3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Close to Perfection!, December 14, 2010
A Kid's Review
This review is from: The Case That Time Forgot (Sherlock Files (Hardback)) (Hardcover)
This is the second book that I have read in the Sherlock Files series. I loved the first one so much that I could not wait to read this one. Just like the first book, The 100 Year Old Secret, Xena and Xander are trying to solve a mystery. They are brother and sister in London, England and are related to Sherlock Holmes.
In this book, Xena and Xander's friend, Karim, tells them that his great, great, great grandfather confessed that he stole an amulet from a museum that could make time stand still every 50 years. The next time this was supposed to happen was just one week away. Using notes that Karim got from his grandfather they begin to gather clues. They show the clues to the members of SPFD, the detective club they joined in the first book of the series. They need them to help translate some hieroglyphics in two of the clues. The clues lead them to places all over London like Big Ben, a pub and a library. The clues were like a treasure hunt. One led to another and another and so on. While they were going from one clue to the next, weird things kept happening to them. Someone had been listening to them while they were talking about the mystery. That person began following them. Xena and Xander knew they were being followed because kept hearing noises and finding the same footprint every time they went looking for clues. The secret person tried to keep them off track so they could not solve the mystery. He even put them in danger sometimes. They really wanted to find out who this person was and why he was trying to keep them from finding the amulet. In the end though, they find out he was only trying to solve the mystery himself and get the amulet so he could help his mother get her job back that she had just lost. Finally, just like in The 100 Year Old Secret, they put enough clues together to find the amulet and solve the mystery.
I think this mystery was written to perfection. I actually got so nervous while reading certain parts that I got shivers and felt that somebody was sneaking up on me. I liked how Tracy Barrett describes how Xena and Xander used each of the clues they found to get closer to finding the amulet. I don't think I could have solved them they way they did. One thing I think you will like if you read this book is that the author did not let Xena and Xander get everything they wanted in the end. They solved the mystery but did not get what they expected. I hope you read this book to find out what I mean by that.
In the end though, I did not like where they found the amulet. I thought it could have been found in a place that was much more interesting. That's the only reason I gave it four stars instead of five. That still does not mean I can't wait to read the next book in the series. So far there are three books in the series. I hope Tracy Barrett keeps writing more Sherlock Mysteries so I can keep reading them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No