Customer Reviews

Chattel or Person?: The Status of Women in the Mishnah

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Wegner tries to understand the status of woman as given in the Mishnah. Her major point is that it is by and large determined by her sexual status. A minor girl is under the authority of her father, a married woman under that of her husband. The father can sell the daughter to her prospective husband. The wife must undergo the trial of 'Sotah' at suspicion of infidelity, whereas there is no such demand of the husband.
Wenger claims that women , such as the girl who attains adult status, the divorcee, who are not under the sexual jurisdiction of a man have prerogatives and freedom.
Wenger too points out however the privileges and respect the system gives to women, the way the Torah protects the woman by such means as Ketubbah, and by the Halachic demands made upon the husband to provide for his wife's sexual needs, her food and clothing, her standard of living at least as high as it was previously.
Wegner says that women in the Mishnah have mixed status often, combining elements of being chattel and of being independent respected persons.

Knowing the complexities associated with studying Jewish Law, especially those laws based on gender, this book is an asset to you library.

Wegner explains these laws, offers a variety of Rabbinic commentaries throughout the centuries as well as modern day feminist interpretations and arguments. Her easy to follow commentary makes understanding the history of the Mishnah and purpose of these laws a comprehendable process for the professor as well as the students of the Mishnah. I would highly recommend adding this book to your library, preferably in hardback, seeing how you will refer to it time and time again.

I've returned to this book over and over again in my work as a writer and a rabbi. It remains important and relevant!