From School Library Journal
Grade 7 Up—The wealthy and beautiful 15-year-old Hamilton triplets—impetuous Lexington, pragmatic Park, and mini-mogul Madison—have it all and Manhattan is their playground. At a fundraiser for the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the sisters have a troublesome encounter with a zealous paparazzo that leads them to discover the dead body of a famous fashion magazine editor. When Lexington is implicated in the murder, the teens set out to solve the case themselves. Full of snobbery, cattiness, sexual encounters, and underage drinking, this book tries very hard to be like Cecily von Ziegesar's "Gossip Girl" series (Little, Brown) and Bennett Madison's "Lulu Dark" mysteries (Sleuth/Razorbill), but it has none of the wit and knowing sarcasm that make those books so entertaining. The mystery starts off well for these wannabe Nancy Drews but it is so drawn out that, by the end, readers will lose interest in whodunit and why. Because the story is written in alternating chapters about different characters, readers don't get to know the stereotypical sisters, their boyfriends, and their employees, but since they are all so unlikable and smug, no one is likely to care.—Anne Rouyer, New York Public Library
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Using the Gossip Girls as a template, this introduces the high-society Hamilton triplets, Madison, Lex, and Park. But now, along with all the booze, sex, bitchiness, and designer names, there's a mystery. Madison is hosting a charity function at the Met when fashion editor Zahara Bell is found dead in the cloakroom--wearing one of Lex's original designs. A paparazzo, who has caught Park in a compromising position with heartthrob Jeremy Bleu in the bathroom of the Met, is later found dead in the girls' penthouse. Clearly, the girls must go into detective mode to solve the crimes. The silliest thing about this is the fact that the sisters are 16, even as they attend board meetings! Design clothes! Plan celebrity-studded charity events! Why not just cast them as college students and call less attention to the improbabilities? But the mystery element is good with plot turns that will string readers along. Attracted by the gutsy (albeit obnoxious) girls and their lavish lifestyles, readers will certainly want to find out "who dun it." Ilene Cooper
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

