Customer Reviews

Castle In The Sky (Score)

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

For their production of a new dub for Hayao Miyazaki's terrific adventure fantasy LAPUTA (renamed CASTLE IN THE SKY in America to avoid offending Spanish-speaking audiences), Disney commissioned composer Joe Hisaishi to re-record his much loved score for the film with the Seattle Music Orchestra. This caused a bit of controversy among some anime purists, but Hisaishi - no stranger to the Hollywood style of film scoring - complied. The new score was released on CD in October 2002 in celebration of the film's DVD premiere in Japan.

Even to this day, there are naysayers who attack this ambitious reworking, claiming that it tarnishes the film. However Miyazaki has personally applauded Hisaishi's new reworking, and there are many who have echoed him in agreement. I am one such enthusiast. While nothing will ever be able to capture the magic of the original score, this rearranged version doesn't necessarily have to in order to provide a powerful, magical experience in its own right. The experience of hearing the original, electronically generated music converted to symphony is nothing less than visceral.

The orchestral pieces follow their original compositions closely and are performed with beauty and power by the orchestra. "The Girl Who Fell From the Sky", in particular, sounds amazing in its new dress, as do "Memories of Gondoa", and "Confessions on the Moonlight". The action cues are equally thrilling, especially "The Chase" and the robot attack sequence. Added to the mix are piano solos and synthesizer sounds (some from the original score) tucked in more than one track by Joe Hisaishi. Admittedly, the recording acoustics don't sound as vibrant as Hisaishi's more recent work for Miyazaki (PRINCESS MONONOKE, SPIRITED AWAY, and HOWL'S MOVING CASTLE come to mind), but there is no denying that this score is nothing short of breathtaking.

There are some minor embellishments to several tracks. The trumpet fanfare for Pazu, for example, is no longer trumpet only, but accompanied by a lyre. The tear-jerking choral hymn for the apocalypse of Laputa starts out a cappella, then is accompanied by the orchestra. Some of these minor alterations may be too jarring for long-time fans of the original score to appreciate, but in many ways they really enhance the score, particularly the aforementioned "Collapse of Laputa" track. There are even a couple of new cues. Some of these replace previous selections on the original ("Stones Glowing in the Darkness", "The Dragon's Nest", and "The Forgotten Robot Soldier"), while others are created especially for the newer edition.

This album release consists of a good selection of the new score - a total of 61 minutes in all. Yet I still found myself wondering if Tokuma Japan could have afforded to squeeze in just a little bit more. The remix of the film's heavenly closing theme "Carrying You" is sorely missed, as is the full version of the fortress fight sequence, which is cut down to three minutes and omits many of its exciting passages.

While some will argue over whether the U.S. score of CASTLE IN THE SKY does justice to the movie or not, it remains brilliant and an enjoyable listen in its own right, especially in album form. I personally recommend acquiring both versions; each puts its own stamp on Miyazaki's masterpiece and offers a special kind of magic of its own.

I first saw Castle In The Sky over a decade ago, and then unfortunately only about half of it but the memorable images and scenes (e.g. the robots laid against the giant tree) immediately came back when I clapped eyes on the US import DVD last april. Ive been a big Miyazaki/Hisaishi fan ever since.
I'm disappointed that I had to import this from Japan, but it was worth it. The music is very majestic and reminds you of the scenes nicely, especially track 8 (on the train being chased by Dola's gang) which is my favourite.
Ive bought several soundtracks since for the miyazaki movies, and would put them in the following order of purchase:
1. Castle in the Sky
2. Princess Mononoke OST (US)
3. Spirited Away (No-Faces' theme is used too often in the later tracks, but otherwise great)
4. Princess Mononoke Symphonic Suite (some of the tunes in the middle of the CD are plain noisy)

There is really only one problem with CITS, and that is the closing theme, sung by Azumi Inoue, is missing! I was looking forward to that..

I just bought this soundtrack as used and new for only twenty bucks and I was glad I did. I found the score mystical and glorious, a perfect addition to the Princess Mononoke CD I also have. Joe Hisaishi is most certainly among the masters of movie scoring. His simple melodies and breathtaking arrangements get me every time!
I have never listened to any other additions of this music and have only seen the english movie But as far as I'm concerned, I basically the entire score and I enjoy it constantly.
It was so fun for my brother and I to go and listen to the music, while picking out what part of the movie they were from and quoting the lines with gusto (We absolutely LOOOOVE the movie).
SOme of the songs I have to say, swept me away with grand style. These included "The FOrgotten Robot SOldier", "The Lost Paradise", and of course the main theme, "THe GIrl who Fell from the SKy".
Other themes such as "Dola and the PIrates" and the prologue "Flaptors Attack", had me laughing because I could easily envision the parts of the movie that they were from. And that is the magic of Hisaishi's music. Usually I have to listen to a score many times and THEN watch the movie before I can pick out all the themes from my CD. THis was quite the opposite. After seeing the movie about ten times throughout the past year and a half, I came to know all the music so well, than almost none of the music on the CD came as a surprise.
BUt most certainly, nothing compares to the heartwrenching piece right before the finale, "THe Destruction of Laputa (CHoral Version)". SOmetimes when I listen to this song, it is all I can do not to cry.
Over all a musical masterpiece. NO collection is complete without this work of genius!

Joe Hisaishi's score fit perfectly with the movie by Miyazaki. The music provides wonderment, excitement and even comedy and really highlights what is going on in the movie. The score can take you to another land and raise spirits. It is truely inspiring and makes you want to get up and go on an adventure. The way Hisaishi uses strings and percussion to puncuate the mood is amazing. This music rivals that of "Spirited Away" and makes the band nerd in me want to get out the horn and play. From one that loves music, I would recommend this score to anyone.

I've been a great fan of Joe Hisaishi/Hayao Miyazaki ever since the original Laputa movie came out in 1986. I used to have the original soundtrack on tape back then and always wanted to get it on CD. Recently, I bought this US version by mistake. The music is still great. But maybe I'm too attached to the original scores, I still prefer the original. Also it feels incomplete without the closing theme sung by Azumi Inoue.

After looking through all the different soundtracks, I settles on this one when I heard that the original soundtrack was mostly synthesized. I didn't remember that from watching the movie. This is exactly what I had hoped it would be. It's a real orchestra performance. I like it much better than the synthesized tracks, though this does not have the credits track.

Even though this CD cost over $40, it was well worth the money. My sister and I split the purchase and she fell in love with the music immediately. She watched the movie in Japanese with the original music and told me that the new soundtrack was ten times better. It added so much more emotional impact to the movie with the way they arranged the music to match the events of the movie. All the songs are enjoyable, but the Song of Destruction, Patzu's trumpet theme, and the Girl Who Fell From the Sky are my favorites. Anyone who enjoys classical music will be delighted with this CD.