Customer Reviews

Carnival

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Part way through this closely observed, and ultimately depressing, novel, I began noticing an odd affinity for "The Sun Also Rises" which I had not read in decades. Soon it became apparent that this was more than a passing similarity but rather a retelling of the story set in contemporary Trinidad during Carnival, complete with vivid descriptions of food, drink, and in this retelling, drugs, with Trini slang playing the role that Spanish did in the original, adding to the exotic color. (The Carnival setting for retelling the story also recalls Marcel Camus' "Orfeo Negro.")

Having not read the original in a long time, I cannot remember how Hemingway captures the bacchanalian haze into which his protagonist descends, and I not sure if it was Antoni's writing, or my own jet-lag, but pretty soon the endless Caribs and joints did get hazy. This being the 21st century, the remake is more explicit than the original - the putative source of Jake/William's sexual difficulties is not left to the imagination, though the novel is sufficiently open-ended along many dimensions that one is left space to draw their own conclusions. Love does not conquer all, but it would be happy to think so.