Customer Reviews

Carlucci 3-in1

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

"Carlucci" is often lumped in with cyberpunk, but it really has nothing to do with virtual reality or artificial intelligence or any of the computer and network focus that resides at the heart of that genre. "Carlucci" in truth is three hard-boiled detective yarns set in a down-and-really-out mid-21st century San Francisco.

As another reviewer mentions, the first tale isn't actually about Carlucci, but the story does set the stage for the SF police detective's starring role in the second two tales. The three stories are distinct and complete, not linked other than by the occassional re-appearance of minor characters.

The plots were involved enough to hold my interest, but not so convoluted that I lost track of what was happening. But Russo's real strength is in his descriptive power and ability to elicit our empathy for many of the scumbags that lurk in his gritty world. "Stark" might be the best word to describe how Russo describes the chaos and tensions of a Bay Area polarized into a gleaming Financial District and the Tenderloin, a teeming zone of danger and opportunity for outcasts, thugs and perverts. I found myself aching at times with the poignancy with which these novels are drawn.

"Carlucci" always fascinates. The strange and bizarre constantly crawl across the page. There is little in the way of flashy technology, gadgets and science. Instead, the book's weirdness is rooted firmly in its main characters and supporting cast. Russo envisions a segment of society for whom all taboo and restriction has broken down. Mutilated "spikeheads", insane "head cages", Inquisitor-like "saints", ultra-intelligent but bloated "slugs", the fervently religious "screamers" with their mouths surgically sewn shut... Russo keeps the parade of pervsion coming hard and fast.

And in the middle of it all is Carlucci, a career detective with a normal family, a fondess for the jazz trumpet, and a dependence on black coffee that is as relentless as his pursuit of whatever scraps of justice he can scavenge from a corrupt system. Another reviewer felt Carlucci's basic goodness made him less interesting, but I found it actually heightened the sense of peril as you so desperately want things to turn out well at least for this one poor guy. There are plenty of morally suspect and flawed characters present to impart a sense of hazard. And believe me, you won't forget the baddies, either. Russo rarely relies on a Stephen King-like shock factor, eschewing graphic violence and gore in favor of mood, suspense and dialogue.

One caveat. These are relentlessly sad stories. There are some lighthearted moments, but the overall atmosphere is dark and gritty and depressing. Carlucci is one guy making his way in a rotten system. All victories are Pyrrhic. Main characters die, with zero regard for age, gender or moral fortitude. Like Carlucci and the rest of his society, you'll just have to live with that.

As much as I want to give this omnibus 5 stars, I just can't. I've seen what Russo can do when he's at the top of his game (just pick up a copy of "Ship of Fools" and you'll get what I mean) and the three books that comprise this volume don't quite cut it.

This does not mean that "Carlucci" ain't worth the read. Far from it. Russo does a wonderful job sidestepping most all of the red-herrings and cliches that normally clutter the cyberpunk genre. Sure, there are a few here. Good cops going up against shadowy corporations. Police officers driven to alcoholism and suicide by the things they see on a daily basis. Etc...

Russo's 21st San Francisco occupies such a vivid world, generates such intense interest in the reader, that idiotic chase scenes, useless gunplay and overly graphic violence are all unnecessary. The intrigue, the characters, and the story are all that's needed. Russo delivers.

As I said before, "Carlucci" does not compare to Russo's masterwork, "Ship of Fools". Whereas "Ship of Fools" took on themes of spirituality, alienation and love (not to mention a decent dose of horror) and ran with them, the books collected in "Carlucci" are straightforward detective novels set in the future.

I have one complaint. The major character of the first "Carlucci" book, "Destroying Angel", is NOT Frank Carlucci, but Louis Tanner, a burnt-out ex-cop who trafficks in illegal medicine. I liked Tanner. Alot. I felt a little cheated when the later books, "Carlucci's Edge" and "Carlucci's Heart" eschewed the Tanner character entirely. While Carlucci is interesting, he's a cop anti-stereotype. He's still married. Loves his family. Doesn't drink or smoke to excess and isn't given to violence as a way to solve his issues. In short, the man has some principles. Its a nice idea, but it makes everything seem a little less than dangerous.

Despite that, "Carlucci" is still a compelling read.

Ruso is a top flight writer of science fiction. In this collection of his `Carlucci' novels he shows why he is also a first rate writer of mysteries. He deftly combines the genre in a manner so that readers of either SciFi or Mystery will be satisfied. I recommend these in this volume or individually. There is enough difference to interest anyone.

My major comment and the reason for my title is the really glum, despondent, morose . . .I think of run out of synonyms here. Ruso really paints a bleak and scary picture of the close future. I remember a article I think Ray Bradbury wrote years ago. He said that on days when he felt especially good, he'd write a quick dismal story just to get all traces of depression out of his system. Maybe that is what Ruso is doing here. Although most of them of a quick nod to emotional uplift at the end, they are, for the most part really bleak views of the world.

Don't let that turn you off unless you are a perpetual Pollyanna; we all need a dose of the blues from time to time.

First, to the person who wrote the review stating that the book was like 'Blade Runner without the flying cars'. You have to take the time to read the short story the movie is based on. Also, take some time to watch the movie once again. Neither have much to do with a police or detective novel, they are just caged in one; instead telling a story about humanity and what makes a person a person.

I say this because I think that is what's going on in the Carlucci books. Humanity is lost in the age of technology and that man is a victim to his own advancement -- ie the constant heat and strange colored skies. The characters in these works all seem to have remembered their humanity, but must face a world in which it may be lost.

Overall, they are very deeply-written works.

I would have gone for a full 5 stars here but I found myself a bit bored with the last work in the collection, and was only interested in what happened to Carlucci's daughter.

Cyberpunk genre has a lot of fantasy. This trio of books doesn't - it has a very probable reality. Grittier than any other cyberpunk you'll find (Gibson, Sterling, Stephenson) it doesn't pull punches to give you a warm fuzzy. What's going on in the real world now - this is a real outcome. Starts with "Destroying Angel" where Carlucci is a secondary character, then the other 2 have him as the main. Many may not like these because they're not an escape, they're eye-opening. Bad things happen. I read all three seperate before this compilation - thank you for making this trio as it is a MUST read for Cyberpunks and futurists.

I never write reviews but this is a must read for any sci-fi fan who likes a good detective story. Great writing, great setting, great characters, very entertaining... it's the whole package, a true gem.

I bought this book believing it to be by the same Richard Russo who wrote Mohawk, Empire Falls, Straight Man and Nobody's Fool. Well, slap me silly, how was I to know the difference when Amazon have the books of both authors all listed together. Since I was now the proud owner of a book I no longer wanted, what else do you do with it but read it? I mean, with a hefty 624 pages you could also use it to prop up the end of your sofa!

On a serious note, if you are a reader of futuristic detective novels, you will probably enjoy Carlucci. In my opinion, this author does not possess the literary skills of Richard Russo (Richard Russo without the Paul, that is) but Carlucci does have some interesting plots and is filled with lots of action and excitement.

Beware misleading listing here at Amazon as to their confusion in putting books by Richard Russo(author par excellant) and those by Richard Paul Russo ( author medicore), on the same page.