From Publishers Weekly
Wealthy American widow Ruth Harkness became famous in 1936 for bringing the first live giant panda to the United States, but little has been known about the two Chinese-American hunters who led Harkness on her trek through the Sichuan mountains in search of the panda. Kiefer, a freelance writer and former Outside magazine editor, tells the story of Quentin and Jack Young, dashing naturalists and adventurers. Kiefer first met Quentin in the late 1980s and spoke with both brothers (by then estranged), though he spent more time with Quentin. At the time of the expedition, the Young brothers and Harkness knew little about pandas (Quentin actually admits that he hated them), and Kiefer doesn't whitewash the cruelty of their mission. In the 1930s, only a handful of Westerners had seen these animals, and swashbucklers such as Theodore Roosevelt's sons, Ted Jr. and Kermit, had made a sport of hunting them. Once Chicago's Brookfield Zoo bought Harkness's panda, other zoos began to covet their own specimens, setting off a legacy of panda hunting that led to the animals' becoming endangered. At the same time, the author obviously admires Quentin, though he's aware how unfashionable and morally dubious his lifestyle as a hunter is considered today. As he puts it, "Quentin Young is the last specimen of an endangered species: the early twentieth century explorer-adventurer-naturalist." Readers interested in either this or the more traditional kind of endangered species will enjoy this well-researched, nuanced tale.
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Adult/High School-The excitement and, depending on readers' sensitivity about hunting, the gore that surrounded one panda's journey from its natural habitat to an Illinois zoo in 1936 are part of this story. The true tale, however, lies in the relationship of those doing the chasing, in particular, Quentin Young, a neophyte naturalist in China who was challenged by his older brother, Jack Young, a celebrated expeditionist, to build a reputation by guiding an American woman through the bamboo thickets in Sichuan to capture the animal. Gutsy Ruth Harkness got a baby panda, fodder for a book, the drive to be a lifelong adventurer, and a broken heart after a month with Quentin. Personal interviews and solid research about the individuals before, during, and many years after the "chase" contribute to this captivating biography. YAs will see how nationality, politics, economics, and even sibling rivalry can make or break a person, and how time can tame one's outlook. Teens who tune in to "Biography," Animal Planet, or the History Channel will eagerly turn the pages and stare hard at the black-and-white photos, typical of the era, to find evidence of the melodrama described. A trip to the zoo will take on new meaning.
Karen Sokol, Fairfax County Public Schools, VACopyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.