I had been saving up for some time for the
Canon EOS 5D MarkIII. I wanted to upgrade from crop sensor Canon to full frame Canon. I saved the money up, and just as I was prepared to pull the trigger, along came an unexpected windfall that essentially doubled the cash at my disposal. I researched, and awaited reviews (and pre-release reviews/thoughts) for a few months to decide if I would prefer a lens and 5D MkIII or "just" a 1Dx.
I went with a 1Dx, based on my desire to own top of the line and not be limited by the tool in my hand. I couldn't be happier.
I am not a professional. I am simply a photography student and photography enthusiast that had too much money available to him when making a purchase. Moving from cropped sensor, via my 3 year old
Canon XSi, to full frame, was an eye opening experience.
Weight:
On its own, this camera is just shy of 3.5 (3.4) lbs or 1.54 kg. It is HEAVY when compared to any cropped sensor camera. The size and weight still over shadows a crop prosumer DSLR, even with the battery grip installed (mine was roughly 1.6 lbs or 725 g and the 7D, top of the line crop prosumer, would be right around 2 lbs w/ grip).
Add on a quality L series lens, such as the
Canon EF 70-200mm f/2.8L IS II USM, not unheard of for wedding photographers, and you're looking at just north of 6 lbs (2.72 kg), and you have a heavy beast of a camera.
And the first thing you will want to do, and in fact, I would recommend you purchase along with the camera, is to replace the poor, poor quality Canon neck strap. Yeah, the gold colored embroidery is nice, but I'm sorry, for this price you can't include a strap of a higher quality and usefulness than what's provided with Canon's "bottom of the price barrel" DSLRs? I went with a
OP/TECH USA 1501012 Pro Strap, which turned up only a few days ago. I plan to write up a full review on that when I have used it long enough to properly review it. This isn't just a Canon flaw. Nikon, Sony, Pentax and Olympus all suffer from poor neck straps included. Of course, most professionals that have been working in photography for years already have a brand and model strap they prefer - for those just moving to into the ranks of full frame cameras, you will definitely want to watch the strap.
Ease of Use:
If this is your first DSLR, you're in for a steep learning curve. If you're accustomed to a non-weather proofed Canon, you're in for a smaller adjustment. In order to keep the 1Dx properly weather resistant, Canon uses buttons for anything and everything possible. WB, ISO, etc. are all set with buttons. The dials are used for aperture and similar type function changes, but most everything is button based.
Overall, the buttons, for my medium sized hands, seem to be properly and appropriately placed. I'm finding that I can have my finger on the shutter button, press the AF button and then control the little joystick on the camera without looking and by feel alone. After using the camera for roughly 2 hours in near complete darkness, I think the button configuration is about as close as you can get to perfect.
The additional portrait style shutter release, which includes all of the AF functions and the dial, means battery grips aren't needed. And to conserve power, you can actually turn this function "off" until you need it. I'm finding I just leave it on, as sometimes I like to recompose to portrait just to see how things look. It's great to finally have a camera where this capability isn't added as an afterthought.
One thing I really appreciate is the button that can be pressed to light up the 2 camera LCD displays. These are not to be confused with the LCD monitor as Canon calls it on the rear of the camera. These are the displays that show you WB, ISO, Aperture, etc. In darkness, this function is a life saver and I'm sure they've had this on previous bodies - it is my first experience with it. The orange color didn't ruin my night vision, which is an added bonus.
An oversight on a camera with such a tremendous ability in near complete darkness shooting, is that none of the buttons have any lighting at all. You had better study your camera in detail and know it front to back, top to bottom, if you plan on any real night shooting. The argument could be made that this lighting could affect AF or some other camera function, but perhaps there's some way to link this to a certain length of time and when you depress the shutter button half way, it turns those lights off? Long and short of it is, if you shoot in darkness, "know thy camera."
AF in AI Servo mode is nothing short of amazing. There's a certain joy to mounting a high quality lens to this camera, picking it up, pointing at your chosen AF point and it takes almost no time to focus - THEN it can follow the subject near perfectly no matter where it heads. I've tried several of the AI Servo AF modes and this is where I plan to focus my learning next. The results I've gotten from just a few weeks with the camera are very good - once I know what I'm doing and which mode to use and when, I'll go from very good to great. I've captured images with this camera that my old XSi would have never been able to compete.
The camera is complicated. It's not something you'll pick up and "know" right out of the box. It has a learning curve.
Image Quality:
At normal ISO ranges, 100-1600, images are high quality and sharp. I've yet, even without any processing in Digital Photo Professional (or my preferred tool,
Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 4), had anything that needed any large amount of sharpening, if at all. Low to no noise is order of the day for these ISO ranges.
Bumping into the 2000 - 12,600 range, you start to see some noise creeping in. I would say that at 12,600, the results are STILL better than the highest ISO of my old XSi (1600) and actually usable for prints. At 13x19 print size, you need to denoise a little, but they are still quite sharp at those ISOs.
Bumping into the 25,000+ range, you can probably pull off 8x10 quality. At 52,000 you will want to really shrink that image if you want to print.
The two "H" modes - 102,400 and 204,800, are essentially useless for prints. If you absolutely have to get the shot in complete darkness, this might give you a result, but it won't be decent, and it won't be something any paying customer is likely to want to pay for. It's a novelty, and I guess it's nice to have, but in real world photography, most users won't bother going there.
To me, it's amazing how far we've come in just the short time since the first Canon DSLR (D30...not the Kodak rebrands) was released. ISO was 1600. 12 years later, we have a camera that is capable of 128x the ISO range. It's only a matter of time before the big camera manufacturers can offer the 204,800 ISO and actually have it usable...
In terms of contrast, dynamic range and color, even discounting the 6 MP advantage over my XSi, the 1Dx provides some of the best dynamic range I've ever had the pleasure to see from a DSLR. And yes, I've used and seen RAW images from more than just my own XSi
Advantages:
12 fps burst mode. The sound of this is something that simply has to be heard. It's such a satisfying sound the first time you hear it. And with AI Servo, capturing that one sport shot you've always wanted, the bird in flight, the dog mid-jump... whatever fast action you want to grab, I can almost guarantee you'll have an easier time capturing it with this camera. No doubt.
Super-fast AF. This cannot be stressed enough. Mating the 70-200 mkII to this camera, picking up the camera, aiming and pressing the shutter button takes fractions of a second. In the high speed world of sports photography, this would be a heaven send.
Phenomenal low light performance. I've visited the Longwood Gardens Bruce Munro Lights display twice. The first time, I took my XSi and tripod. The second time, I took the 1Dx. I captured images, albeit at 12,600, hand held, that I could only achieve on tripod with the XSi. Granted, I can't hand hold at ISO 100 and have anything usable, but the quality, even at 12,600, is more than usable for any size print I personally will want. If I can't capture the image I want now, then it's almost certainly the photographer and not the camera.
Potential Issues:
As others have complained, the AF points only light up when AF lock is achieved. When you shoot in AI Servo, these lights NEVER light up. The workaround that I've found that is serviceable, is to hit the AF point button, have all the points light up, choose my AF point and compose my shot keeping this point in mind. This is a rather shoddy way to have to do things, but it does work. It's quite an oversight on Canon's part, but one I can personally work around.
Of course, if you only shoot during the day, this is probably less of an issue, or probably a non-issue. The hope on the Internet is Canon will fix this with a firmware upgrade. In my mind, the argument made thus far about why it is setup the way it is, is for AF and light metering.
Read more ›