3.0 out of 5 stars
Gold, girls and foreigners, January 17, 2010
This review is from: Case Closed, Vol. 32 (Paperback)
"Case Closed Volume 32" has a big fat wobble right in the middle of its three main storylines -- the crime is awesome, but the method (and the denouement) are painfully implausible. Fortunately it's bookended between a pair of cleverer mysteries and one left undone at the very end -- and some rather sinister new characters who may cause trouble for Conan.
Harley and Conan buckle down on the case of the man who fell off the roof in flames, and quickly find some suspicious marks on the roof and an unopened lighter... as well as a fragment of pottery, and a piece of parchment with the word "dragon" on it. It seems to imply the existence of a legendary treasure that may be hidden nearby -- and someone's willing to kill to keep it hidden.
Then Richard and Co. are invited to the engagement party of Yoko Okino's friend Kaoru, as well as all the other former members of their pop band. But then Kaoru is found with her throat slit in the bath, and the police are baffled by who might have tried to kill her -- and by whether it was an inside job or a stalker.
And when Conan and his buddies befriend a friendly American tourist, they end up on the hunt to find him when he's kidnapped -- unaware that he's got secrets of his own, and that he's not as innocuous as he seems. And finally, Detective Sato goes to a marriage meeting just to shut up her mother, only to interrupted by reports of a robbery.
Gosho Aoyama has a pretty good knack for writing mildly humorous detective stories, interwoven with taut thrillers -- and "Case Closed Volume 32" does not disappoint in that area. The first of these stories (continued from Volume 31) is a sharp little treasure hunt with multiple people pulling the puppet strings, and later on there's a heated kidnapping case that has darker undertones -- it looks like some of the people involved may have connections to the organization that shrank Conan.
Unfortunately, his knack fails in the middle story -- the first 90% of it is golden whodunnit, but the denouement falls painfully flat. The method of murder is implausible enough to make your eyes bug out, and the handling of someone committing the murder of someone close to them is.... never really handled. There's the perfect setup for an emotional confrontation, and instead there's several pages of engagement babble.
And one minor complaint would be the lack of historical notes. Since the first story involves a Japanese ruler than most Westerners have never heard of, it would be nice if Viz had included something on that.
Harley gets a bit more development in this volume, since his attempts at solving the treasure case are hampered by his heavy-handed dad (who is actually a lot smarter and more tolerant than he appears). As usual, Conan's band of preteen friends are more of a distraction than a help, and the newcomer James Black is an enigma -- he seems like a harmless, genial English-American tourist with a soft spot for animals, but he also calculates the ideal way to escape gun-wielding kidnappers.
"Case Closed Volume 32" is hampered by a middle story that just falls apart in the last lap, but otherwise it's a pretty entertaining little collection -- and as usual, it leaves you hanging partway through one mystery.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No