Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Granny and Nanny versus the undead, February 5, 2004
This review is from: Carpe Jugulum (Mass Market Paperback)
Those of us who grew up watching Hammer films know better than to invite a vampire into our castle. But suppose you are the new jester-turned-king of a small principality on Discworld, and you want to be friends with all of your neighbors, even if they happen to be undead. (Hint: always check to see if a country has a disproportionate number of 24-hour Walgreens before issuing your invitations).Not only does King Verence invite a family of vampires to his daughter's christening, his invitation to the powerful witch, Granny Weatherwax goes mysteriously astray. Foopahs abound. Granny Weatherwax closes up her cottage as though she never means to return. Her friend and fellow-witch, Nanny Ogg is upset by King Verence's choice of a priest of Om as the official baptizer--a priest who relies on bits of strategically placed paper to jog his uncertain memory--which is how the little princess ends up with the name 'Esmerelda Margaret Note Spelling of Lancre.' Of course, Lancre did once have a king named, 'My God He's Heavy the First.' This is obviously going to shape up as one of the most disastrous christenings since Sleeping Beauty got the shaft (or more correctly, the spindle) from the thirteenth fairy godmother. Then events take a turn for the worse when the vampires happily chow through Nanny Ogg's special garlic dip without a single rumble of indigestion. I love all of the Granny Weatherwax/Nanny Ogg Discworld novels, and even though "Carpe Jugulum" tackles some unusually serious themes (its vampires are truly evil, unlike the loveable, teetotalling Otto in "The Truth"), it is still vintage Pratchett and vintage Granny. It is amazing how an author of such absurd fantasies can still convey such a bone-chilling description of evil. Pratchett is much more than a 'simple' comic novelist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Deja Vu, November 12, 2001
This review is from: Carpe Jugulum (Mass Market Paperback)
This is just one of umpteen reviews, so I'll skip the summary. In fact, the only reason I'm reviewing this AT ALL is that I bought the book through Amazon, so every time I write a review of something else, they remind me I still haven't reviewed this one.But, after having it for months, I've finally started to read it. Wow, I'm glad that I did! Let's be honest. The plot is really secondary to the characters. And that is where PTerry shines. He gives us characters with motivations and passions, likes and fears, and he lets the humor flow from that, rather than forcing a plot point to make the humor come out. PTerry's humor is never forced. However, as many have pointed out, this plot is a re-hasing of Lords and Ladies. Without a doubt, Lords and Ladies is my favorite. So when this plot also takes place in Lancre with an outside force of supernatural beings assaulting the kingdom, it felt like I was coming back to a well-eorn fable. I knew the plot, and I could concentrate on reading about the characters. And we learn so much about the characters this time. Nanny Ogg and Agnes get some great treatment this time around (which they lacked in previous books), and even Granny Weatherwax gets some new twists. The characters are delicious. Why a four star rating instead of a five, then? Because PTerry wasn't as inventive this time. In Lords and Ladies, we see Elves in a different way. Cliches are broken, mangled, played with, and twisted. But the Vampires (vampyrs, as they prefer) are somewhat mundane. One of them is even named Vlad, for Pete's sake! PTerry certainly did give us a new take on some of the traits of the Vampires, but they didn't get the much-needed overhaul that the Elves got previously. Otherwise, an entertaining, highly-readable, highly-quotable book (as Discworld books tend to be). But it's still the younger, less successful brother compared to Lords and Ladies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Consistency is a GOOD THING, September 5, 2000
This review is from: Carpe Jugulum (Mass Market Paperback)
David Brin once said that it is harder to write science fiction than fantasy because readers expect more from a writer than do fantasy fans. Readers of fantasy prefer, Brin said, to read the same plot over and over, while science fiction fans want something brand-new each time.Pratchett certainly recycles a lot of material and characters, and "Carpe Jungulum" is no exception. We get to see our friends of Lancre again, including the three -- no, now four -- witches, the king and queen and the current villains, a group of so-current vampires. Magic gets used and misused, our heroes are challenged - even Granny Weatherwax! - and right (or at least pretty good) prevails. Nothing new as far as plot goes. So Brin is pretty much right, and Pratchett's Discworld® stories are retellings of similar plots. And so what? In Discworld® the plots are merely frameworks for what brings us back for more Pratchett stories. We read Tom Clancy for engaging plots, but we read Pratchett for humor, insight, humor, character, dialog, humor, and satire. In this book, Pratchett more than satisfies. His portrayal of the hipper-than-thou vampires - excuse me, "vampyres" - and the "modernization at any cost" king are proper zings to things that should be zinged. Igor is exactly what an Igor should be, and his dog Scraps is indescribable. Other notable characters include Agnes and Perdita, two personalities in one comfortable body, Hodgesaargh the single-minded falconer, Mightily Oats the priest who was of two minds about his calling, and the Nac mac Feegle, the roughest, toughest bunch of little people since "The Terror of Tiny Town." My only minor complaint is the phoenix, the role of which in the denouement confused me considerably. The other 350 pages were terrific, though. Read this book, and, as Granny says, "Don't go spilling allegory all down your shirt." Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|