Customer Reviews

Cello Suites Bwv 1010-1012

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

No, perhaps this doesn't have the "sparkle" and depth of Verbruggen's first, landmark recording of the cello suites (still available, suites 1-3 on Harmonia Mundi Franc - #7907071), which are truly incredible. But that may just be that the bloom has faded from me and the surprise and awe I felt at first encounter with that first CD. But this release still has treasures awaiting anyone who loves the suites and exploring Bach's capacity for nuance. Much clearer than with bowed or plucked strings, I think. Like organ music, but only with a virtuoso musician playing with the heart of Bach.

Marion Verbruggen has done what I believe to be the first recorded transcription of the famous Cello Suites of Bach for flute.

The playing is actually quite clear and very well-paced, but sadly, lacks the emotional depth which one feels when listening to this in its original cello format. This is the only reservation I have for this recording, but for any Bach enthusiasts like myself, it is indispensable as a recording primarily for its novelty. I do however suggest that you listen to the Cello Suites of Casals, Jaap ter Linden, or Mstislav Rostropovich before you buy this CD, so as to have a deeper appreciation for this musical piece. You might also want to look into the transcription of this piece for Lute done by Hopkinson Smith before trying this CD out.