"[A] work that has been widely praised in a variety of Catholic publications. Varacalli is a serious and responsible scholar who writes in a precise and balanced manner. Parents can be confident in the information he provides to counterbalance the secular humanist biases their children are likely to encounter in their textbooks, in both public and parochial schools."
–
First Teachers
"Of his several books, this new one I think gives the greatest help in grasping just what has happened to the Catholic Church in this present period of the study's appearance….[v]ery valuable, and also very readable."
–
The Wanderer
"[A]n informed and fair-minded sketch both of the Catholic faith and of the history of the Catholic Church in the United States. The approach is strongly sociological with a good deal of sensitivity to cultural analysis of this institution and its membership. The prose is clear and concise, free of an initiate's jargon: theories and terms are always explained in accessible language. explained"
–
American Catholic Studies
"The readers of Catholic Southwest will find much information on the issues of immigration, nativism, racial and ethnic cooperation and conflict, and assimilation and segregation. But let me conclude on this note with the highest praise for Dr. Varacalli's book, a book made possible by the very courage of the late Roman Pontiff. Pope John Paul II may not have successfully arrested the deconstruction of the Catholic Church, but he did inspire new studies like the one at hand -- studies that at least offer a hopeful alternative to the progressivist scholarship and interpretation that overwhelmed the immediate post-Vatican II period."
–
Catholic Southwest - A Journal of History and Culture
"The story of Catholicism in America may be an open book, but the book reads very differently depending on who's doing the writing."
–
Catholic Education Resource Center
"The Catholic Experience in America by Joseph Varacalli chronicles the history and present situation of the Church and the American subculture."
–
CNS Mission
"[W]orth having to refer to as well as to read. You should inquire at your public library asking for this book--if only to motivate the librarians to order the book. It is the kind of book that should be available in the library for citizens doing research on the Church or for students writing papers and such."
–
Catalyst
"[T]he Catholic Experience in America warrants a close look by high school and college teachers, and by others curious about the past, present, and future of Catholicism in this country."
–
First Things
"[A] sociologically informed history of the Catholic Church in the United States analyzing historical turning points and topics such as abortion, women in the church, and sexual scandals."
–
University of Chicago Magazine
"[E]xcellent introductions to the subject."
–
www.catholichistory.net
"[A]n excellent sociological overview of the Catholic experience in America….[s]ummarizes general trends and major turning points in American Catholic history, the rise and fall of a Catholic plausibility structure, and Catholic perspectives on contemporary issues such as homosexuality and family structure, birth control and women's health issues, abortion and the culture of death, and secularization in Catholic higher education. Appendices on Church documents, Catholic organizations, demographic and statistical information, a glossary of key terms, and an excellent Bibliography are also provided."
–
Social Justice Review
"[S]erves not only to make us all aware of the high (and low) points of Catholic history in America but also serves as a fundamental introduction to the Catholic Church for non-Catholics and for the many Catholics who have received little or no effective catechesis, especially about the basic structure of the Catholic Church. As such, the book, while being unabashedly a product of academic professionalism, is also capable of an evangelization effect by introducing the Catholic Church accurately to students. This evangelization effect is possible because the author embraces the official teachings of the Church, instead of presenting readers with a tendentious mirage based on a liberal imagination, as we have in so many other works on the Catholic Church. His book is an example for all academics of combining straightforward professional work without compromising the truth of Catholic belief."
–
Catholic Analysis
"[S]hows how the Second Vatican Council was a turning point for how Catholics in the United States deal with the culture and relate to the Church's hierarchy and official teachings….Varacalli presents both sides fairly and lets the reader draw his or her own conclusions."
–
National Catholic Register
"[C]ontext is everything. To know the recent historical context of the grave problems faced by Catholics in the U.S. is to enable ourselves to make all things new as the Scriptures tell us and to ensure that the Catholic Church in the U.S. develops the true vision of Vatican II and not the mediocre liberal caricature that for too long has been the default position in too many places. Varacalli's book will help you know that context."
–
Catholic Analysis (blog)
"Varacalli guides the reader effortlessly though the pertinent literature. He does not break much new ground here but that is not the point of this useful book, which describes the Catholic experience in America from its origins to the present in light of the findings of the most important scholarly research."
–
The American Conservative
"[V]aracalli is to be commended for striving to be as objective as possible in presenting the Catholic experience in America….In eight appendices the author presents much useful information about the Catholic Church in America. This is followed by an extensive bibliography on all things Catholic in the USA during the past 300 years or so. If you have the opportunity, it would be good to recommend to your local public library that it acquire this book for those who want to do research on the Catholic Church in America."
–
Homiletic & Pastoral Review
"[T]he Catholic Experience in America considers the many facets of life as a Catholic in modern America. From different faces of Catholicism within the American church to issues of race and gender, chapters provide historical and social background. The Catholic Experience in America provides thorough coverage of events which have affected the church and its religious foundations."
–
Midwest Book Review - Internet Bookwatch
"Drawing upon the best contemporary and objective scholarship, Varacalli's The Catholic Experience traces the historical fortunes of the Catholic Church in the United States from its first Anglo-beginnings in Colonial Maryland (also noting French and Spanish Catholic contributions), and examines carefully the interaction of Catholics with the surrounding culture….Valuable feature of The Catholic Experience in America are its appendices listing Church documents and Catholic organizations, key resources on the Internet, a glossary of key terms and phrases, and relevant demographical statistics. Varacalli's scholarly volume is highly recommended."
–
Lay Witness
"Joseph A. Varacalli's The Catholic Experience in America is….[a]n affirmative look at the social history of the Church, yet it does not back away from some of the challenges that the Church has faced-including the clergy abuse crisis of the past decade, the growing secularization of her colleges and universities, and the negative response of many progressive Catholics to her teachings on birth control, abortion, and homosexuality….While Varacalli, a founder of the Society for Catholic Scientists, is steadfast in his loyal support for the magisterium, he is also fair in presenting the not-so-loyal opposition."
–
Catholic Social Science Review
"[O]ffers a multifaceted look at Catholic life in the United States….Varacalli knows well the legitimate diversity within American Catholicism. His treatment accounts for a long history of intra-ecclesial competition which this condition helped produce. His discussion of religious communities and devotions also accounts for the historical vitality of Catholic tradition in so many different times and settings; one community or devotional practice will emphasize or embody a particularly compelling insight from the rich Catholic treasury; another will highlight some insight, and so on. The end product is both an infinite complexity and a sociologically sensitive and efficient creature that can survive in widely and divergent contexts."
–
The Chesterton Review
"The Catholic Experience in America offers a broad and helpful description of the church in America as a social institution. Varacalli, a sociologist, notes in particular the ongoing tension between loyalty to the nation and the development and decline of a Catholic plausibility structure, the institutions that socialize Catholics into willing acceptance of their church's teachings."
–
Touchstone
"[A] thorough, accurate, and mostly unbiased account of the history of the Catholic Church in the United States….[F]or anyone, Catholic or non-Catholic, wanting to know more about the history and beliefs of the Church."
–
Catholic Education
"Readers interested in the changing fortunes of the Catholic Church in America will find Varacalli's work of great interest. He has managed to produce a study that is both scholarly and accessible to a general audience."
–
Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly
" [B]racing and insightful… Readers interested in the changing fortunes of the Catholic Church in America will find Varacalli's work of great interest. He has managed to produce a study that is both scholarly and accessible to a general audience."
–
Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly
