26 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very nice execution of a risky concept. Buy it if you have few cookbooks., November 11, 2005
This review is from: Chef, Interrupted: Delicious Chefs' Recipes That You Can Actually Make at Home (Hardcover)
`Chef, Interrupted' by leading cookbook co-author, Melissa Clark is a better than average collection of recipes from a very large number (more than the 26 named on the cover) of prominent chefs from around the country, ranging from Batali, Bouley, Boulud, and Colicchio in New York City to Judy Rodgers in San Francisco to Norman Van Aken in Miami to Charlie Trotter in Chicago to Tom Douglas in Seattle.
The factor which makes this better than a simple collection of recipes from famous chefs is the fact that the recipes are simplified and stated by a single expert culinary writer, backed by a single team of recipe testers. This immediately makes the book more valuable than your average collection from diverse sources such as the recent `Today Show' collection of recipes from the TV show talent and various `visiting fireman' chefs, including many of the same names such as Batali and Boulud.
But, one must ask, is this book really worth it. If I apply my `one good recipe' rule, it passes on the strength of a Bobby Flay recipe for the Spanish Tortilla (potato frittata). It's not as if I don't already have a good half dozen recipes for this dish, but Flay spices it up with garlic and embellishes it with bell peppers, a very traditional Spanish ingredient.
Daniel Boulud's blurb on the back of the dust jacket hits upon the primary value of the book. It contains lots of recipes whose innate values and high name recognition sources will easily impress. For a less than standard $35 list price, you get recipes from practically every recognized chef in the country without having to buy forty different books with forty different styles of presenting recipes.
This largely answers the question about the book for those who have three cookbooks, but what about those of us who already own cookbooks done by half the collaborators for this book. I checked `East of Paris', the book with which Clark collaborated with David Bouley and found that neither of the recipes in Clark's book were in the Bouley / Clark collaboration. This leads me to believe that most, if not all of the recipes in this book are new to this book, although the author makes no statement to that effect. At the very least, their statement is new to this book.
One problem with this book is that we loose some of the aspects that make the chefs' work original. Since we can still buy their books, this is a small concession.
While the cover announces that these are recipes you can actually make at home, no not take this as a claim of being `fast' or `easy'. Most take over an hour and most also take a fairly large ingredient list.
My only objection to the style of the book is that some recipe names should have been translated, as with Jonathan Waxman's `Pollo al Forno with Panzanella'. Foodies will recognize it as baked chicken with a bread salad, but the translation would have been good for the non-foodies, since it is that audience for which the book is best suited.
I like the fact that the author didn't feel compelled to add chapters on making stocks, dressings, or other pantry items, especially as every contributing chef probably does it in a different way anyway.
For what it does, this is a superior book, much better than any other omnibus book I can think of, such as some from the Food Network Kitchens, but you will have to carefully weigh whether it adds value to your cookbook collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Chef Whisperer, November 12, 2005
This review is from: Chef, Interrupted: Delicious Chefs' Recipes That You Can Actually Make at Home (Hardcover)
This is a chef cookbook without the heartache. It's got at least two "wows" going for it - it's a very broad sampler of of great chef recipes, and it makes innovative dishes accessible to those of us who don't have 2 days to build a sauce. Chef Interrupted is full of inventive recipes that an employed person, with a decently-equipped kitchen and a good supermarket, can make with total success.
The recipes are startlingly delicious. Steak with spiced coconut sauce? Tomato and watermelon salad with ricotta?? Rosemary polenta pound cake??? I was attracted to the weird stuff first, and it was simple and delicious to make. I can tell you my girlfriend was delighted. I'm a good cook though not an adventurous one, and this book's an inspiration. There are more conventional dishes too, and I'm getting new ideas from each one. I thought the shortcuts might dull the food down, but generally they allow the core idea of the dish to come through even stronger. I haven't found a clunker yet. It's such fun to try the new stuff that I'm cooking at home more just so I can see what happens next.
When chefs do cookbooks they go to dizzy heights I can't always follow, and speak a language I only half understand. Clark teases out their passion and motives and translates them without dumbing them down. The notes are practical and amusing. She has a genius for catching the spark and essence of both the chef and the dish. Even the cover photo shows this (though you don't totally get it till you see the photo on page 265). If The Babbo Cookbook makes you the famished fly on the wall of Batali's kitchen, then Chef Interrupted flies you to forty kitchens where a charming and brilliant interpreter helps you get your hands on some real food.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One Great Recipe After Another, October 23, 2005
This review is from: Chef, Interrupted: Delicious Chefs' Recipes That You Can Actually Make at Home (Hardcover)
I just got this book as a gift from a friend and I've already made two of the recipes -- rack of lamb w/cumin and salt crust (YUM!) and pizza with garlic pesto and ricotto (more YUM!). i usually don't make pizza at home, but this was ttally doable -- and delicious - and the lamb was too easy and so sophisticated and wonderful. The tips from the chefs and the writer are really useful -- and there are drink tips that i found really helpful, too. It was a great gift and I'd highly recommend it for any enthusiastic home cook/foodie.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No