42 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ah! loved it!, May 2, 2010
This review is from: The Carrie Diaries (Hardcover)
While the criticism regarding the book not being in line with the show: yeah. But who cares? We all know that the original Sex and the City book had not much in common with series 2-6. And did we like series 2-6? Yes we did.
So, just read the book, because it's effing good!
Sneaked into the toilets to read the first chapter on my Kindle (hooray! Kindle!) and I got immediately hooked. Didn't want to go back to work, just wanted to read the rest.
What can I say...it's a high school story, with all the high school drama, very readable, Carrie-in-the-book truly is recognizable as Carrie-in-the-series/films, liked the characters. The story wasn't very 'high literature' of course, but it is so well written, that at no point the story or the characters are flat. Like the hint of feminism in it. The ending was marvelous and left me with goosebumps all over my arms.
Hope Bushnell will write another book starting where she left off with this one, I honestly do.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Back Story, May 18, 2010
I came to the SATC party just recently and have been enjoying the series on DVD. Having said that, I may not know everything there is to know about Carrie, but I think that from what I've seen...this book is totally believable. It took me some time to get into the story and I was frustrated with Carrie for caring about a boy who frankly is no Mr. Big. But, she's a senior in high school and this is what high school is like. You want a boyfriend to have a boyfriend, it isn't always the best thing for you. I felt that this book really takes off in the last fourth when Carrie leaves for New York. That was the point that I couldn't put it down. I am hoping for another book because I'd really like to see Carrie in NY with all the gals. I would say to people out there. If you love the series, this is a good book. It's true to the spirit of Carrie.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A good quick read, but NOT the SATC we know and love, May 21, 2011
This review is from: The Carrie Diaries (Hardcover)
While I admit I didn't finish reading Candace Bushnell's original "Sex and the City" due to the fact that I found SJP's Carrie much more lovable than her original portrayal, I don't see many links between the Carrie of "The Carrie Diaries" and the Carrie of the TV series.
First of all, "The Carrie Diaries" has Carrie and her two younger sisters being raised by her father after her mother has passed away. In Season 4, I believe, Carrie's editor at Vogue (the one who surprised her in the Vogue Closet in his briefs) asks Carrie about her father and Carrie replies, "There's not much to tell...He skipped out on my mom and me when I was pretty young." She is then shown peeking at an antique photo of her and her father that she keeps in a copy of Salinger's "Catcher in the Rye."
Next, in Season 5, Carrie reunites with her high school boyfriend, Jeremy, who is seeking mental health treatment in Connecticut. "Jeremy" is no where to be found in "The Carrie Diaries."
In TCD, Carrie talks about cooking at home from Julia Child's cookbook to provide stability for her younger sister. I'm fairly certain Carrie never mentions siblings in the series. She also "stores sweaters in [her] oven," "Triscuits from the mid-80's," and "an old bottle of Kahlua, somewhere." She loves that Aiden and Big cook. That doesn't sound like someone who'd make coq au vin in high school, does it.
I don't buy the whole swim team/diving thing. I just don't. At the end of TCD, Carrie has been accepted to Brown and many of her classmates were heading for Ivy League schools. The valedictorian of my graduating class tried to get into Brown, and failed. Maybe it is massively different if you are the daughter of an alumnus, as the Carrie of TCD is purported to be. Aside from that, Carrie never specifically mentions her education in the TV series, but again, Brown?!
In one of the earlier seasons, Carrie is held up at gunpoint and robbed of her bag, jewelry, and Manolos. She says she's never been mugged before, but in TCD, her purse is lifted almost immediately upon arrival. Also, she contacts Samantha Jones, a cousin of a high school acquaintance who's in advertising, as a last resort after having her bag stolen. The second SATC movie states that she met Samantha while Samantha was bartending at CBGB. The second movie also has Miranda as the first of her three friends that she connects with.
There are many, many more inconsistencies that turned me off to the book. If you read it without expecting the HBO Carrie, it's a quick and easy read. I read it in a single afternoon.
I understand difference between the original book and the TV series/movies, but once the show and movies have gained such popularity, you'd think Ms. Bushnell would think to collaborate with the stories that people are most familiar with. I was disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No