119 of 140 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Well written adventure .... but not James Bond, June 23, 2011
This review is from: Carte Blanche (Hardcover)
Jeffery Deaver is a great writer.
CARTE BLANCHE is a fairly good adventure story (if you are careful to keep track of the long list of organizations and surplus of numerous characters}
The problem ?
It's not really James Bond.
Of course the cover says it is James Bond, and we are told this is a James Bond story.
But if I were to "search and replace" all references to the use of the name James Bond in this novel and substitute another name -------- you would never recognize this was supposed to be a James Bond story.
Yes, there is the attempt to capture the "Fleming Flair" by identifying by specific brand wines, clothes, watches, etc...
But unlike Fleming who was able to make it flow naturally and interestingly; here it feels forced and stiff.
Ian Fleming was once quoted as saying he realized he was not writing great literature but he was writing stories that interested people. He said the secret to a good story is "it keeps the reader turning the page".
Nothing should distract, annoy or hinder the reader from simply flying thru the book effortlessly and enjoyably.
So while Fleming's stories sometimes really stretched the realism and Bond got into some sticky situations that a skilled spy would have easily avoided; the stories were still tons of fun.
I confess, it took some work to get thru CARTE BLANCHE.
It was not a book that grabbed you and made you feel like you could not put it down until you finished.
I said at the beginning, it was a fairly good adventure story, and it was ....... but in a kind of stiff & clinical way.
It may be that Deaver is a good writer (and he is as evidenced by other books of his) ... but James Bond is not the right subject to come naturally for him.
Much like a hard rock musician may be great at what he does -- but would be weak at classical or country music.
In CARTE BLANCHE we are told what Bond does, but not so much what he thinks.
For example,
Deaver may write that ..
"Bond tried to make his way thru the crowded street filled with locals and tourists"
By comparison, Fleming may have written that same scene .....
" Bond navigated the slow moving mass of casually clad sunburned bodies thinking how odd it was in America that nobody seemed to work on Fridays. The resulting traffic and crowds were always worse on this final day of the supposed work week. "
In CARTE BLANCE, few of Bond's personality traits exists .
Instead we have a watered down, politically correct, neutered centrist who could be anybody.
Bond had strong views. Some were abrasive.
He had a bit of a snooty, persnickety attitude, he had vices.
He was flawed but still effective.
This Bond is some sterilized, bland and weaker redefining of the character.
Heck, both James Bond and Dirty Harry Callahan back in the 50s-70s were in their own ways warning us of the dangers of too much political correctness, going soft on evil criminals, union labor and abuse of social programs, etc..etc..
I am still surprised when I re-listen to Fleming's Bond books (read by Simon Vance) how often Ian Fleming throws in a sly criticism of trends he saw developing in UK and US back in the 50s and 60's that have become major problems for us today.
To summarize,
A nice, well written adventure book.
But it is NOT James Bond.
UPDATE (August 4, 2011)
This past week I had to take a long road trip so I listened to Sebastion Faulk's "Devil May Care" in the car.
While listening to this story which I liked better than Carte Blanche, a thought came to me regarding my original review above.
I must give some consideration to the fact that Deaver was given the difficult task of modernizing Bond with this novel.
When one thinks about it, this in itself goes a long way towards defeating the feel all of us long time Bond fans have for the character.
After all, once you remove an iconic figure from their original environment, you really change the character.
By comparison, imagine trying to bring Clint Eastwood's "Man With No Name" western figure into modern times.
Imagine a modern day Tarzan.
Imagine John Wayne's character of Rooster Cogburn in the modern day West.
I feel this modernization in itself where we remove Bond from the world that Ian Fleming lived and wrote in (1950-1960's) ... does much to make this story not feel like a true James Bond story as many of us expected.
By comparison, I feel "Devil May Care", being set in Fleming's universe just months following the battle with Scaramanga better felt like the Bond many of us "old-timers' feel a literary connection with.
OVERALL SUMMARY --
Deaver obviously spent much time and effort to write this book.
The plot is pretty involved and intertwined.
Carte Blanche is actually a good spy story, and on its own I would rate it 4.0-4.5 stars.
But if you are expecting to recapture the "Fleming Feel" of Bond, then it is not really in this story.
Maybe it is the attempt to remove Bond from his original time period, maybe it is the attempt to reboot the series, maybe it is the different writing style of each author.
Maybe it is a combination of all three factors.
Whatever the reason, this does not feel like Fleming's character of James Bond.
Thus as a continuation of the James Bond universe, I rate it as 3 stars.
But ... if you approach the book with an open mind and no expectations of experiencing "Ian Fleming MKII", you will find the story entertaining.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
52 of 65 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
He's back, June 15, 2011
This review is from: Carte Blanche (Hardcover)
Bond is back,again,and he is very good.
This new Bond novel written by Jeffery Deaver is a modern Bond,contemporary and functioning in a post Iraq invasion world.
There is a very nasty villian, which Deaver does well anyway, but this one would have done Fleming proud.
This is much better than Sebastian Faulks book of a few years back, and as a American author he is very good writing in Flemings style.
He is a very clean Bond, no smoking - he still has a drink but nothing excessive. He doesn't bowl over as many women as he has in the past either or perhaps he doesn't make the most of his opportunities, this is according to me anyway.
I am a fan of James Bond novels, love them and I have read most efforts by other guest authors and I can honestly say there is only daylight between this book and the next written post Ian Fleming's passing.
Great,great fun.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not your father's James Bond, June 22, 2011
This review is from: Carte Blanche (Hardcover)
I read all of the Ian Fleming James Bond novels while I was in high school, 35 years ago. At the time they were a bit dated: now of course they're almost antiques. Ian Fleming's estate keeps the character alive, hiring various authors to write new versions of the character, with new plots. Apparently, Jeffrey Deaver is the 5th author to take up the charge, and he's decided on a total reboot of the series. What you get, then, is pretty similar to the new Sherlock series that was on the BBC this year; just as that was Sherlock Holmes reimagined in modern London, this is James Bond, the womanizing spy from the '50s and '60s, reimagined as a 21st century, iPhone-carrying, sort-of-spy. He doesn't work for MI6 anymore, instead being employed by a supersecret agency that works to disrupt terrorist organizations and bad actors "by any means neccessary."
Things start out with Bond surveilling bad guys at a restaurant in Serbia, trying to figure out how they're related to a series of messages that Britain's codebreakers have partially deciphered. The bad guys try to derail a train carrying toxic gas, but Bond thwarts them, and the principal bad guy vanishes. Bond pursues him back to London, and of course things begin to get complicated. There is a full cast of characters (or at least their names) from previous Bond books, M, Moneypenny, Felix Leiter, etc., and the action moves along at a very good clip. I read this book cover to cover in about 6-7 hours. There is a twist at the end, though it wasn't that surprising (at least compared with the endings I remember from some of Deaver's other books). Still, the story was satisfying and the "solution" to what the terrorists were after was interesting and believable.
I have enjoyed the few Jeffrey Deaver novels I've read. For what ever reason, the idea of the Lincoln Rhyme series never appealed to me. This new book is a welcome addition to the James Bond library, however, and I look forward to seeing where Deaver will take the series from here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No