From School Library Journal
Grade 6-9-Vice President Coolidge became president after the unexpected death of Warren G. Harding in 1923. This dramatic transfer of power to the Republican former Massachusetts governor in the middle of the night opens the book and a general biography follows. For a leader who was born during Reconstruction and reached the peak of his power during the Roaring Twenties, his life and time in public office is less than captivating; he is basically just what Allen summarizes as a "good- citizen" with a "positive legacy." His presidential tenure saw U.S. tensions with Japan, a strike by coal miners, and the resurgence of not only the KKK, but also speculation in the stock market. An ironic note is that while "Improved Relations with Mexico" is touted on the cover, that nation does not even appear in the index. The final chapter offers a good summary of the man and his arguable importance. While the book is not visually appealing, the elements that make a solid nonfiction title are here in satisfactory amounts: reproductions of source documents, footnotes and source notes, and a further reading list (even if many titles are inaccessible).
Andrew Medlar, Chicago Public Library, ILCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Reviewed with Michael A. Schuman's
George H. W. Bush.
Gr. 6-12. The two newest additions to the United States Presidents series begin with pivotal moments in each man's life: Coolidge being woken in the middle of the night to be sworn in after Harding's sudden death; Bush facing Desert Storm. Then each text moves chronologically, highlighting the leader's childhood, family influences, education, career, and journey to the White House. The authors do an impressive job of emphasizing the strength of character of each president while still providing a balanced assessment of their influence on U.S. history. With fewer personal details to share, Allen explores Coolidge's shy character and analyzes the impact of his stoicism as President. In contrast, Schuman is able to move briskly through Bush's life and his many challenges, successes, and setbacks as a politician. Both biographies will give readers a clear profile of twentieth-century leaders in the context of major events in American history. Roger Leslie
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved