Censored 2006: The Top 25 Censored Stories [Paperback]

Project Censored (Author), Peter Phillips (Author), Tom Tomorrow (Illustrator), Norman Solomon (Introduction)

Book Description

Publication Date: September 6, 2005 | Series: Censored

The yearly volumes of Censored, in continuous publication since 1976 and since 1995 available through Seven Stories Press, is dedicated to the stories that ought to be top features on the nightly news, but that are missing because of media bias and self-censorship. The top stories are listed democratically in order of importance according to students, faculty, and a national panel of judges. Each of the top stories is presented at length, alongside updates from the investigative reporters who broke the stories.

Editorial Reviews

About the Author

PROJECT CENSORED, founded in 1976 by Carl Jensen, has as its principal objective the advocacy for and protection of First Amendment rights and the freedom of information in the United States. In 2008, Project Censored received the PEN/Oakland Literary Censorship Award for the publication of Censored 2009. For more information, visit www.projectcensored.org.
PETER PHILLIPS, director emeritus of Project Censored and president of the Media Freedom Foundation, is an associate professor of sociology at Sonoma State University. He is known for his op-ed pieces in the alternative press and independent newspapers nationwide, such as Z Magazine and Social Policy. He is also the winner of the 2009 Dallas Smythe Award, presented by the Union for Democratic Communication.

Product Details

• Paperback: 432 pages
• Publisher: Seven Stories Press (September 6, 2005)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 1583226923
• ISBN-13: 978-1583226926
• Product Dimensions: 5.5 x 1.1 x 8.4 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.1 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.3 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (7 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #1,317,086 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

33 of 38 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars More of the Same..., March 12, 2006

By 

doomsdayer520 (Pennsylvania) - See all my reviews
(HALL OF FAME REVIEWER)   

This review is from: Censored 2006: The Top 25 Censored Stories (Paperback)

...from the corporate media, and from Project Censored. The team has delivered another volume of the most important stories of the year, which have been ignored or covered up by the mainstream media. In an insult to American traditions of a free press and an informed citizenry, the corporate news industry continues to suppress important stories about corporate hegemony; the errors and crimes of elected leaders (from the dominant party, that is); and most importantly, any story about the modern assault on participatory democracy from the wealthy elite. Uncovering these stories and describing their importance to regular citizens already makes the work of Project Censored incredibly important. However, I have been diligently reading these annual guides for nearly a decade, and this year's edition continues the tendency of the books to undermine the importance of the uncovered news stories.

The main problem is the large portion of this book that follows the year's top stories, in which the team attempts analyses of media behavior. With the exception of strong reports from FAIR and PR Watch, the media analyses here are at worst amateurish, or at best summaries of the type of work done by far stronger experts in the field of mass communications and political economy (such as Ben Bagdikian or Robert McChesney, as just two examples). Here we get only slight introductions to a rich field of knowledge that would be much better explored in books by the experts, rather than the term papers by students that are predominant here. (The more intricately researched, though sarcastic and hyperbolic, submissions from writers like Greg Palast aren't helping much either.)

This running weakness is compounded by absolutely atrocious technical editing. This book is damaged by severe typos on nearly every page – for example, "to reminder us all," "Depart of Defense," or "February 29, 2005." This volume is dedicated to the late investigative journalist Gary Webb, and they even misprinted his date of birth in the large introduction on the first page (he wasn't born in 1995). What we have here is an unprofessional lack of the most basic proofreading, evidenced by the fact that essays by some of the writers contain very few typos, but others are so poorly typed that entire sentences border on incomprehensibility. This is especially a problem in the section that follows up the top censored stories from previous years, with updates written by various students and interns in the project. Sure, typing is a chore and it's not contingent on the believability of one's writing. However, a project that has a few hundred people working on it should have at least one or two technical editors on staff. To avoid the perennial weaknesses of editing and analysis that might forever damage the annual books, it might be a good idea to just stick with the Project Censored website for what's really important – the censored stories themselves. [~doomsdayer520~]

17 of 21 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars The book seems to never end but it is full of good stuff, December 15, 2005

By 

Chris (Washington state, USA) - See all my reviews

This review is from: Censored 2006: The Top 25 Censored Stories (Paperback)

In this book Dahr Jamail records witnesses to the assault on Fallujah in late 2004 who describe U.S. troops killing civilians trying to swim across the Euphrates to escape the fighting, rolling tanks over wounded bodies, killing people waving white flags and invading homes and killing people when they didn't respond to commands in English. At the Fallujah General hospital and a hospital ten miles away, U.S. forces engaged in a quite blatant violation of the Geneva Convention by invading the hospitals and making doctors and patients lie on the ground shackled, shooting out lights, firing at ambulances killing one drivers, shooting out doors, blocking access roads and access out of the hospital for ambulances and so on. Jamail records the feeling of people in the Al Dura region outside Baghdad who report U.S destruction of their wells and fields and records witnesses to the civilian deaths of U.S. bombs dropped on civilian areas. It is explained in the book that according to the Lancet/John Hopkins study which estimated 100,000 Iraqi civilians killed in the year after the March 2003 invasion as a result of that invasion, died for the most part not by direct killing by U.S. soldiers, but by rocket and missile attacks, unexploded cluster bombs, etc. He notes that while violent crimes against women averaged about once every several months under Saddam, this increased to several per week by July 2003 under the blessings of American occupation.

The Iraqi government commission on the media set up by Bremer has banned and threatened news outlets, which don't toe its line. The book has a section surveying abuses of freedom of speech and press in the world. In U.S. allies like Egypt and Morrocco, excuses are still found to jail journalists and send out masked men to beat them up. In Tunisia, the country's press association was expelled by the International Federation of Journalists after the former gave an award for press freedom to the country's virtual dictator President Ben Ali, a notorious persecutor of opposition journalists. In Afghanistan, journalists report that they heavily exercise self-censorship for fear of facing retaliation from the warlords, the real rulers of the country.

The book points out the deception behind the Oil for Food scandal uproar. It notes that it was not the demonized UN leadership but the U.S. and UK dominated the UN sanctions committee which approved all the Oil For Food Deals. U.S. allies Turkey and Jordan gained U.S. acquiescence in the billion dollar smuggling of Iraqi oil that went on over their borders. 80 percent of Iraqi oil during the sanctions period ended up in the hands of U.S. companies.

Another section deals with the situation in Haiti. The old barbaric military and police have regained power on behalf of the U.S. installed Latortue government and gone around beating up judges who try to prosecute them. Thousands are in jail w/o charge.. Rape has been a particular tool used by this regime.. Amnesty International has reported on the extreme violence of the new regime but the Bush administration, the Martin Government in Canada and the UN have engaged in lies and obfuscation about it. The leading Haitian human rights organization, like the rest of the groups in the "democratic uprising" was heavily subsidized by the U.S. prior to Aristide's overthrow, now refuses to go into the slums and villages where most Haitians live, to investigate abuses. Meanwhile in May 2005, the government of the Dominican Republic, began arbitrarily picking up Haitian migrant workers and refugees in the country and dumping them across the border into Haiti. More than a few of these tens of thousands dumped over the border appear to be poor dark skinned Dominicans arbitrarily classified as Haitians by the Dominican police.

Domestic related matters in this book include a report on how Gale Norton's Interior Department has been blocking inquiry into the royalty accounts of revenues gained from resource extraction by corporations on Native American land since 1887. An investigator appointed by a federal judge estimated that, while many Native Americans live in third world style poverty, the Government had robbed Native Americans of over 137 billion in revenues since 1887. The Bush administration successfully pressured that this investigator resign. Another article deals with the proposals for dealing with illegal immigrants and it points out that recent proposals such as those by Senators Kennedy and McCain, at best resemble the previous "guest worker" program, the Bracero program that lasted from 1942 to 1964. During the latter, the government often withheld money from workers on the ground that it wanted to ensure completion of work contract, but that money was never released to the workers.

An interesting article describes how the army of Ethiopia, ruled by virtual dictator Melas Zenawi, has engaged in a campaign of ethnic cleansing complete with the usual village burning, mass rapes, executions, etc. against the Anuak people in Ethiopia's Gambella region, in part by supporting the violence of other ethnic groups against the Anuak. The region is a major source of oil and other natural resources for U.S. corporations. The Ethiopian Government receives major military aid and training from the Bush administration. The author of the "update" section of this article makes a few questionable assertions but his overall point is fair enough.

Other interesting items discussed include: Video and Audio propaganda produced by the White House and corporations that pass as real news on TV and radio stations and lack of safety against terror attacks at chemical plants. Two articles seem to be centerpieces of the book. The first laboriously tries to prove that the Republicans stole the White House in 2004. The second points out problems with the official story about 9-11 and implies some conclusions that I think are unwarranted at this point.. Greg Palast in the last article discusses the Bush draft dodging/Dan Rather buffoonery.

22 of 28 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars If The Majority Are Unaware Of A Crime, Then ....Did It Really Happen?, November 25, 2005

By 

Sunshine Greeny (The Wonderful World of Colonized Minds) - See all my reviews

This review is from: Censored 2006: The Top 25 Censored Stories (Paperback)

"They could be made to accept the most flagrant violations of reality...and were not sufficiently interested in public events to notice what was happening." ~ Orwell, 1984

You are being to lied to at every turn. Truth is dismissed as propaganda, while propaganda is presented as truth. It's been this way for so long that most people aren't capable or willing to examine it. It's too alien, unfamiliar. Project Censored helps by serving as a counterbalance.

How could so many be part of what would have to be a broad, intricate "conspiracy" to lie to the public? ..people ask. It's complex, not always black and white, and largely has taken root through the individual's internalization of self-serving, illusory truths and facts as doing so is seen as benefitial for advancement, wealth and social status. "That's just how it is," is the resounding collective concession, not willing, of course, to likewise concede that dire problems long ignored invariably courts disaster. Regulated media through corporate consolidation, and Orwellian "de-regulation" policies = the demise of democracy.

Naturally, if, from birth, a person is indoctrinated into a system of beliefs and values, that is, a 'worldview,' via mass media, that reinforces highly deceptive perceptions of self, society, and state, than to address those views with fact-based skepticism is akin to pulling a rug out from underneath those whose propagandized perceptions constitute the very fabric of their consciousness ...so, it's little wonder why many won't or don't want to face the magnitude of the truth, and instead attack the messenger.

People will always take mental shortcuts, and if the encouraged daily round of living, through example, doesn't permit or condone critical thinking, reading, research, ability and confidence to voice views beyond that which they have been strategically 'instructed' to abide, you end up with this bizarre experiment that we have in the U.S.: constitutional strongholds that permit many rights and liberties for all, yet, a majority that take those rights for granted to the extent that when broad, unprecedented measures are taken to eliminate and subvert those rights and march us toward a closed, totalitarian society, they fail to acknowledge that it's actually happening ...because they're unable to see it.

They can't see it because the all-reaching media apparatus assures them it isn't so. And if their disbelief persists, they'll have to take on some thick skin as they'll be personally attacked and shouted-down. And once someone becomes a somewhat established dissident, the facts and views she/he brings are routinely ignored, because the personal attacks brought against them only misdirect away from those views and facts for so long.

If you're skeptical of the lies being sold, you're largely considered an enemy, a malcontent, and within establishment rhetoric and policy[Patriot Act], are on par with "the terrorists." One doesn't have to look too far back into history to understand the strategy of that level of social engineering.

It's clear as to why the Powers That Be strategically implemented the never-ending 24/7 "news" cycle vis a vis cable "news;" incessently repeat the propaganda, thus ensuring a stranglehold on perceptions of "reality." From there, the herd polices itself. Like Chomsky says, the more you frighten the populace over tweaked crime stats, welfare mothers and drug addicts, the more you control everybody.

The Project Censored group realize this all too well. Try asking some of those you know if they've ever even heard of them ...."huh, were they on Star Search last night?" Exactly. Yet, year after year, they diligently release volume upon volume of collected information that *should* serve as a clear, loud WARNING. There are some aspects of existence that we may never have definitive answers for, but the facts, the reality, of how a supposedly open democracy runs itself, and the instruments used to inform its citizenry in ways of ensuring properly informed, healthy civic interaction, is so crucial, so plain to see, that it is disheartening, if not unnerving, to see all the power in the wrong hands, and scores of people who, like many others less fortunate yet more wary, are the literal victims of those in power, vehemently supporting the degredation.

I hope more people will read this book, including the entire long running series, for a clearer understanding of how "reality" is meticulously managed within our illusory "democracy." Kudos to Project Censored!

[...]