Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
enjoyable historical fiction, July 15, 2010
This review is from: Caves, Cannons and Crinolines (Perfect Paperback)
Do you know what a crinoline is? Most young ladies today would have no idea. However, Elizabeth (Lizzie) Stamford is a fictional young lady, who lives at Vicksburg, MS, in 1861 during the Siege of Vicksburg by General Grant and his Union forces. Her father is a physician at the local hospital. Her two older brothers, Joseph and Willie, are soldiers in the Confederate Army fighting in Virginia. She, her mother, her younger brother Nathan (Nat) who seems slightly slow-witted, and their two servants are forced to live in a nearby cave while the Union cannons are shelling Vicksburg. Patrick, the young man who had been sweet on her, signed up with Joseph and Willie, but he had already been killed.
Lizzie has a rebellious streak, and feeling great anger toward the Union forces due to all the changes they forced in the Stamfords' lives, she puts aside her crinoline, which is a hoop skirt with a petticoat of highly sized, stiff fabric to make it flare, and sneaks out, disguised as a boy dressed in Nat's clothes calling herself Eli, to join General Pemberton's Confederate defenders. However, that does not go too well, especially after Private Arnold, who had become like a mentor to her, is killed right before her eyes, so she decides to return home. On the way, she discovers a Yankee soldier, Private Benjamin Clayton from Ohio, who had been shot in the arm, and, thinking about what she would want people to do if they found either of her brothers injured, she took him home where her father attended to his wounds. The soldier leaves a few days later in the confusion when the Stamfords receive a letter about Willie. Will it be good news or bad news? And will Lizzie ever see or even hear from Ben again?
Historical fiction is probably my favorite genre of young people's literature, and Beverly Stowe McClure, author of Rebel in Blue Jeans, does a great job of presenting the Civil War for teenagers from both Southern and Northern viewpoints. There is no bad language or, for that matter, much to which anyone would object, aside from a couple of minor references to drinking alcohol. All the characters are portrayed quite naturally, and the action is carried forth in a way that will keep the reader turning the pages. One can really get a feel for how the war affected the lives of the people who experienced it. Caves, Cannons, and Crinolines would make good historical fiction supplementary reading in connection with any study of the Civil War, especially the capture of Vicksburg.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An intriguing read, not to be missed for historical fiction readers, October 7, 2010
This review is from: Caves, Cannons and Crinolines (Perfect Paperback)
Even when the world is coming down around you, the need for love and comfort is more important than ever. "Caves, Cannons, and Crinolines" tells the story of Lizzie Stamford and her family as they struggle to survive and live their lives as the American Civil War explodes around them. Through the chaos around them, they try to remember what is truly important in their lives. "Caves, Cannons, and Crinolines" is an intriguing read, not to be missed for historical fiction readers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I'm So Glad I Read This Book!, October 4, 2011
This review is from: Caves, Cannons and Crinolines (Perfect Paperback)
Most of us have read about the American Civil War, Mrs. McClure gives us a chance to live it through the eyes of Lizzy, a 14-year-old girl who is determined to help the South send those darn Yankees back to the North where they belong. Their beloved family home isn't safe anymore, and if the war keeps up any longer, it will be unrecognizable from all the rubble surrounding it. Lizzy hates those cannons. She hates living in a cave even more, but what really gets her ire up is seeing how much those Yankees have turned the lives of her family upside down. She rarely sees her father. He's the town doctor so he's gone for days at a time, caring for wounded soldiers. Apparently, it doesn't matter that his family also needs him. Both of her older brothers snuck off in the middle of the night to enlist. Nobody has heard from them since. Lizzy writes them daily, but she's afraid for them. She's afraid of a lot of things lately. The cannons are getting closer, food is scarce, and her gentle younger brother, Nat, is changing. If this war keeps up, Nat might abandon his dreams of flying machines for a gun! Her mother is too busy to notice. When she's not making bandages for the war effort or helping wayward neighbors, her attention is on Lizzy. The woman is determined, against all odds, to turn her daughter into a proper Southern lady. All Lizzy has to do is look pretty, keep her opinions to herself, and focus all that excess energy on attracting a suitable beau. The Yankees!--Lizzy decides, all of this mess is the Yankees' fault. Donning her brother's clothes, she sets off to enlist. Someone has to end this war. Why not her? Guns, battle, Yankees... none of them are what she expects. The lines between right and wrong are blurred. Friends are foes. Foes are friends. How in the world can a Yankee be a gentleman? Isn't that an oxymoron? I was hooked from the first page. Mrs. McClure weaved an endearing tale. I laughed. I cried, and I learned! I'm so glad I read this book! Thank you Beverly Stowe-McClure for writing it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
