7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great disappointment..., December 27, 2008
This review is from: Cassandra and Jane: A Jane Austen Novel (Paperback)
Ever since I read "Just Jane" by Nancy Moser and watched "Becoming Jane" starring Anne Hathaway, I've come to adore Jane Austen's sister Cassandra. There is so little known about her yet her story still fascinates me. The older sister of a well-known author, an amateur artist, a woman who never looked at another man because her one true love died at a young age. So when I discovered "Cassandra and Jane: A Jane Austen Novel," by Jill Pitkeathley, I was eagerly expecting a book about the Austen sisters' unique relationship. No two sisters could be closer (with the exception of my sister and I). I won't outline the story; any Jane Austen nut already knows what it is. And if you don't, you'll just have to read it for yourself.
There is nothing objectionable in the story's content. Sex is referred to as a woman's duty to her husband and whenever the topic is brought up, they characters are vague about it. Faith in God and prayer is held in high esteem; in fact two of the Austen sisters' suitors believe they are called of God to serve Him rather than just viewing the church as a means of making a living. As a Christian who is pretty picky about what she reads, I think that this is a novel that could easily be sold in the Christian market or at a religious bookstore.
However, as an avid Austen-ite, I was disappointed. From the multiple biographies out there about the author, it is believed that the characters Jane Bennet and Elinore Dashwood are loosely based on Cassandra, yet this portrayal of her in no way resembled those characters. She comes across as bland and boring, with no references to her own personal interests or passions.
As a first person narrative told in Cassandra's perspective, Cassandra herself isn't really given much of a personality, just observations of the events in her life. When reminiscing about her relationship with Tom Fowle, the author doesn't go in-depth about Cassandra's feelings. In this book, he is rarely ever mentioned. I can understand that she mourned for him on her own, but this being a book from her point of view, I expected that because of her steadfast devotion to Tom that the author should have at least depicted it more than she did.
Truth be told, this story focuses mostly on Jane Austen; her characterization is another disappointment for me. Before her fling with Lefroy, Jane behaves almost as ridiculous as Lydia Bennet and afterwards she is more like Marianne Dashwood. I had imagined Jane Austen to be a vast deal more mature and reserved. What bothered me the most was that Jane relied heavily on Cassandra's opinions, even when it came to writing. Instead of applauding Jane's own creative genius, Cassandra is credited with assisting her sister in naming the Dashwood sisters and for titling "Persuasion." Often enough in the book, Jane is unable to think for herself and goes running to Cassandra to work out troubles for her.
Maybe I'm just being nit picky; perhaps if you read it you'll like it better.
http://veronicaleigh.blogspot.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Cassandra and Jane, September 9, 2008
This review is from: Cassandra and Jane: A Jane Austen Novel (Paperback)
This is my first fictional take bookwise on any part of Jane Austen's life, though I have seen a couple movie versions. While I'm just a plain and simple Jane Austen fan, and no expert of her life, what I do know I usually don't want people changing to make something more exciting or the like. . . so, in the end. . .
I really liked this book! :)
FIrst and foremost, I like how the author used Cassandra as the narrator, instead of someone else, a third person point of view or different family member. Using Cassandra made it more personal and we got to hear the story directly from the other person that mattered in the relationship between the sisters. We get what I thought was a great look at them. . . they loved each other, knew each other, and understood each other through the good and the darker times. It speculated on the imperfections of Jane, making her more human. In the end, I really liked this author's speculations into the life of Jane and Cassandra and their interactions with each other, while staying within the letter that did survive through history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fictionalized portrayal of a beloved historical figure., January 20, 2009
This review is from: Cassandra and Jane: A Jane Austen Novel (Paperback)
CASSANDRA & JANE is a fictionalize story of the historical author Jane Austin. The story is told through the eyes of the person who knew her best, her older sister Cassandra.
Jill Pitkeathley begins with the author's birth and carries readers all the way to her death. With such a realistic presentation, it was hard to see the line between fact and fiction.
Normally biographical-type books, fictionalized or not, bore me to tears. From the beginning, Pitkeathley formed an emotional web attaching me to the characters. I felt each painful disappointment as though I was there. In the end, when Cassandra lost Jane, I felt it too.
This is a powerful portrayal of a beloved historical figure and Pitkeathley's tale stayed with me days after the final page was read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
