From School Library Journal
Grade 2-3-The nutty but charming Gaskitt family is back, and this third installment is the best yet. The humorous incidents revolve around pet thefts, a mom who spends much of her time in bed, a teacher who falls out of the window trying to find the missing class rat, and a ridiculous substitute teacher. McEwen stays in step with the author with her dynamic watercolor-and-crayon illustrations on white backgrounds. Text and art flirt playfully with one another, often trading jobs. The book is loaded with fun elements such as timetables and aerial-view maps. There's more than a bit of slapstick, understated humor, third-grade-style sarcasm, and characters contradicting the author in thought bubbles. Specific references to popular culture are tossed off, as when the family cat, riding the city bus home after being abducted, daydreams that he's the lead in the movie The Incredible Journey. These elements put The Cat at the sophisticated end of its genre and the rich end of the literary-experience spectrum. It's a romp on a par with Dav Pilkey's "Captain Underpants" books (Scholastic), but without the irreverence. It's also a school story featuring a substitute teacher to top Viola Swamp from Harry Allard's "Miss Nelson" books (Houghton). Children will love it.
Liza Graybill, Worcester Public Library, MACopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Gr. 1-3. Ahlberg's third saga about the Gaskitts has a lot going on. Randolph, Gus and Gloria's class pet rat, disappears; then the Gaskitts' cat, Horace, does, too. Mr. Gaskitt is doing all the cleaning, and Mrs. Gaskitt hardly gets out of bed, though she is cheerful enough. Children will giggle through the enticing adventures as they figure out why Mrs. Gaskitt goes to the hospital. The crisp design features a good-size typeface, and McEwen's watercolor-and-crayon artwork is tucked in and around the text in a lively, deadpan way. A few literary and pop culture references will delight kids and amuse their parents.
GraceAnne DeCandidoCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
See all Editorial Reviews