4.0 out of 5 stars
Richard Thomson, Camille Pissarro: Impressionism, Landscape and Rural Labour, October 9, 2011
This review is from: Camille Pissarro: Impressionism, Landscape and Rural Labour (Hardcover)
This volume is the catalogue that accompanied the first major Pissarro exhibition ever to be held in Great Britain outside of London (Birmingham and Glasgow). It was conceived and selected by Richard Thomson as a kind of back-up to the large 1980-81 retrospective mounted ten years before in London, Paris, and Boston (see my review on this website). It has a sharper focus than its predecessor and was intended to recognize and reflect the diverse developments and changes of perspective in Impressionist studies in general and in Pissarro scholarship in particular that were given impetus by the earlier show. These included the first authoritative biography, a thorough study of Pissarro's drawings, the important contributions of Christopher Lloyd and Richard Brettell, and the first three fully annotated volumes of the artist's correspondence: quite a busy decade. In his introduction to this book, Thomson points out that the notions of "immediacy" and "accuracy" that were once commonly used to describe Impressionism have given way to the recognition that Impressionist images are fictions resulting from the artist's choice, editing, and preparatory work, and that they depend on individual ideology and various economic and market forces. In the present case, Pissarro emerges as "an artist of greater diversity and complexity" than we had thought, "a figure rich in paradox" whose career now appears on the whole as "a dialogue between city and country" (8). Thus the exhibit and catalogue concentrated on Pissarro's images of rural labor and markets and on specific locations such as Pontoise and Rouen, and the author is occupied greatly with the artist's concern "not merely with HOW to represent the landscape but also with WHAT the landscape should represent" (12).
Thomson's major theme is that no matter HOW, Pissarro's WHAT is largely a fictionalized image. Thus in the paintings of the Paris suburbs, Thomson shows us how changes in palette, touch, "effet" and other elements give the same stretch of the Seine quite divergent identities. And as far as Pontoise is concerned: despite the fact that it was, during Pissarro's residency there, becoming a virtual satellite of the capital, the artist consistently represented it as essentially still a country town. Thomson refers here to Pissarro's "reluctant awareness of transition" (35) as, toward the end of the 1870's, his representations of L'Hermitage increasingly promoted the "fiction of a rural community" (39) and he was only occasionally willing to admit symbols of modernization into his landscapes. Thomson cites an 1892 interview in which Pissarro refers to manipulating his studio impressions "to create the true poem of the countryside" and Thomson comments correctly that the artist is thus admitting that his art is an "idyllic fiction" (81). Indeed, Thomson calls Pissarro's landscape pictures in the last decade or so of his life "the late rural idylls" (81), in which he is constructing an ideal of a classless community in accord with his anarchist ideology. Thomson is very good in indicating that no matter how much Pissarro has in common with other painters who were also constructing fictional ideals through the manipulation of rural imagery--say, Jules Breton and Leon Lhermitte--it is Pissarro's commitment to anarchist ideals that distinguishes him: whereas Breton and Lhermitte look back in plaintive regret at the loss of traditional values rooted in their national and religious heritage, Pissarro is looking forward to the communitarian ideals of post-revolutionary society (a point recently underlined most forcefully by Richard Brettell in his exhibition and catalogue "Pissarro's People" [cf. my review]).
Thomson's book is an excellent survey of Pissarro's rural art, and together with Brettell's almost simultaneously published "Pissarro and Pontoise: The Artist in a Landscape" (cf. my review), it constitutes a fundamental reassessment of Pissarro as a landscapist. His text is clearly organized and concisely written, and it is all the more pity that it has not been better served by the accompanying illustrations. The author has provided some excellent comparative paintings to illustrate his points about Pissarro's, but many of these are printed too dark to reveal much detail. Of the total of 139 illustrations, only about twenty or so are reproduced in color, and the color is not always very true. This is, then, not a book to purchase for its reproductions, but for its text, which is an outstanding contribution to Pissarro studies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
pissarro, September 2, 2010
This review is from: Camille Pissarro: Impressionism, Landscape and Rural Labour (Hardcover)
hardback book...............8 1/2 x 10 inches..........127 pages long. There are color and black and white photos of art work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No