be considered an overwhelming task. Importantly, this industry veteran shows that there is reason to believe the goal is achievable.
Our healthcare system has profound effects throughout every fiber of our society, from the way we live our lives to the taxes we pay to the role of government in providing for a healthful place in which to pursue our dreams. As such, it is important for all concerned citizens to understand the challenges facing the establishment and maintenance of a true health care system.
"A Call to Action" is a surprising, thought-provoking, and ultimately hopeful challenge to establish a true and sustainable health care system. I strongly recommend this to anyone interested in one of the biggest issues facing the US both today and in the future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A catalyst for debate., July 27, 2005
This review is from: A Call to Action (Hardcover)
Look, there is a lot of misinformation in the media and in public forums about the pharmaceutical industry and healthcare in general. I've read and heard many stories that strike intensely emotional chords where the only purpose is to assign blame or seek out and expose the villainous (whatever moves the print I guess).
The issues in healthcare, both global and domestic, are complex. They are too complex to draw simplistic conclusions about them or apply simplistic solutions toward resolution. To add these issues in affect are intimately personal to almost everyone, almost everywhere.
We need experts who are closely related to the issues on a day-to-day basis to pull apart and reassemble our healthcare system, yes, in a pragmatic way but also with an unprecedented level of objectivity, creativity and compassion.
I believe in this book Dr. McKinnell succeeds in relaying my point above. He also provides the basic building blocks to stimulate thought and he takes us far enough down the path to suggest dramatic changes. I believe we have reached the point of dire necessity. To ignore this would be in my estimation disastrous.
READ THIS BOOK. Take the time to understand and do not draw your conclusions to quickly as some apparently have. I ask that you keep this basic thought in the back of your mind when reading: It takes on average 12 years to bring to market a new drug. Internalize this fact and apply it to your personal situation. Seek out the facts.
These are my own views, take them or leave them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Decent Book Raising Legitimate Questions, July 7, 2005
This review is from: A Call to Action (Hardcover)
Like it or not, to discuss about the healthcare system this book raised some legitimate questions such as sick-care vs prevention-care, free riding on the global market, malpractice law suits, third party payment system, etc.
There are some industry and Pfizer PR stuffs in the book. Anyway, you cannot expect a current CEO of a company to suggest something that would hurt his company or industry. (By the way, Peter Rost seems to be an interesting exception. When he does this, you need to do some research on history and ask why.) Still Hank McKinnell discussed seriously about the overall structural loopholes and possible reforms of the system.
Don't simply blame the pharmaceutical industry as the only "bad" boy in the game. It's true that not everything the companies do seems "right" under the bright sunshine, but who does in capitalism? That's why the system is designed to have balances and checks, while money chasing is the ultimate incentive in the market and real life.
If you know fair amount of biomedical science, you understand how little we know and how difficult it is to develop a novel and really effective and safe treatment under current knowledge. Healthcare as a whole is a very large and complex system. Because of the sensitivity the system deals with, which is the length and quality of human lives, it is already under the toughest regulations among all industries.
If you are open to new ideas and want to seriously think about the healthcare, you may find this book useful to provide some perspectives.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|