5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A classic and a disaster, December 15, 2004
This review is from: Cape Fear (1991)/Cape Fear (1962) (DVD)
"Cape Fear" is a classic example of psychological horror and suspense -- what if you and your family were being threatened by a conscienceless killer, yet had no way of stopping him? What lengths would you go to? This two-pack includes both the original 1962 version and the inferior 1991 remake.
The original stars Gregory Peck as Sam Bowden, a successful attorney, who seems to be living the American dream -- he has a beautiful house, a loving wife, sweet daughter, and lots of friends. Then one day, a man named Max Cady (Robert Mitchum) arrives in town; Bowden put him in prison for several years, and now he wants revenge.
But Cady doesn't directly attack Bowden or his family -- he begins a series of mind games, toying with Bowden's head by assaulting a young woman (who is too frightened to speak out), following Bowden's daughter at school, and subtlely threatening Mrs. Bowden. Finally Bowden hires a trio of thugs to attack Cady, but that backfires. Finally, the desperate Bowden stashes his family aboard a houseboat, and lies in wait to finish Cady off when he finally comes...
The remake has the same general plot, but Scorsese tries to beef it up and make it edgier, making Cady a tattooed thug and making Nick Nolte's Bowden almost as creepy and sleazy as Cady. And while the idea of the plot is decidedly creepy, it doesn't fit in the 1990s, when stalking laws had been put into place.
Unfortunately, Scorsese doesn't seem to understand what made the original such a horrific experience -- the THREAT of Cady raping the wife and daughter is more ominous than having Cady seduce the girl. Moreover, making Bowden a sleazy, adulterous creep undermines the whole point of the original movie -- a good man driven to possible crimes to protect his family.
While Nolte's portrayal of Bowden is almost nauseating, Gregory Peck's performance is outstanding. Peck was usually cast as the straight-shooter, but here that casting is twisted as Bowden is willing to even descend to murder if it keeps his wife and daughter from being attacked. Robert De Niro is miscast as Cady in the remake, turning him into a run-of-the-mill thug without the brains for a cat-and-mouse game. Mitchum, on the other hand, is eerily, creepily effective as a superintelligent stalker-rapist. (Censoring of the time did not allow direct references to rape, but it's an overhanging threat)
The original "Cape Fear" is a magnificently horrific suspense movie, with a dynamic cast and solid script. Just don't bother with the remake -- it's the twisted twin of the original.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
WHY A REVIVAL ?, August 28, 2010
This review is from: Cape Fear (1991)/Cape Fear (1962) (DVD)
I APPRECIATED THE THOMPSON FILM FOR ITS GENUINE TENSION WHILE I HAVE FELT REAL DISGUST FOR THE SCORSESE REVIVAL WHICH, WITH ITS SPECIAL EFFECTS, SWEARING AND VIOLENCE, HAS ONLY DISTURBED ME. THE CAST SOUNDS COMPLETELY FALSE AND BOTHERSOME. LANGE IS IRRITATING. DE NIRO, EVEN IF PARTICULARLY ABLE, GIVES THE IDEA OF A SELF-COMPLACENCY IN ACTING LIKE THAT. I NOW REGRET HAVING BOUGHT THIS SET. THE THOMPSON FILM WOULD HAVE BEEN SUFFICIENT FOR MY COLLECTION.
ERNESTO OPPICELLI - GENOVA CERTOSA - ITALY
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fabulous, July 23, 2007
This review is from: Cape Fear (1991)/Cape Fear (1962) (DVD)
Both these films are worth getting, but as a double bill this becomes a great purchase. If anything the original film is the better of the two, but don't under-estimate Scorcese's remake, its a powerful film in its own right, but just a little over the top.
Gregory Peck and Robert Mitchum star in the original 1961 version, and Scorcese gave them both small roles in the remake. Nick Nolte and Robert DeNiro star in the remake. DeNiro worked out seriously for this role, and although aged 49 at the time, when you watch the opening scene (the last to be filmed) you can see he was in tremendous shape. He was working out for hours every day before filming. The main difference between the two films is that in the original version the Bowden family are basically 'good' and Max Cady (Robert Mitchum) is 'evil'. In the remake this is much less clear cut, and the family have problems. Cady is also given some legal basis for being unhappy with Sam Bowden (Nick Nolte) in the remake, although this is no justification for his actions of course.
Its worth mentioning Bernard Herrmanns teriffic score which was adapted for the remake as well. If Hitchcock had had the chance he would have used this, its very sinister, with a memorable hook.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
