1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Charley's War, November 23, 2008
This review is from: Charley's War (Vol. 5): Return to the Front (Hardcover)
Charley's War should be required reading. It is, to a literate audience, what Mash is/was to North American readers.
Mills and Colquhoun hit on all cylinders this book as Charley Bourne returns to the front only to find himself working under a cruel and heartless commander. Lieutenant Snell and Charley met the previous year, and it was not a memorable moment. His first impression of Snell as a man after only his own reputation was bang on, and once he is assigned to Charleys' unit, his blatant disregard is obvious. As Charley finds out when two men are killed by a sniper so Snell can have a canteen of water, and men are jailed for drinking without permission, and an old sargeant is disbarred under ridiculous circumstances, the men have little respect for him as well. A well cooked meal of rat (instead of rabbit) goes a long way to dispel a little dismay.
War is hell. This book clearly shows the real side of the war that is not shown, nor discussed. Shell shock, cruel commanders, pranksters who get people killed, and the merciful and obedient who pay the ulitmate price for poor decisions.
Joe Colquhouns' art is spectacular! His portrayal of the trenches and battlefield conditions are apalling at best. If this book were in color, it just might be an EC comic just before they were banned!
Many have said it, and I will do so again. This is a classic, and it should be required reading for students around the world. Going to war is no walk in the park. Troop conditions, especially in WWI, were atrocious. If the Hun didn't get you, the dysentery or conditions would.
Charley's War is amazing. God bless Mills and the late Colquhoun for creating this strip. If it saves one life...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
charlie's war, February 21, 2009
This review is from: Charley's War (Vol. 5): Return to the Front (Hardcover)
great series of books,brought back memories of the "battle"magazine i used to read growing up in nz in the 70's.charlies war was my favourite,excellent artwork and realistic stories,not glorifiying war in any way,but as it was.
took awile to get here as 1st copy went missing enroute,but well worth the wait.would recommend to anyone interested in ww1 history or comic strips
mike zeier,new plymouth,nz
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lovely detail makes for an unusually well done, complex story, January 9, 2009
This review is from: Charley's War (Vol. 5): Return to the Front (Hardcover)
UK comics writer Pat Mills and artist Joe Colquhoun provide a fine military graphic novel highly recommended for any military library and many a collection specializing in graphic novels. In 1916 one Charley lies about his age to enlist and flight on the battlefields of France. Recovering after battle, Charley has been resting in the UK and returns to the front lines only to find some of his comrades are as dangerous as the Germans they are fighting. Lovely detail makes for an unusually well done, complex story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No