10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
THE definitive remastering of the Original Soundtrack, July 17, 2007
This review is from: Captain From Castile [Original Motion Picture Soundtrack] (Audio CD)
Along the years I have made several reviews on remasterings and recordings of this Score. I do like, especially, Facet's 44-minute remastering, as well as Charles Gerhardt's recording. No doubt, great events in the history of film music.
But this double CD is the SUMMIT of all prior remasterings. SAE and FOX have discovered the original masters of the Soundtrack, and have produced the DEFFINITIVE and OFFICIAL release of the score, as it was recorded by Alfred Newman. The double CD includes 96:31 minutes of music. The booklet is very clear: the remastering is ALMOST the whole score AND in stereo. There is ONLY ONE missing cue, not very important, and, except the main title, everything is in STEREO, thanks to the computer advances which permit to create stereo versions from Newman's early two-microphone recordings. There are even some cues corresponding to beatiful Spanish-flavoured source music composed by Spanish guitarist Vicente Gómez.
If you have Tsunami's version, please discard it. If you have Facet's version, you can keep it, because it deserves a place as a very good attempt of early remastering of a symphonic suite of the score. Obviously you MUST always keep Gerhardt's re-recording, which is part of the history of Film Music.
At the moment when I write this review (July 2007) this release is still extant in the market. You can get it at Screen Archives Entertainment and Intrada. In the future, I am certain it will be a treasure.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Membran reissue of Tsunami. Not necessary., February 26, 2006
The CD which appears in the main photograph is the MEMBRAN reissue of the Tsunami edition of the Original Soundtrack. For a while it was very good, because it was the most complete available remasterization of the original recording. And it was quite good, with around 75 minutes of music, in mono, and a very acceptable sound. But, please never forget that Tsunami editions do not employ the best sources for their releases, and every day Tsunami reissues turn outdated when US based companies discover and remaster the original recordings.
Not long ago SAE issued an official double CD, authorized by 20th. Century Fox, with the whole (or almost complete) Original Soundtrack, and, morover, in stereo. That must be considered the definitive edition. I understand it is still available at Intrada. And it has around 95 minutes of music.
Cosequently, if you can, get the SAE edition.
If you cannot, try directly with the TSUNAMI edition, which is still extant in Europe (amazon.co.uk). It is a double CD which also includes THE SNAKE PIT (also by Alfred Newman).
Only in the last place get this MEMBAN reedition of Tsunami.
Now, if you ask my advise, the edition of around 45 minutes by FACET (there is a comment written by me there), is a very good suite, apparently also assembled using elements of the Original Soundtrack, easier to find in the US and cheaper. In my opinion, a person who loves this score for CAPTAIN FOR CASTILE should have only three versions:
1) SAE's double CD (95 min.)
2) FACET's Symphonic Suite (45 min.)
3) Charles Gerhardt's CD Captain from Castile (6 minutes rerecording).
If you have them, Tsunami's or Membran's editions are superfluos.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Soundtrack rarity, October 13, 2010
This review is from: Captain From Castile [Original Motion Picture Soundtrack] (Audio CD)
Sometimes the music score for a movie is like a co-star. This Alfred Newman score achieves that stardom. The "Conquest" theme was commercialized soon after the pictures release. The structure of film scores is forever influenced by this score. And this is the original stereo score assembled from the studio archives.
This is as complete a movie score from original sources. It is Alfred Newman's work. There are excerpted recreations that are fine samples of the music. This recording is the composers best work. It is a collectors "must have" item.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No