Among my friends, the appreciation for EL-P's work seems to be arranged in the reverse order of his release dates, with Funcrusher Plus on top and (not including this one) ISWYD on bottom. However, I always resented that dichotomy, because I thought Funcrusher was symptomatic of merging the late 90's era of dark/serious lyrical rap with doses of the comedic "ignorant rap" that was able to thrive prior to 1995 (IE: The Afros, Arsonists, early Gravediggaz, Boogiemonsters, Pharcyde, and anyone else rapping about sudo-fantasy scenarios with tons of skits and goofy voices and stuff). I basically felt that Fantastic Damage improved on the Co Flow aesthetic, and that ISWYD improved on the Fan Dam formula without changing it. Well, this time I sort of agree with my friends, at least in the sense that I cannot easily place Cancer 4 Cure above his previous solo albums. Please note, that in no way do I consider this a sub-par album, because I am a huge EL-P fan and I think his work still stands head-and-shoulders above any of the surviving artists from the school of lyrical rap (that should be redundant, but unfortunately rap is no longer focused on quality or quantity of lyrics). I wish I could say he is at the forefront of the re-emergence of lyrical rap, but despite the re-emergence part being true, he is not at the forefront of it (as of right now), except in my mind because I think EL-P, Black Thought, Aesop Rock, Busdriver (arguably in a genre of his own), and Del the Funky Homosapien are the most skilled lyricists who remained active throughout the rise and fall of the lyrical (formerly known as "East Coast") style of rap.
So, what the heck am I saying about this album? Well, compared to anything like it (as if) by any other artist, it totally destroys everything, as far as the skilled vocal and beat delivery. However, there are some notable distinctions from his prior work. First off, the level of the vocals in the mix: EL-P has faced a fair amount of criticism (at least among my friends) for burying his vocals too low in the mix. As if to respond to this, he now has the vocals shoved WAY up in your face. If you think I am exaggerating, just turn your volume to 1/4 for the 2-6 track and you will notice that you can only hear tid-bits of the beat trying to lurk around his overpowering vocal. Not only is the vocal very loud especially in the front end of the album, but that half is also a touch more angry and (arguably) shouty (maybe it just seems that way because of the mix, etc.).
Again, don't attack me yet; we all love EL-P, and I'm not dissing this album. It is tough to turn anyone on to this, unless they have followed the evolution of hip-hop from it's goofy 80's bounce, through the forceful rock textures of Rick Rubin's beats and the emergence of gangster rap, into the ricochet influence that led New York into a much darker and more violent sound, through the emergence of Southern rap, which led to the current state of predominately less lyrical "blog rap." If you followed all that, then I can play this for you without preface, otherwise for people basically just checking in, I feel the need to explain why this dude is lobbing a million angry words a minute into your earhole. That is funny to me, as a child of the 80s/90s who previously grew accustomed to defending EL-P's beats to people who loved the lyrical approach but didn't get everything else El-P did when he was not aiming for throw-back moments.
So, what else is different here? I do not agree with Pitchfork.com calling this a reinvention along the lines of Portishead "3." The style/approach changes here are mostly subtle. The vocals are turned up, he lets the beats play out uninterrupted more often (as opposed to stacking a million sampled sound snippets in every open space), and due to less excursions it feels like a shorter and more cohesive unit. In no way does this album feel cobbled together in the cut-and-paste way his last two did. At that time he seemed to just be decorating around the centerpiece of his "bangers." Also, there are some other notable differences in the design, he placed all his guest rappers dead center of the album on two back-to-back posse cuts (basically showing-off his tour-mates, with the exception of Danny Brown's awkward disposable verse, compared to Despot and Exquire's more essential verses), rather than his old approach of sprinkling as many emcees from the DefJux roster as possible in every nook and cranny (though he does utilize a couple of Camu Tao samples). In keeping with a move he made on ISWYD, he does have a couple of songs featuring indie-rock-based vocalists, one from Interpol (although I cannot tell which song without looking up the credits), and a more noticeable appearance by the Islands singer late in the album on "Stay Down" (a stand-out track, for me). This time the indie singers appear in a more fleeting way, and the majority of the album is raw EL-P with an album intro and outro, but not a ton of twists and turns. Basically this is Jaime (that's his name) in his rawest form.
How much you like this depends on what you compare it to. It works well as a companion to Killer Mike's new album (produced by EL-P), because even though this is a version of EL-P that is less mean-spirited, Killer Mike works a lot harder to infuse a heart-and-soul aesthetic rather than the non-stop aggressive and heavy-hearted "fight music" EL-P aims for. El has a grim outlook, while Mike remains more hopeful and presents himself as a family man who's minor gun talk comes off as protective. However, I miss the vocals being buried in the mix more so that the beats bang up front more, and I miss the intro-to-the-intro-of-the-intro approach that led his last two albums to be more detailed with samples like Paul's Boutique. Instead, this is a VERY strait-forward album for El, where his use of vocal effects (vocoder, pitch shifter, etc.) do not replace or come off as samples, although they seem to be aiming for that niche, his beats are given more breathing room in those spots, and his harsh tone is so raw at times that it's almost rapid-fire spoken word. However, do not let this distract you from buying it. Comparing a genius to himself is always more nit-picky than comparing them to any of the idiots they dwarf in the current industry.
Get this, then go get his other three albums I mention...actually, you probably already have them. If not, then I'm impressed you just now stumbled on this guy and he didn't scare you off. These days it's easier to sell people on his (now very current-sounding) beats. There are just not a lot of rappers out right now who are employing this barking-dog aesthetic. Judging by the sound of the second half of this album where his tone mellows, and his themes are less "rapey" than his usual B-side antics, even EL-P might not be wearing his barking-dog mask for a lot longer. Get it, get barked at, be scared. It's fun!