| |||||||||||||||
|
Browse our Bookshelf Favorites store for big savings on popular fiction, nonfiction, children's books, and more. |
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images? |
In 1996, Catholic homeschoolers already had two strong books - Catholic Home Schooling: A Guidebook for Parents by Mary Kay Clark and Designing Your Own Classical Curriculum by Laura Berquist. The Hahn/Hasson book didn't add anything new to understanding *Catholic* home schooling. It is more of an opinion piece on what methods and resources they like and don't like. Most homeschoolers can get that information from support groups, email, and friends.
Another challenge I had was the lack of acknowledgement of long-standing Catholic home schooling proponents and programs already on the scene for twenty years and more. For new homeschoolers reading this book, Hahn and Hasson may appear to be trailblazers, which they are not. The dismissive and negative attitude toward those trailblazers with different methods and idealogies (especially full-service curriculum providers)was a bit embarassing. I found the ommision of Catholic home schooling history in America to be a distraction.
Finally, the long list of resources, while helpful, had many Protestant materials which were constantly being defended in the text of the book. Each family has to pick and choose what is best. But one has the feeling while reading the book that these mothers have a hard time with those who believe that only Catholic materials should be used in a Catholic education. Perhaps some have given the authors a hard time on this topic.
I am not sorry I read the book, but I am sorry I bought it. I haven't picked it up since 1996. But I lend it to anyone who askes. Something may strike a chord with them.
|